{ "config": { "view": { "continuousWidth": 300, "continuousHeight": 300, "stroke": null }, "axis": { "domainColor": "#A0ABB4", "gridColor": "#E5E9ED", "gridWidth": 0.6, "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "labelPadding": 5, "tickColor": "#A0ABB4", "titleColor": "#172B3A", "titleFontSize": 14, "titleFontWeight": "normal", "titlePadding": 12 }, "background": "white", "font": "DejaVu Sans", "legend": { "columnPadding": 18, "columns": 4, "direction": "horizontal", "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "offset": 24, "orient": "bottom", "rowPadding": 7, "symbolLimit": 1000, "symbolOpacity": 1, "symbolSize": 45, "symbolType": "circle" }, "title": { "color": "#172B3A" } }, "layer": [ { "data": { "values": [ { "start": -5, "end": 5 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#343E47", "strokeDash": [ 5, 4 ], "strokeWidth": 1.1 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "x2": { "field": "end" }, "y": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "y2": { "field": "end" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "y": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.3885253830076921, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 3.4147827899666137, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5288892869379433, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7528002318625951, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 3.4147827899666137, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7528; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.3328428430090348, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 2.4813782064818644, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7520064855512179, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40501845027573946, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 2.4813782064818644, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.405; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.385059491047323, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 3.1121304142542905, "se_normalized_difference": -0.025394052809753983, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47578789224074497, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 3.1121304142542905, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4758; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.20535587329137728, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.9403105956474556, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20629487713198497, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4755457444652286, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.9403105956474556, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4755; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.35038915647090907, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 3.6672865385561884, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4501909985412788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4912213849296376, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 3.6672865385561884, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4912; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.22224621433890407, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4105115212167811, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22319664872739578, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16584271954927018, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4105115212167811, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1658; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.42594215301119437, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 3.063135126493506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6077352836076337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 3.063135126493506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.0636290695671966, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.47601221502014696, "se_normalized_difference": 0.30256851691010567, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6238759371413234, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.47601221502014696, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6239; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.06153564561861635, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 0.6641303289063571, "se_normalized_difference": 0.28850940807882325, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9007339476341801, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 0.6641303289063571, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9007; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.2860739583907882, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.5245967953100297, "se_normalized_difference": 1.111778291083094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.744755025448304, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.5245967953100297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7448; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": -0.07239225849517301, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": -0.8438784517311982, "se_normalized_difference": -1.6804077637082337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1883135791121969, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": -0.8438784517311982, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1883; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": 0.2604059077160187, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": 2.7656284795470314, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0880875836783972, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7555106259415197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": 2.7656284795470314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7555; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.11764988087499709, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.883643182599003, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3382433676435073, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8775181204600441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.883643182599003, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8775; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.08860159710440971, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 0.9719592159911877, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31164434620889925, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11053990821571197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 0.9719592159911877, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1105; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": -0.10398415086730348, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": -1.0277453468056132, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4194402699439226, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6613097442013468, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": -1.0277453468056132, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.17528994011918686, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.579283320391719, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9192786009535644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8426154697309903, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.579283320391719, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.06328050733614857, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 0.6347730868317343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6451137650494003, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.904975638165574, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 0.6347730868317343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.039867497536061294, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.393115506998779, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4617745654598037, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9224037401332055, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.393115506998779, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9224; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 1.651153141158054, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22967394938499702, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 1.651153141158054, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.1685790387984038, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 1.8258833684449844, "se_normalized_difference": 0.27500155858422975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.12359234733591484, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 1.8258833684449844, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1236; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.04003771997148135, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 0.4431815934837828, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8604278797423379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8852716493371069, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 0.4431815934837828, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8853; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 1.2949695075512722, "se_normalized_difference": -0.39946129871962477, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 1.2949695075512722, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.5524011544647354, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 4.982732437148825, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1005293228826023, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.01714325715860586, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 4.982732437148825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01714; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.1065328086513135, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -1.014751306568505, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4016095808936353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9650240752385251, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -1.014751306568505, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.965; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": 0.2006988537785288, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": 1.612275723179677, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5748925503596426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6742386532450715, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": 1.612275723179677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6742; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": 0.06975588945735992, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": 0.4730545873038456, "se_normalized_difference": -0.578305632692984, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8493619630133346, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": 0.4730545873038456, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.24343173113939617, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 2.1429167471879733, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12928298396029417, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.368668192626714, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 2.1429167471879733, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3687; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": 0.22087079811454136, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": 1.6320398924198933, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5537940866718213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": 1.6320398924198933, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 2.448405761746198, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1714667306431985, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 2.448405761746198, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0894488186393951, "se_normalized_difference": -0.049675814622635504, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0894488186393951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.1508950291473108, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -2.3110066391030823, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2759274864151426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09612628893524412, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -2.3110066391030823, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.20707550078154957, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.3262722628899362, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2557703864165844, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3428608116390395, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.3262722628899362, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.11579504661744161, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 1.0937022099197315, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5151283473619641, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6833402896734146, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 1.0937022099197315, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1085905496696486, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.0565407513080447, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2346447510359829, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.05372630452950017, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.0565407513080447, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.12334687831889027, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.080433657834606, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22961822897067982, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.080433657834606, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": -0.021588580009078137, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": -0.15510186540209908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.022122764010544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": -0.15510186540209908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.2200701629813498, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -1.8561175264468608, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7136746991547429, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5312685394334519, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -1.8561175264468608, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5313; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": 