{ "tranche": "tranche200", "assessed": 50, "estimated": 0, "new_calibration_points": 0, "statuses": { "unsupported_design": 50 }, "categories": { "not_did": 7, "randomized_trial": 21, "nonbinary_treatment": 3, "instrumental_variables": 19 }, "measured_treatment_columns": 45, "note": "Completion means source-design assessment, not successful re-estimation. Criteria are provisional; incompatible targets are not coerced into binary DiD.", "papers": [ { "paper_id": "aeraej-543", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The supplied target decomposes SNAP enrollment, eligibility and spending changes; it is not an outcome-on-binary-adoption regression. Required SNAP QC preparation inputs are also missing." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-220", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Home-energy-report receipt is experimentally assigned. Recipient-by-billing-cycle effects and the compliance-IV robustness lane remain experimental, not observational DiD. Utility and survey microdata are NDA-restricted." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-608", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "Table 4 regresses budget delay on the continuous year-over-year unemployment-rate change unemp_diff, with state effects. Binary political controls do not turn that exposure coefficient into a binary-policy ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-116", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The source uses RD/RK and IV variation to instrument continuous loan_amount, including a DiD-style instrument in Appendix Table 1. The loan-level analysis_file.dta is absent; an IV interaction is not an observational binary-treatment ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-85", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The laboratory study compares human/human, human/robot and feedback treatment arms. Its selection-game outcomes are experimental contrasts, not policy-adoption DiD effects." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-460", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The headline instruments changes in low-English Hispanic enrollment share with the predicted immigration shock inst_sca. This is a cross-sectional IV in long differences, not binary policy adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-350", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Voucher-by-subsidy-period effects and network spillovers come from randomized input subsidies in Mozambique. Village-round fixed effects do not change the experimental assignment design." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-587", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The fiscal multiplier instruments public-investment growth G with compulsory-administration shocks CD_S1 and L1CD_S2 after province/year residualization. Binary instruments are not the continuous endogenous treatment." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-50", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The paper combines laboratory experiments and an Olympiad cutoff design. Gender/session contrasts and randomized feedback do not supply an observational treatment-adoption panel." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-547", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The empirical target uses the unemployment-benefit schedule kink and DD-RKD; the public R target reproduces structural calibration artifacts. Neither is the template binary-adoption ATT, and confidential register microdata are absent." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-506", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The Reply reports a nonlinear firm-owner incidence share built from four continuous business-tax-shock coefficients and structural parameters. Substituting a binary tax-change indicator would change both treatment and estimand." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-555", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Online enrollment is instrumented by offer-by-distance-to-campus. Binary online enrollment does not make the identifying IV design observational DiD; the student analysis inputs are also restricted." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-111", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Anonymous resumes are randomly assigned; offer fixed effects and treatment-by-applicant-group interactions estimate experimental contrasts, not an adoption-time DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-156", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The lab-in-field contract-enforcement experiment estimates game-condition interactions with network distance. Individual effects and repeated game rounds do not identify a policy-adoption DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-49", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The public-visibility by Trump-won-information contrast is a randomized 2-by-2 survey experiment. A factorial interaction is not an observational before/after DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-617", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "nonbinary_treatment", "reason": "The target is continuous monthly government advertising expenditure in a newspaper/month fixed-effects regression of corruption coverage. No binary exposure is substituted." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-379", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Early-life exposure dp1 derives from the school-level randomized deworming program. Age-at-exposure and survey-cohort controls do not change that experimental source of identification." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-406", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Judicial-vacancy effects use judge deaths and pension-eligibility-based predicted vacancy spells in OLS/2SLS. Actual court-capacity exposure is fractional, and the required case-level outcome data are not deposited." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-583", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Cost-equalization grants are instrumented by the grant-formula discontinuity Dforcing1. The grant-amount effect is RD/IV, not the effect of binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-17", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Firm access to finance is randomly assigned; interpost estimates its direct pre/post effect and inter4post captures continuous competitor spillovers. The pre/post form does not make this observational DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-554", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Report cards are assigned experimentally. The selected school-fee regression is a treatment/control ANCOVA with baseline fees and district effects, not observational policy adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-277", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Table 5 relates premiums to continuous current/lagged low-income-subsidy enrollment shares; the paper also uses market-level IV specifications. This mixed design is not a binary-adoption ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-141", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Highway grants per capita are instrumented with lagged road-formula variables in a cross-state fiscal-response regression. Neither continuous grant exposure nor its instruments are binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-73", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Geographic spending multipliers instrument stimulus outlays with pre-recession allocation measures. These cross-state IV/long-difference coefficients are not binary-treatment DiD effects." