{ "tranche": "tranche239", "assessed": 39, "estimated": 0, "new_calibration_points": 0, "statuses": { "unsupported_design": 38, "design_review": 1 }, "categories": { "randomized_trial": 8, "design_review": 1, "not_did": 9, "instrumental_variables": 6, "nonbinary_treatment": 15 }, "measured_treatment_columns": 29, "note": "Completion means source-design assessment, not successful re-estimation. Criteria are provisional; incompatible targets are not coerced into binary DiD.", "papers": [ { "paper_id": "aeraej-175", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Subdistricts are randomized to incentivized, nonincentivized or control block-grant arms. The indicator-pooled health/education effects remain experimental; key analysis inputs are unavailable." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-130", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "CMTO housing-search services are randomly assigned. The high-opportunity lease-up contrast is experimental and its confidential household inputs are not deposited." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-76", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Habitat infrastructure is randomly assigned to urban polygons. The two-period polygon fixed-effects DiD estimates an experimental ITT, excluded by the current observational-extension rule." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-621", "status": "design_review", "category": "design_review", "reason": "The source regresses second-difference log assets on temporary 401(k) ineligibility. This is plausibly DiD-related, but the collapsed target is not a levels-on-adoption ATT. Reconstruct and review the original eligibility/time paths before admitting a template comparison; do not infer permanent ineligibility from the descriptive label." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-84", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The transit-opening specification uses a time discontinuity with cubic trends and weather/hour controls. The binary opening indicator alone does not supply the template untreated comparison group." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-494", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The public target computes intergenerational-mobility bounds and distributional summaries. These are not treatment-adoption effects; an appendix regression does not replace the main estimand." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-138", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The supplied empirical targets concern gasoline-price cycles, alignment and margins. There is no selected binary treatment with an adoption/control contrast for this template." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-410", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The selected regression is cross-sectional village-level y on inverse network distance Dist_inv, with village clustering. It has no treatment timing or before/after comparison." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-415", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The village labor-supply elasticity is estimated using randomized wage offers. lnwage has multiple doses; village/week fixed effects do not make it observational binary DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-329", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Polluting firms are randomized across public/private complaint arms and control. The seven-arm field experiment and violation-triggered interventions remain experimental." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-439", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Marriage-market exposures are instrumented with predicted immigrant shares and sex ratios. Fixed effects and first-stage regressions do not provide a binary-adoption DiD target." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-414", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The gubernatorial-party design relies on close-election RD, retaining vote-margin polynomials and interactions. The Democratic-winner indicator is binary, but the identification is not the template adoption DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-235", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The full contraceptive-subsidy arm is randomly assigned by clinic catchment. Treatment effects are experimental arm comparisons, not observational adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-536", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The public targets are unemployment-exhaustion consumption profiles and structural model/calibration results, not a treated-versus-control DiD coefficient. Confidential household transaction data are also absent." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-219", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Press-release effects use a fuzzy RD/IV around region-period penalty cutoffs. Restricted OSHA inputs are absent; a binary release indicator would not remove the RD/IV identifying assumptions." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-94", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The one-step dynamic referendum estimator uses close-election RD and many lagged vote outcomes/running-variable polynomials. Its ten-year lincom is not the binary-adoption ATT estimated by this template." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-154", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The source x_0 is the change in the number of daily newspapers, not a binary entry event. The turnout equation is a count-exposure panel event-study target; thresholding changes its estimand." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-493", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The target is a temperature response curve represented by eleven temperature-bin indicators. A vector of dose bins is not a binary treatment, and games are not absorbing policy adopters." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-149", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The main agriculture targets are IV/OLS effects of continuous predicted sulfate exposure. Public binary Phase-1 emissions event studies are supplementary policy figures, not substitutes for the main crop-yield estimand; prepared agricultural analysis panels are missing." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-196", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "s_Indicator distinguishes specialist from nonspecialist lobbyists in a pooled congress-effects regression of opposite-party connections. It is a binary characteristic, not a policy adoption or pre/post treatment." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-250", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Handwashing incentives and monitoring are experimentally assigned across six arms. The selected I1-versus-control comparison is randomized, not observational adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-136", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "predyield1 is continuous country-specific predicted agricultural-yield exposure. Country/year effects estimate a dose coefficient, not a binary-adoption ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-71", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The main cluster-productivity application combines continuous cluster-density exposure and IV. Secondary Rochester/Kodak binary-shock specifications do not replace that mixed design under the current rule; their analysis data are also unavailable." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-531", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The asylum-grant regression uses continuous case-day temperature temp6t4 with rich fixed effects. Temperature shocks are not binary absorbing adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-129", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The selected import-value equation uses the continuous tariff-change interaction dltariffCHNOASIAtreat. NewTariff coding or a China indicator is not the whole treatment regressor; it is not thresholded." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-128", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "TreatImp and TreatExp are continuous import/export tariff-reduction exposures interacted with the NAFTA period. The design is continuous-treatment DiD, outside this binary-treatment template rather than invalid DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-217", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "num_exper_upgrades_st_cum is a cumulative count of machine-upgrade trials. The firm/semiannual fixed-effects coefficient is a dose effect, not binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-47", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The patent PPML DiD uses foreign_per_64 interacted with post as a continuous exposure. The deposited state exposure aggregate is not the required crop-year patent panel; no exposure threshold is imposed." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-328", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "Race-by-decade indicators trace changes in racial wage gaps with rich individual/composition effects. Race is not a policy adoption, and a collection of binary interaction columns does not create the template intervention." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-330", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "House-price exposure enters OLS/IV marriage-market specifications using geographic/age-linked instruments. It is continuous exposure with an IV strategy, not binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-132", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "nexposure is standardized industry import-competition exposure in the unionization regression. Its continuous variation is retained conceptually, not recoded into treated/untreated industries." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-333", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Lagged enforcement fine counts are instrumented by lagged DETER cloud cover. This is a continuous-intensity panel IV design, not binary-adoption DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-3", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The flooding regressions use continuous wetland changes and related exposure terms in panel/long-difference specifications. Wetland acreage changes are not a binary treatment." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-143", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "logret is the continuous log top net-of-tax retention rate in inventor-location regressions. The tax elasticity is not a binary policy-adoption ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-326", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Vehicle monitoring is randomly assigned to Kenyan matatu firms. Six assignment-by-study-month effects remain experimental, not observational staggered adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-142", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The migration equation uses the continuous origin-destination log net-of-tax differential ATR_p99_diff_log. Varying tax doses are not replaced by binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-508", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The selected occupation-level first-difference regression uses dval, the continuous change in the long-hours wage premium. It is not a binary intervention or adoption panel." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-90", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "BIPhypgoldpriceOUTLA interacts high-South-Asian exposure with a continuously varying gold-price index. The binary exposure component alone is not the treatment; the source target is continuous-exposure DDD/TWFE." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-322", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The stacked recession event studies use continuous local recession severity. The generated CBSA/CZ analysis panels are also absent; recession dates do not make the severity treatment binary." } ] }