0.019629505394895136, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": 0.15288052365790902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2693180289941803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.35019378980996957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": 0.15288052365790902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": -0.18143225297181387, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": -1.3874157380204908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2610500940171219, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.44892433741068394, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": -1.3874157380204908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4489; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": -0.1972046536126607, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": -1.3696511938562184, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6484590274995803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": -1.3696511938562184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.06076953126919374, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -0.5599313788877915, "se_normalized_difference": -0.014511269968484064, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6140200715446021, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -0.5599313788877915, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.614; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.08678442257440994, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.663058341854694, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8057170383258024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5307579151547169, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.663058341854694, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5308; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": 0.08080864784158243, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": 0.7545368107908907, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18806120158701928, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0502924517983174, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": 0.7545368107908907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05029; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.13312774663920757, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 1.37254658344467, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5497262605136766, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0384481776614768, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 1.37254658344467, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03845; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": 1.036530243767059, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0835143109148764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": 1.036530243767059, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.11748987923104534, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 0.7922914922158757, "se_normalized_difference": -0.006987762485435748, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.08317218243244932, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 0.7922914922158757, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.08317; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": -0.006545688292584825, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": -0.04810912669492938, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1143899187070034, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8156953081194223, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": -0.04810912669492938, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8157; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 0.49425217077821487, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6924049321882342, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 0.49425217077821487, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.06203785992970153, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -0.6726159239003874, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9228038799524354, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -0.6726159239003874, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P062", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3008887212720041, "modern": 0.3473935080976446, "twfe_se": 0.31083588666172546, "x": 0.9679986584028292, "y": 1.1176106846237603, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1496120262209312, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6998373490996154, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9679986584028292, "display_y": 1.1176106846237603, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P063", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.49306361679116867, "modern": 0.6471186994364466, "twfe_se": 0.18166472287589872, "x": 2.714140692730955, "y": 3.562159395572442, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8480187028414876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9989912166654179, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.714140692730955, "display_y": 3.562159395572442, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P064", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13450188332648486, "modern": -0.06464438569611686, "twfe_se": 0.4167804498641, "x": 0.3227163926963033, "y": -0.15510416987455988, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4778205625708632, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06784394081766397, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3227163926963033, "display_y": -0.15510416987455988, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06784; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P065", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658198080855093, "modern": -0.12842303879624975, "twfe_se": 0.4081892333040155, "x": -0.5305920958656024, "y": -0.3146164286518588, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21597566721374353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8829318262431582, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5305920958656024, "display_y": -0.3146164286518588, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8829; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P066", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13997365996268946, "modern": 0.1807103456031524, "twfe_se": 0.20009060583611854, "x": 0.6995513826237947, "y": 0.9031425780736589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20359119544986423, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8155361799666327, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6995513826237947, "display_y": 0.9031425780736589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8155; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P067", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4448736019775512, "modern": 0.34165081521349516, "twfe_se": 0.28926475842925403, "x": 1.53794608231322, "y": 1.1811007226345316, "se_normalized_difference": -0.35684535967868836, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8251925142753511, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.53794608231322, "display_y": 1.1811007226345316, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8252; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P068", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5483851615815729, "modern": 0.5148405121812912, "twfe_se": 0.27592838943462955, "x": 1.9874184120930816, "y": 1.8658482848980735, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12157012719500823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6503824307717044, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9874184120930816, "display_y": 1.8658482848980735, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6504; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P069", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18640506753037372, "modern": -0.5597970757619195, "twfe_se": 0.3193859691436377, "x": -0.5836357433927901, "y": -1.752729079686533, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1690933362937428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4502524658648966, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5836357433927901, "display_y": -1.752729079686533, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4503; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P070", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18520047564986342, "modern": 0.012421380811847016, "twfe_se": 0.39534645345353947, "x": -0.46845108646365513, "y": 0.03141897620009068, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4998700626637458, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4205575876619039, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.46845108646365513, "display_y": 0.03141897620009068, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4206; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P071", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22194506642235692, "modern": 0.38764788926886995, "twfe_se": 0.24948117419673407, "x": -0.8896265104449809, "y": 1.5538161968212534, "se_normalized_difference": 2.443442707266234, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8641356346203798, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8896265104449809, "display_y": 1.5538161968212534, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8641; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P072", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04440438154510488, "modern": 0.16878837243409034, "twfe_se": 0.2581006713311633, "x": 0.1720428750382078, "y": 0.653963321999739, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48192044696153113, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.030267294207242283, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1720428750382078, "display_y": 0.653963321999739, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03027; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P073", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.161233735547124, "modern": 0.16128810371104074, "twfe_se": 0.23175829526333874, "x": 0.6956977974139817, "y": 0.6959323873511185, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0002345899371367215, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.49816860286009496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6956977974139817, "display_y": 0.6959323873511185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4982; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.45984172770274206, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 3.260354618668821, "se_normalized_difference": 0.34959121811943566, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8734628894882257, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 3.260354618668821, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.34450545002681265, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 2.398021338683492, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1573927097569581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5421794687577995, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 2.398021338683492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5422; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.17714854287302012, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 1.819861143119684, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6158213790525858, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6432918537486636, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 1.819861143119684, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6433; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": 0.07075989313060833, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": 0.4681427154307966, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0920789767934687, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8612826733542684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": 0.4681427154307966, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.3223054726379633, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 2.7365508733470856, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4893059853913318, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8936855951413996, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 2.7365508733470856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.025541150642906123, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.14216282734383506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.015522274289653934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8330329896265545, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.14216282734383506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.07159163451959023, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.4469922187214222, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5520585507711355, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.00020231659013051603, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.4469922187214222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0002023; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": -0.02067761653089223, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": -0.11699838816876441, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0678679329240792, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4581735747017874, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": -0.11699838816876441, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4582; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": -0.25577428336671953, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": -1.2592413191907492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6164680810767089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7499233525260419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": -1.2592413191907492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7499; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": 