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-32", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Community monitoring is randomly assigned. The selected mortality regression compares treatment and control with district effects; it remains an experimental contrast." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-228", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The change in federal revenue per pupil is instrumented by the 1960 poverty share fracpoor60. Long differences and county clustering do not replace the IV identifying assumption with binary DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-70", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Capital grants are assigned by lottery; the headline interacts winning with peer-ranked ability. The randomized treatment and heterogeneity interaction are not observational adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-293", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Consumer spending is regressed on stimulus-payment dollars esp instrumented by the receipt indicator iesp. The binary receipt instrument must not be substituted for the continuous endogenous regressor." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-137", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Police-station intervention arms and training intensity are experimentally assigned. percenttrained_post is a multivalued dose; within-station pre/post estimation remains experimental." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-225", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The paper uses sailing-versus-steam travel-time instruments in gravity/trade and income equations. The supplied OLS travel-time regression is not a binary-adoption DiD substitute for that design." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-234", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The civic-education intervention is a school-level cluster RCT. The public prepared target is descriptive; missing panelized student/teacher files do not justify treating it as observational DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-389", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The selected target is a cross-sectional regression of elicited Social Security risk premia on perceived benefit uncertainty sdben and survey controls. There is no before/after treatment-comparison panel." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-535", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "The wage-subsidy voucher is randomly assigned. Voucher-by-round dynamic effects remain experimental even though the data contain pre/during/post periods and firm effects." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-140", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The headline is long-difference 2SLS of local outcomes on Chinese import exposure d_tradeusch_pw, instrumented by other-country import exposure. The treatment is continuous, not a binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-83", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The child-benefit specification is a discontinuity in time around July 2007 with separate cubic trends. post is binary, but the supplied design has no untreated contemporaneous DiD group." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-342", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Doctors and mid-level providers are randomly assigned to clinics. The doctor coefficient is an experimental arm contrast with randomization-stratum effects." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-210", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "School block grants are experimentally assigned. The selected Year-1 test-score regression compares grant and feedback-control arms with baseline scores, not observational adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-628", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "wk2 is the recurring Saturday/Sunday indicator shared by resorts. Resort and week effects identify a weekend reporting contrast, not staggered adoption with a contemporaneously untreated group." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-591", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Topographic hydropower potential instruments electricity infrastructure. The supplied first-stage coefficient and main IV effects cannot be reinterpreted as a binary electrification ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-107", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "Textbook-funding eligibility is assigned at the API-score cutoff. The source retains the running variable and side-specific slopes; this is an RD rather than the adoption-panel template." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-287", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Oil output per capita is continuous; it enters reduced-form regressions and instruments municipal revenue in the main IV design. Geographic allocation instruments do not create a binary-treatment DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-95", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The aid-growth design instruments lagged Chinese official-finance exposure with historical recipient propensities and global supply shifters. It is panel IV with continuous exposure, not binary adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-108", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "assigned_p1 is randomized microenterprise-support assignment. The selected endline ITT with baseline controls remains an experiment, not an observational DiD." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-20", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Depression pharmacotherapy is randomized across four arms. Treatment-by-survey-round ANCOVA effects remain experimental; no artificial adoption panel is constructed." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-584", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The paper uses close-election/IV specifications for women politicians and child mortality. The supplied binned first-stage relationship is not an observational binary-adoption ATT." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-620", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "The selected house-value regression uses continuous changes in immigrant shares in decadal differences, and the paper also reports IV specifications. This mixed design is not the binary-adoption target." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-533", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "instrumental_variables", "reason": "Trade growth is instrumented by time-varying geography/predicted trade measures in GDP-growth regressions. Continuous trade exposure is not binary policy adoption." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-448", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "not_did", "reason": "The target links aggregate volatility to fundamental volatility var3 in a country panel. There is no policy treatment, adoption date or treated-versus-comparison intervention." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-268", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Improved cooking stoves are offered by randomized lottery. Rolling lottery dates and household panels do not change the experimental assignment design." }, { "paper_id": "aeraej-256", "status": "unsupported_design", "category": "randomized_trial", "reason": "Agricultural market entry subsidies are randomized. Both the S2 reduced form and the IV for entrant counts derive from that experiment, not observational adoption." } ] }