0.04879427886184874, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": 0.3230439185568635, "se_normalized_difference": -0.08789101633244381, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1285965376483094, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": 0.3230439185568635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1286; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.11425085708872226, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 0.9064489961403578, "se_normalized_difference": -0.443019344105053, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.055514115135109246, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 0.9064489961403578, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05551; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.06042820415359978, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -0.4088311916526365, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6401967941459146, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8391664853751086, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -0.4088311916526365, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8392; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P086", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5308687052782026, "modern": 0.6101266467133601, "twfe_se": 0.24844672525912923, "x": 2.136750664451335, "y": 2.4557644946899573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31901383023862245, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.10106640442242432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.136750664451335, "display_y": 2.4557644946899573, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1011; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P087", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15166924638969265, "modern": 0.22914942410328415, "twfe_se": 0.17916704385202792, "x": 0.8465242442407801, "y": 1.2789708373630149, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4324465931222347, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8016167718102788, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8465242442407801, "display_y": 1.2789708373630149, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8016; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P088", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3320653723940968, "modern": 0.3871365784380185, "twfe_se": 0.21620740446726425, "x": 1.5358649404829912, "y": 1.7905796491656902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25471470868269924, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.015974233938446332, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5358649404829912, "display_y": 1.7905796491656902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01597; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P089", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38234882585818836, "modern": 0.4908149332691468, "twfe_se": 0.2472861682957992, "x": 1.5461795881799167, "y": 1.9848054448481849, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4386258566682682, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7479907029715333, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5461795881799167, "display_y": 1.9848054448481849, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.748; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P090", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.013652890780187027, "modern": 0.07752727058447548, "twfe_se": 0.15900157709156928, "x": 0.08586638591845101, "y": 0.48758806046198766, "se_normalized_difference": 0.40172167454353663, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45023964544400547, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.08586638591845101, "display_y": 0.48758806046198766, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P091", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5533939995776936, "modern": 0.44743787084264147, "twfe_se": 0.11947743667565217, "x": 4.631786678517415, "y": 3.7449570671432313, "se_normalized_difference": -0.886829611374183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3518130830232728, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 4.631786678517415, "display_y": 3.7449570671432313, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P092", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06267395216048637, "modern": 0.5141642001275655, "twfe_se": 0.24040116283962085, "x": 0.2607056946820932, "y": 2.138775844734913, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8780701500528199, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07500784724867739, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2607056946820932, "display_y": 2.138775844734913, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P093", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16706306048849764, "modern": -0.2136394317829444, "twfe_se": 0.1886167895820999, "x": -0.8857274098379218, "y": -1.1326639174396127, "se_normalized_difference": -0.24693650760169092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06517953503926142, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8857274098379218, "display_y": -1.1326639174396127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P094", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1606615496153213, "modern": -0.08054578016886683, "twfe_se": 0.2302547890410383, "x": 0.6977555180695356, "y": -0.3498115305411136, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0475670486106492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11143156050705309, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6977555180695356, "display_y": -0.3498115305411136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1114; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P095", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2020209774341155, "modern": 0.3867152084443397, "twfe_se": 0.20501189505896467, "x": 0.9854110044493325, "y": 1.8863061986384464, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9008951941891138, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8408310081916496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9854110044493325, "display_y": 1.8863061986384464, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8408; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P096", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18439267097790166, "modern": -0.21044983030886144, "twfe_se": 0.24010389880009209, "x": 0.7679703324244018, "y": -0.8764948481077339, "se_normalized_difference": -1.644465180532136, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1096167789729291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7679703324244018, "display_y": -0.8764948481077339, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1096; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P097", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19717701724999584, "modern": 0.09528105206321572, "twfe_se": 0.20729820707749333, "x": 0.9511757001173005, "y": 0.45963278412532166, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4915429159919788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37850866874177913, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9511757001173005, "display_y": 0.45963278412532166, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3785; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8648815281075595, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 52.68648865332906, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2784374559434193, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47983688921801004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4798; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.1506838359231915, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 1.4883319133012118, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0488170221190814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1078307178723161, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 1.4883319133012118, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1078; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.18632123492718622, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.432185451343945, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6053175924336561, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9766705419510177, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.432185451343945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9767; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2221519598503761, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.2290980840968975, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5557647120017833, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.29345806370975447, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.2290980840968975, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2935; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": -0.10378186951570695, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": -0.9703913291942493, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2994228674763574, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2937123391699629, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": -0.9703913291942493, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.05493625656459516, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 0.45011780174715565, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9177591117655919, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4327564058760361, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 0.45011780174715565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4328; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P019", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09881088092328953, "modern": -0.19702122681021703, "twfe_se": 0.041534411407364795, "x": -2.3790124278917455, "y": -4.743566121061767, "se_normalized_difference": -2.3645536931700213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9429154965763455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3790124278917455, "display_y": -4.743566121061767, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P020", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08182840209484749, "modern": -0.1044007606091853, "twfe_se": 0.04813993283519639, "x": -1.6998029967133763, "y": -2.1686935244923133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4688905277789369, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9979580492039667, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6998029967133763, "display_y": -2.1686935244923133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P022", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17108040462993862, "modern": -0.15152466684137159, "twfe_se": 0.09706403855215703, "x": -1.7625518902967254, "y": -1.5610793564905123, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20147253380621316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9954625342637035, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7625518902967254, "display_y": -1.5610793564905123, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9955; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P023", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22004242857243222, "modern": -0.2009834428455899, "twfe_se": 0.12222233244634166, "x": -1.8003455192530855, "y": -1.64440850393545, "se_normalized_difference": 0.15593701531763565, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7586733997657202, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.8003455192530855, "display_y": -1.64440850393545, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7587; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P024", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14886186739593033, "modern": -0.10647375061688505, "twfe_se": 0.138167725784353, "x": -1.0773997078613593, "y": -0.7706123120464854, "se_normalized_difference": 0.306787395814874, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7283317035604059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0773997078613593, "display_y": -0.7706123120464854, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7283; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.2030383904269613, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -5.454757808398558, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5366276102184089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.484369966916825, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4844; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.21522117011185216, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -5.140118555774866, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8327432034636664, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11394349161470584, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1139; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.037306221004405324, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.6275662609162148, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1818776506343336, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8589956912870166, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.6275662609162148, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.0025936652535203247, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.03659969088893413, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1819049474612453, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1255451611841135, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.03659969088893413, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1255; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P029", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0949616989865803, "modern": -0.10690884560481552, "twfe_se": 0.038049286231772846, "x": -2.4957550690473416, "y": -2.809746415572492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3139913465251503, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9702899415292684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.4957550690473416, "display_y": -2.809746415572492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9703; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P030", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09127764261905837, "modern": -0.06459281001888015, "twfe_se": 0.038194441354129714, "x": -2.3898148364772225, "y": -1.6911573445986834, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6986574918785391, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.724030079051392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3898148364772225, "display_y": -1.6911573445986834, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.724; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P032", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12649461371178825, "modern": -0.08542924465000176, "twfe_se": 0.04336430141456208, "x": -2.917021826375147, "y": -1.9700362248038876, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9469856015712593, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7412517325644989, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.917021826375147, "display_y": -1.9700362248038876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7413; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P033", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16654716073235562, "modern": -0.08625191848631315, "twfe_se": 0.07374191421984075, "x": -2.2585142044976236, "y": -1.1696457760667476, "se_normalized_difference": 1.088868428430876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8826731469363056, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.2585142044976236, "display_y": -1.1696457760667476, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8827; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P034", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07279015339305425, "modern": 0.01704381018527843, "twfe_se": 0.06863507827387309, "x": -1.0605386520082523, "y": 0.24832506371259427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3088637157208465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5287294560445291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0605386520082523, "display_y": 0.24832506371259427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5287; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P035", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12463507367894962, "modern": -0.2017528598254334, "twfe_se": 0.049849340233739076, "x": -2.50023517050671, "y": -4.047252358394963, "se_normalized_difference": -1.547017187888253, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8494017199900289, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.50023517050671, "display_y": -4.047252358394963, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P036", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.043926056251628945, "modern": -0.05883144652871759, "twfe_se": 0.06775212077722162, "x": -0.6483347790110352, "y": -0.868333652937058, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2199988739260228, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9998153761870533, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6483347790110352, "display_y": -0.868333652937058, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P037", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1628351506261486, "modern": -0.11445768260576336, "twfe_se": 0.13255912926737692, "x": -1.2283963505652165, "y": -0.8634462465040621, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3649501040611544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9749886262020702, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2283963505652165, "display_y": -0.8634462465040621, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.975; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P038", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21969405227287891, "modern": -0.19067453120151492, "twfe_se": 0.12417221322224024, "x": -1.7692690383127514, "y": -1.535565214258125, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23370382405462642, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8437358834062463, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7692690383127514, "display_y": -1.535565214258125, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8437; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P039", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17957745866693553, "modern": -0.14142155067261403, "twfe_se": 0.16968725044087066, "x": -1.0582849224108986, "y": -0.8334247287594178, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22486019365148083, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7607391303141677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0582849224108986, "display_y": -0.8334247287594178, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7607; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P040", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26058903381841686, "modern": -0.20611977391920205, "twfe_se": 0.048392318481709495, "x": -5.384925583115218, "y": -4.259349012118683, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1255765709965346, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.019002181513361277, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.259349012118683, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.019; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P041", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.27992479239217416, "modern": -0.19705826602738652, "twfe_se": 0.051856524198979286, "x": -5.398063150512583, "y": -3.8000669939090383, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5979961566035454, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0006513060327783259, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.8000669939090383, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0006513; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P042", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1991390977895775, "modern": -0.1032364219762335, "twfe_se": 0.07237834054272763, "x": -2.751363132897725, "y": -1.4263441411079216, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3250189917898032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8339898457445425, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.751363132897725, "display_y": -1.4263441411079216, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.834; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P043", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113344233100728, "modern": -0.013069438910426293, "twfe_se": 0.07177601502906009, "x": -1.4090144498835886, "y": -0.1820864379993072, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2269280118842814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40992872560893645, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.4090144498835886, "display_y": -0.1820864379993072, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4099; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P044", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10837223305188158, "modern": -0.11974799382173384, "twfe_se": 0.04140854184295684, "x": -2.6171468066392336, "y": -2.89186695527415, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2747201486349165, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7996425394527843, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.6171468066392336, "display_y": -2.89186695527415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P045", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10566714520974, "modern": -0.07583447636706275, "twfe_se": 0.043653148547609565, "x": -2.420607647452873, "y": -1.7372051934433819, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6834024540094914, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37814114698857904, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.420607647452873, "display_y": -1.7372051934433819, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3781; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P046", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14629841804187504, "modern": -0.08617568094208841, "twfe_se": 0.04993271739678495, "x": -2.9299110016250562, "y": -1.7258359936092136, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2040750080158424, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3283672765607059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.9299110016250562, "display_y": -1.7258359936092136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3284; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P047", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14827651156083027, "modern": -0.04561761497369614, "twfe_se": 0.06730218782328327, "x": -2.203145489863761, "y": -0.677802853801354, "se_normalized_difference": 1.525342636062407, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9827773985566427, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.203145489863761, "display_y": -0.677802853801354, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9828; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P048", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08214515452042444, "modern": 0.004458662587853971, "twfe_se": 0.06549133531049521, "x": -1.2542904207247152, "y": 0.06808019055826847, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223706112829838, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8745609470697958, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2542904207247152, "display_y": 0.06808019055826847, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": 0.17550353597810928, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": 2.1728699927870183, "se_normalized_difference": 0.16007252895007676, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999624123905335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": 2.1728699927870183, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P050", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.106052751043436, "modern": 0.20027928776966455, "twfe_se": 0.08556206429156468, "x": 1.2394833144984259, "y": 2.340748665053065, "se_normalized_difference": 1.101265350554639, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9929672736576767, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.2394833144984259, "display_y": 2.340748665053065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.993; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P051", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1791064414013867, "modern": 0.18109188522066355, "twfe_se": 0.10907175575553293, "x": 1.6420973528914802, "y": 1.6603004505268286, "se_normalized_difference": 0.018203097635348442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9996434964466455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.6420973528914802, "display_y": 1.6603004505268286, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P052", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29588760263791564, "modern": 0.45520704034638326, "twfe_se": 0.1917331060707312, "x": 1.5432264604776254, "y": 2.374170270722341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8309438102447158, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9905191040017244, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.5432264604776254, "display_y": 2.374170270722341, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.21330251090649066, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.97838641702771, "se_normalized_difference": 1.15462796952067, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7240551444770145, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.97838641702771, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7241; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P054", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.31697833977317097, "modern": -0.22634360501738188, "twfe_se": 0.05435043811509917, "x": -5.832121152398049, "y": -4.164522179895751, "se_normalized_difference": 1.6675989725022977, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.022610883654263465, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.164522179895751, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02261; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P055", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1687796323024688, "modern": -0.14439005880064443, "twfe_se": 0.05054143946022593, "x": -3.3394306554187394, "y": -2.856864789422422, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4825658659963176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7349488855609596, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.3394306554187394, "display_y": -2.856864789422422, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7349; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P056", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658618154426823, "modern": -0.24440024114240916, "twfe_se": 0.09394992184708006, "x": -2.3053364737950517, "y": -2.60138844543387, "se_normalized_difference": -0.29605197163881813, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9168659980691416, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3053364737950517, "display_y": -2.60138844543387, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9169; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P058", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.3045492169792317, "modern": -0.18906972486722454, "twfe_se": 0.05422852223290661, "x": -5.616033858920593, "y": -3.48653655091664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1294973080039536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0005341070513687012, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.48653655091664, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0005341; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P060", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09540291291902506, "modern": 0.173457904334113, "twfe_se": 0.09911675406483009, "x": 0.9625306419601283, "y": 1.7500361666470434, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7875055246869153, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2731253467631985, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9625306419601283, "display_y": 1.7500361666470434, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2731; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P062", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.30677046832251936, "modern": -0.011322300818976672, "twfe_se": 0.3383154181902291, "x": 0.9067587577401733, "y": -0.03346670062967787, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9402254583698512, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8243296898940367, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9067587577401733, "display_y": -0.03346670062967787, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8243; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P064", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4225868461420414, "modern": 1.0743855666103255, "twfe_se": 0.15998925084723942, "x": 2.6413452397844828, "y": 6.715360944068474, "se_normalized_difference": 4.0740157042839895, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8319015184116749, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.6413452397844828, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8319; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P065", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T3-C6-TERMINATED-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08618892957737644, "modern": -0.14819726143869597, "twfe_se": 0.1130095983710691, "x": -0.7626691079316422, "y": -1.3113688003039135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5486996923722711, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17373851467052231, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7626691079316422, "display_y": -1.3113688003039135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1737; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P067", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.20669876701357798, "modern": 0.3501846101921218, "twfe_se": 0.1564704858157978, "x": 1.321008022285497, "y": 2.2380234097590175, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9170153874735206, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.3709648141606276e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.321008022285497, "display_y": 2.2380234097590175, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.371e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P069", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2615822418401665, "modern": 0.3868750332009083, "twfe_se": 0.17074781937748124, "x": 1.531979985418571, "y": 2.265768515295784, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7337885298772129, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.967188280417718e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.531979985418571, "display_y": 2.265768515295784, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.967e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P071", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2911068444010106, "modern": 0.4347640408285339, "twfe_se": 0.16302856058516044, "x": 1.7856186876467361, "y": 2.6667967825271224, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8811780948803865, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1205056782398701e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.7856186876467361, "display_y": 2.6667967825271224, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.121e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P073", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C8", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.33394441883176845, "modern": 0.419648540500346, "twfe_se": 0.16330693154006856, "x": 2.04488820947464, "y": 2.5696921529468706, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5248039434722305, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.3171782546872654e-14, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.04488820947464, "display_y": 2.5696921529468706, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.317e-14; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": -0.24338332196265441, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": -3.179768282364263, "se_normalized_difference": -0.28382556804003484, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9859921749777952, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": -3.179768282364263, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.986; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P075", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25765529203915105, "modern": -0.344269166229137, "twfe_se": 0.08021491852307107, "x": -3.2120620052122266, "y": -4.291834643329094, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0797726381168666, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6619100875775956, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.2120620052122266, "display_y": -4.291834643329094, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6619; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.34457526577661013, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 1.5863188700356177, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21498495671490114, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8000304677613004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 1.5863188700356177, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P077", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3348681094062555, "modern": 0.2767375857891446, "twfe_se": 0.1816872107624597, "x": 1.8431022635053085, "y": 1.523153911757471, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3199483517478373, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8576075637925102, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.8431022635053085, "display_y": 1.523153911757471, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8576; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.07573369102387349, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.1016210693909236, "se_normalized_difference": -3.569727963103465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999046342844691, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.1016210693909236, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P079", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.31104951098651784, "modern": 0.17914790760750995, "twfe_se": 0.06478036066813606, "x": 4.801602025342162, "y": 2.7654663506007404, "se_normalized_difference": -2.036135674741422, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.997361150037311, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.801602025342162, "display_y": 2.7654663506007404, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9974; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.10302790726298905, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.25691030838496554, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3741348815843343, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8074659022654093, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.25691030838496554, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8075; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P081", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.46043384283435496, "modern": 0.506695440824378, "twfe_se": 0.35319495551450636, "x": 1.3036251952229372, "y": 1.4346055426705184, "se_normalized_difference": 0.13098034744758127, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9744293819883441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3036251952229372, "display_y": 1.4346055426705184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9744; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": -0.13636564414696845, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": -1.9478414580890306, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5207175730959082, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7146713307312601, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": -1.9478414580890306, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7147; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P083", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1548516162623062, "modern": -0.10001320593217983, "twfe_se": 0.15762235225053767, "x": -0.982421681007352, "y": -0.634511568341594, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3479101126657581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4859193566492677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.982421681007352, "display_y": -0.634511568341594, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": 0.16070124937302005, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": 0.6548286465105709, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3944161269696218, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9384416169802532, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": 0.6548286465105709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9384; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P085", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6055333092652331, "modern": 0.32752083888341826, "twfe_se": 0.3494745746633342, "x": 1.732696319463505, "y": 0.9371807353909364, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7955155840725686, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8013690990268173, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.732696319463505, "display_y": 0.9371807353909364, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8014; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P001", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04554503237764617, "modern": 0.029550752772808053, "twfe_se": 0.02214473217513982, "x": -2.0566982710577126, "y": 1.3344371265859065, "se_normalized_difference": 3.3911353976436196, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.057662324201833e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0566982710577126, "display_y": 1.3344371265859065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.058e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P002", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02025550108463945, "modern": 0.11301216145047226, "twfe_se": 0.019400337721032605, "x": -1.044079818398199, "y": 5.825267738919395, "se_normalized_difference": 6.869347557317594, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.41858595740735e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.044079818398199, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.419e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P003", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04983128423661516, "modern": -0.009579258164665427, "twfe_se": 0.023269833494926877, "x": -2.1414542672803836, "y": -0.41165993588883343, "se_normalized_difference": 1.72979433139155, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.998841751158025e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.1414542672803836, "display_y": -0.41165993588883343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.999e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P004", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04076683043015399, "modern": 0.010150339041711602, "twfe_se": 0.021710065555831447, "x": -1.8777847687891385, "y": 0.46754069054320124, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3453254593323396, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0018548029548275384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8777847687891385, "display_y": 0.46754069054320124, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001855; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P005", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03944842134729418, "modern": -0.11030284624353281, "twfe_se": 0.026703389928004674, "x": -1.4772814033593313, "y": -4.130668298703709, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6533868953443775, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.694515805421165e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.4772814033593313, "display_y": -4.130668298703709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.695e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P006", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.030553147071442598, "modern": -0.10393021827196601, "twfe_se": 0.026538468786438795, "x": -1.1512776911626232, "y": -3.9162100537267825, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7649323625641595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7350396651094451, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1512776911626232, "display_y": -3.9162100537267825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P007", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0561026714314866, "modern": -0.016185880907912578, "twfe_se": 0.02278196935693539, "x": -2.46259094429023, "y": -0.7104689087374793, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7521220355527507, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.579660878741057e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.46259094429023, "display_y": -0.7104689087374793, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.58e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P008", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.040398117292382595, "modern": -0.0021529395683037534, "twfe_se": 0.021098261973614172, "x": -1.9147604358551018, "y": -0.10204345604373737, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8127169798113647, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.011974045630053888, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.9147604358551018, "display_y": -0.10204345604373737, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01197; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P009", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12289171381143947, "modern": -0.18562971917089063, "twfe_se": 0.03767341904728827, "x": 3.2620270981294226, "y": -4.927339324787201, "se_normalized_difference": -8.189366422916622, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.2381304926856194e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2620270981294226, "display_y": -4.927339324787201, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.238e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P010", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0857946819641765, "modern": -0.02319214683225769, "twfe_se": 0.02708791177167179, "x": 3.1672682149644156, "y": -0.8561806841275876, "se_normalized_difference": -4.023448899092004, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.34142504222450115, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1672682149644156, "display_y": -0.8561806841275876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3414; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P011", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1292085737760996, "modern": -0.17418418270666433, "twfe_se": 0.038865479579806766, "x": 3.3245073822074267, "y": -4.481719628571488, "se_normalized_difference": -7.8062270107789145, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.8645232175731985e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.3245073822074267, "display_y": -4.481719628571488, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.865e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P012", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09307990409843145, "modern": -0.023350193242507977, "twfe_se": 0.027324633105262498, "x": 3.406446620522236, "y": -0.8545473658349295, "se_normalized_difference": -4.260993986357166, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3017849118765784, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.406446620522236, "display_y": -0.8545473658349295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3018; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P013", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12085226786022098, "modern": -0.1856924837110375, "twfe_se": 0.038486828046456936, "x": 3.140094260673855, "y": -4.824832108452549, "se_normalized_difference": -7.964926369126403, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.617018334686794e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.140094260673855, "display_y": -4.824832108452549, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.617e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P014", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08796266153707287, "modern": -0.020070455626947314, "twfe_se": 0.02834927992300201, "x": 3.1028181941828374, "y": -0.7079705615613386, "se_normalized_difference": -3.810788755744176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.30425121086324036, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1028181941828374, "display_y": -0.7079705615613386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3043; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P015", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12565713848218707, "modern": -0.18256258165552525, "twfe_se": 0.03829978372654898, "x": 3.280883761102885, "y": -4.766673957194565, "se_normalized_difference": -8.047557718297451, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.4639532829167243e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.280883761102885, "display_y": -4.766673957194565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.464e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P016", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09121693194489162, "modern": -0.021343277699230473, "twfe_se": 0.02830998448046361, "x": 3.2220763670089387, "y": -0.7539134369345635, "se_normalized_difference": -3.975989803943502, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.31275516804953524, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2220763670089387, "display_y": -0.7539134369345635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3128; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P001", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113341599942652, "modern": 0.027090612439988726, "twfe_se": 0.04422121045668668, "x": -2.28698886699367, "y": 0.6126158049545738, "se_normalized_difference": 2.8996046719482442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0019379119886445725, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.28698886699367, "display_y": 0.6126158049545738, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001938; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P002", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20999936204812777, "modern": -0.05455407583706689, "twfe_se": 0.1608196559046698, "x": -1.3058065624304693, "y": -0.33922517449860295, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9665813879318663, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.3058065624304693, "display_y": -0.33922517449860295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P004", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14123366851820662, "modern": -0.016239084998918595, "twfe_se": 0.05193064802837583, "x": -2.7196592740578556, "y": -0.31270715108437064, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4069521229734847, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.797442420089926e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.7196592740578556, "display_y": -0.31270715108437064, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.797e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P006", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.032262235476981815, "modern": 0.07063437888563168, "twfe_se": 0.029038712745296222, "x": -1.111007769523384, "y": 2.4324211443247687, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5434289138481523, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0014348250836651384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.111007769523384, "display_y": 2.4324211443247687, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001435; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P007", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21617031982145912, "modern": -0.13345018549320065, "twfe_se": 0.12472637721842869, "x": -1.7331564071879362, "y": -1.0699435714347276, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6632128357532086, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.7331564071879362, "display_y": -1.0699435714347276, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P009", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08543758521702213, "modern": -0.02445158515512512, "twfe_se": 0.040893257759548066, "x": -2.0892829257916854, "y": -0.5979368359180427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4913460898736428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17464635282314106, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0892829257916854, "display_y": -0.5979368359180427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P011", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.012582455766935948, "modern": 0.13060802678741046, "twfe_se": 0.03446282272370412, "x": -0.3651022978533189, "y": 3.7898238294211466, "se_normalized_difference": 4.154926127274465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.0512315146171582e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -0.3651022978533189, "display_y": 3.7898238294211466, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.051e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P012", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2531616672939931, "modern": -0.11174530127867455, "twfe_se": 0.13764845254350458, "x": -1.8391900716354215, "y": -0.8118166184495014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.02737345318592, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8391900716354215, "display_y": -0.8118166184495014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P014", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08296560274959391, "modern": 0.04343236573361355, "twfe_se": 0.04480111686807485, "x": -1.8518646085074493, "y": 0.9694482809771945, "se_normalized_difference": 2.821312889484644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.1353089477552046e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8518646085074493, "display_y": 0.9694482809771945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.135e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P016", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.021554538786991286, "modern": -0.01927011682842492, "twfe_se": 0.012795115243670585, "x": -1.6845912191102588, "y": -1.5060526194132837, "se_normalized_difference": 0.17853859969697514, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9895992509023763, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6845912191102588, "display_y": -1.5060526194132837, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9896; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P017", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02325612733538412, "modern": -0.003759562756685654, "twfe_se": 0.013863174184456761, "x": -1.6775470773106664, "y": -0.2711906167132225, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4063564605974441, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6775470773106664, "display_y": -0.2711906167132225, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P019", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018531623316536978, "modern": 0.0015926812435597668, "twfe_se": 0.011687651791437265, "x": -1.5855728462165357, "y": 0.1362704221498637, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7218432683663996, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9881657238350432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.5855728462165357, "display_y": 0.1362704221498637, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9882; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P021", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T3-R3-NOTEXAS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00909454819923924, "modern": -0.034258677903352436, "twfe_se": 0.02098480773457043, "x": 0.43338725397311395, "y": -1.6325466659822951, "se_normalized_difference": -2.0659339199554094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6636804273830385, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": 0.43338725397311395, "display_y": -1.6325466659822951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6637; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.21942540341940092, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -4.183521304173129, "se_normalized_difference": -0.533622863721691, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7746975579662475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -4.183521304173129, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7747; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.39004080168212313, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -4.6945839576442845, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4542001499974968, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.13655863769778254, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -4.6945839576442845, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1366; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.29713651030571087, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -3.300894888930935, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3702091580447464, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4673589737110796, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -3.300894888930935, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4674; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.08217984532708654, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 4.268427836198346, "se_normalized_difference": 4.233769081212633, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5483424989161068, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 4.268427836198346, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5483; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.7556108038524608, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -7.9040677243779935, "se_normalized_difference": -5.2058390898486975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.03837020810449744, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03837; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.0006006236053846155, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 0.00698211411303128, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1700982524934386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.32226475891060424, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 0.00698211411303128, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3223; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.7527971699077467, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -7.704823329530131, "se_normalized_difference": -5.0557270090267945, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.02415707991283878, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02416; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.31707319306393916, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -8.256140032352649, "se_normalized_difference": -6.366720071619492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.024815342319498553, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02482; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.06979885590258547, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -1.8955743108907968, "se_normalized_difference": -1.774024555430823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5449672404714518, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -1.8955743108907968, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.545; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.2891986864187225, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -7.975017752597051, "se_normalized_difference": -6.194704159920209, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.031737607081148915, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03174; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0732397096110735, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.727415759980426, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0483174410274692, "homogeneity_pvalue": 9.006184276208503e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.727415759980426, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 9.006e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.3195547289469939, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 1.0028908207552323, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5890444720030076, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0003085680686237034, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 1.0028908207552323, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0003086; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 0.6109798366681785, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 1.7683050110499188, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6096230865684332, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1443603186589448e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 1.7683050110499188, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.144e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 0.5029079612799268, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 1.3794392032159444, "se_normalized_difference": -0.497469958736628, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.874202670498193e-20, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 1.3794392032159444, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.874e-20; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P001", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-LAND-EXPROPRIATION", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.014222863663783235, "modern": 0.08590158133443866, "twfe_se": 0.05506328730150922, "x": -0.25830030063231263, "y": 1.5600518157237626, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8183521163560752, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.25830030063231263, "display_y": 1.5600518157237626, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P002", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-ONE-CHILD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13470016920109934, "modern": 0.45462879236198217, "twfe_se": 0.21610578173287492, "x": -0.6233066423350032, "y": 2.1037326660882303, "se_normalized_difference": 2.727039308423233, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9990884746380607, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.6233066423350032, "display_y": 2.1037326660882303, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9991; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P003", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-PUBLIC-GOODS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00022117981059667995, "modern": 0.024392634950034197, "twfe_se": 0.017307556205773494, "x": -0.012779378438355051, "y": 1.409363324320579, "se_normalized_difference": 1.422142702758934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.454558695624506e-13, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.012779378438355051, "display_y": 1.409363324320579, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.455e-13; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P004", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-VC-UNILATERAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18886559326788294, "modern": -0.02743138018452337, "twfe_se": 0.15723477497681523, "x": 1.2011693551616158, "y": -0.1744612805186907, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3756306356803065, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999986824082961, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": 1.2011693551616158, "display_y": -0.1744612805186907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.2766581646581663, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 9.636297708898367, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7570821868595536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5e-324, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.941e-324; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.12953180482722826, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 2.8884240238938004, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7714333905217267, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.210703514378873e-222, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 2.8884240238938004, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.211e-222; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.26912176061253434, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 9.2839051347098, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4932417463303462, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.1173112187944399, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 2.5635974610464127, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06993961363032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.8236958397887627e-228, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 2.5635974610464127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.824e-228; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P001", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C1-LOGPAY", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11362857677249297, "modern": 0.02654938615172501, "twfe_se": 0.0007785365526435424, "x": 145.95149885598047, "y": 34.101656578070525, "se_normalized_difference": -111.84984227790997, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P002", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C3-TRANSFER-NONSES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06328442003596428, "modern": 0.2187590186566654, "twfe_se": 0.002687404261144327, "x": 23.548530063361984, "y": 81.40160444767447, "se_normalized_difference": 57.8530743843125, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P003", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C5-TRANSFER-SES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.010174911842129224, "modern": 0.002885450203221245, "twfe_se": 0.017429567710625926, "x": 0.5837730465297826, "y": 0.16554915481134577, "se_normalized_difference": -0.41822389171843677, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09480814692180335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 0.5837730465297826, "display_y": 0.16554915481134577, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09481; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P001", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-ANNOTATED-SCALAR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5836461717054291, "modern": 0.7570914198400018, "twfe_se": 0.15493282774663392, "x": 3.7670917144808223, "y": 4.886578466624872, "se_normalized_difference": 1.11948675214405, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7040545930389419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 3.7670917144808223, "display_y": 4.886578466624872, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7041; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P001", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4317959225682691, "modern": 0.2950029536826313, "twfe_se": 0.15175510253551105, "x": 2.845346979138496, "y": 1.9439409202968967, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9014060588415992, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.19866011805386e-06, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.845346979138496, "display_y": 1.9439409202968967, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.199e-06; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P002", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6914907581397147, "modern": 0.6098171388765059, "twfe_se": 0.23881176300149767, "x": 2.895547310772033, "y": 2.553547326195492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3419999845765412, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0006442741347147e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.895547310772033, "display_y": 2.553547326195492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.001e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P001", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C4-ALL-OPIOIDS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2053142392239101, "modern": -0.1461503407935394, "twfe_se": 0.031203796039542576, "x": -6.5797840417790345, "y": -4.683735934189943, "se_normalized_difference": 1.896048107589092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.683735934189943, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P002", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C9-OXYCONTIN", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18941714291972508, "modern": -0.06487917894497999, "twfe_se": 0.05441628787667782, "x": -3.480890562564578, "y": -1.192274987445192, "se_normalized_difference": 2.288615575119386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -3.480890562564578, "display_y": -1.192274987445192, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 6, "study": "Railroads of the Raj", "specification_id": "S06-P001", "source_specification_id": "RRR-T4-C1-REAL-INCOME", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00357296649567496, "modern": 0.012993242286345331, "twfe_se": 0.20218780330947986, "x": -0.017671523391576592, "y": 0.06426323484239628, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08193475823397287, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999999900060716, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 6 (2018)", "display_x": -0.017671523391576592, "display_y": 0.06426323484239628, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 19 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.42594215301121846, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 3.0029270883907704, "se_normalized_difference": 0.44412233935242995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 3.0029270883907704, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.2847501748827035, "se_normalized_difference": 0.39889329152629266, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.2847501748827035, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 1.1814139520448312, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3347048082591956, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 1.1814139520448312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": 0.2208707981145346, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": 1.3905677584074576, "se_normalized_difference": -0.47112704329156324, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": 1.3905677584074576, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 1.5744969021871882, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3918160548713041, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 1.5744969021871882, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.908486123049834, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12875187161505738, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.908486123049834, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.12334687831890981, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.0571567897993446, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25207684340939934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.0571567897993446, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": -0.02158858000909039, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": -0.09431343900620366, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31881155493175717, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": -0.09431343900620366, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": -0.19720465361266512, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": -0.9300878109696857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11687930840934309, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": -0.9300878109696857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": 0.8617823674953772, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08725381187999684, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": 0.8617823674953772, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 0.4636211521472953, "se_normalized_difference": -0.034013242652897, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 0.4636211521472953, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.062037859929712315, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -0.6674725889205914, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1557707726822974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -0.6674725889205914, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P001", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F1B-SIZE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2985242372686371, "modern": 0.29781256170431736, "twfe_se": 0.07399533091199685, "x": 4.034365865917594, "y": 4.024748021716503, "se_normalized_difference": -0.009617844201090544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 4.034365865917594, "display_y": 4.024748021716503, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P002", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F2A-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2407326507382832, "modern": 0.23333207064136352, "twfe_se": 0.07563931534096853, "x": 3.1826392088968998, "y": 3.084798819100149, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09784038979675042, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1826392088968998, "display_y": 3.084798819100149, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P005", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C1-VANISH-CONFLICT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.029729548421959906, "modern": -0.03784763410230067, "twfe_se": 0.014259074918511055, "x": -2.0849563237349407, "y": -2.654283978350312, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5693276546153714, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0849563237349407, "display_y": -2.654283978350312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P006", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C3-VANISH-PURCHASE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00822835391523646, "modern": 0.008619450261432418, "twfe_se": 0.01566429802296934, "x": -0.5252934988322372, "y": 0.5502608702153962, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0755543690476335, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -0.5252934988322372, "display_y": 0.5502608702153962, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P007", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C5-VANISH-EXTINCTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03852214346804064, "modern": 0.021842430436026128, "twfe_se": 0.028415889530356387, "x": 1.3556550262798515, "y": 0.7686695998973425, "se_normalized_difference": -0.586985426382509, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.3556550262798515, "display_y": 0.7686695998973425, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P008", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C1-SIZE-SINGLE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22154054083078928, "modern": 0.21409243802411873, "twfe_se": 0.06337713349981079, "x": 3.4955910530641257, "y": 3.3780707047086294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11752034835549613, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.4955910530641257, "display_y": 3.3780707047086294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P009", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C3-SIZE-UNCONTESTED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18935657850842058, "modern": 0.18408504027258502, "twfe_se": 0.058511023120722476, "x": 3.2362547842947795, "y": 3.1461599960877935, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09009478820698623, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.2362547842947795, "display_y": 3.1461599960877935, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P010", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C5-SIZE-ALL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18010933839074345, "modern": 0.17835022690352453, "twfe_se": 0.061075085940861945, "x": 2.9489821523156023, "y": 2.920179712497143, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028802439818459397, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 2.9489821523156023, "display_y": 2.920179712497143, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P011", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T4-C1-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18420481067124622, "modern": 0.16377852353219974, "twfe_se": 0.05919483001785045, "x": 3.1118395071951133, "y": 2.7667707379649817, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3450687692301313, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1118395071951133, "display_y": 2.7667707379649817, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P014", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T9-C1-VANISH-NOEXT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02920270024836768, "modern": -0.0264029996624148, "twfe_se": 0.013853448593025026, "x": -2.1079733361894264, "y": -1.9058792101562536, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2020941260331727, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1079733361894264, "display_y": -1.9058792101562536, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.2413395907640687, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -2.9015929435621812, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8464469197062248, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2047592728987791, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -2.9015929435621812, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2048; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.2139493432167725, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -3.0784826173169857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.990609631562876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -3.0784826173169857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.1300820525159727, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -1.838100744312126, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5383408583452726, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24264765541323957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -1.838100744312126, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P005", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1976322869564458, "modern": -0.2806193113899418, "twfe_se": 0.08995321908555387, "x": -2.1970563028820473, "y": -3.1196138864474294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.922557583565382, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16617954483812042, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1970563028820473, "display_y": -3.1196138864474294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1662; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.3140427393678433, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -3.2242629699367296, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6987952305532722, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -3.2242629699367296, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.23839113430397812, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -2.4538694021145138, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25048152488725295, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.14208227793353256, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -2.4538694021145138, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1421; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P003", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8A-INITIAL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.05065020247399928, "modern": 0.05315485520642897, "twfe_se": 0.02398136966268965, "x": 2.1120646229310727, "y": 2.216506227712573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.10444160478150014, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9775744925581922, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 2.1120646229310727, "display_y": 2.216506227712573, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9776; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P004", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8B-FULL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07467736218313017, "modern": -0.08795761261594937, "twfe_se": 0.04482978193546973, "x": -1.6657980244165491, "y": -1.9620352546563806, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2962372302398316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45013102997146764, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6657980244165491, "display_y": -1.9620352546563806, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P006", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C1-INITIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13734681236512186, "modern": 0.1349766057015137, "twfe_se": 0.03220903817063694, "x": 4.264232034421095, "y": 4.19064378720144, "se_normalized_difference": -0.07358824721965558, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9994420850606988, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 4.264232034421095, "display_y": 4.19064378720144, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9994; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P007", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C2-FULL-EXCL-PARTIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.039721651217501285, "modern": -0.05744106277769158, "twfe_se": 0.050805728533818637, "x": -0.7818341034330553, "y": -1.1306020882951449, "se_normalized_difference": -0.34876798486208965, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.33223047213496354, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7818341034330553, "display_y": -1.1306020882951449, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3322; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P008", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C3-FULL-DROP-LIMITED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03441024653904987, "modern": -0.0451620507156221, "twfe_se": 0.049669708930519536, "x": -0.6927813204459209, "y": -0.9092473398383918, "se_normalized_difference": -0.21646601939247087, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16306560648547455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6927813204459209, "display_y": -0.9092473398383918, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1631; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P009", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C4-FULL-DMSP-2013", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06437742135856342, "modern": -0.06775557959636926, "twfe_se": 0.05407466514201637, "x": -1.1905283405729634, "y": -1.2530004470378628, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0624721064648995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0008678643456103258, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.1905283405729634, "display_y": -1.2530004470378628, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0008679; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P010", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C5-FULL-DMSP-RAW", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.034129483049029005, "modern": 0.009146639060140477, "twfe_se": 0.04398867224053275, "x": -0.7758698162655809, "y": 0.20793169228036926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.98380150854595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7657199822961114, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7758698162655809, "display_y": 0.20793169228036926, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7657; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P011", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C7-FULL-DISTRICT-YEAR", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04961829037148674, "modern": -0.06304837327176609, "twfe_se": 0.05810665275823827, "x": -0.8539175467210497, "y": -1.0850456923424692, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2311281456214194, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6646258531167744, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.8539175467210497, "display_y": -1.0850456923424692, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6646; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P001", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20015904475694235, "modern": -0.2302701389429832, "twfe_se": 0.09099161176045499, "x": -2.1997527121937583, "y": -2.530674360942123, "se_normalized_difference": -0.33092164874836466, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07256341097820927, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.1997527121937583, "display_y": -2.530674360942123, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07256; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P002", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5866666266332619, "modern": -0.3587760057249104, "twfe_se": 0.21439777269866464, "x": -2.7363466478628946, "y": -1.673412933394457, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0629337144684379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6478429577611663, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.7363466478628946, "display_y": -1.673412933394457, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6478; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P003", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2180655094585218, "modern": -0.04366520037802251, "twfe_se": 0.3747435754693577, "x": -0.5819059317705441, "y": -0.11652021071564163, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4653857210549024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.654702301900471, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.5819059317705441, "display_y": -0.11652021071564163, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6547; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P004", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.32443914047906564, "modern": -0.553339409278403, "twfe_se": 0.09291827843087484, "x": -3.491661123709123, "y": -5.9551190424825995, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4634579187734764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8117889624508522, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -3.491661123709123, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8118; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P005", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.7502544624743879, "modern": -0.7502544624743879, "twfe_se": 0.16706519637830788, "x": -4.490788498973102, "y": -4.490788498973102, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -4.490788498973102, "display_y": -4.490788498973102, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P006", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08658480067380339, "modern": -0.08658461544704904, "twfe_se": 0.36856303915072125, "x": -0.23492534919757688, "y": -0.23492484663292804, "se_normalized_difference": 5.025646488535392e-07, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.23492534919757688, "display_y": -0.23492484663292804, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P007", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PC-C1-TRIPS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5245447118342563, "modern": 0.5367294072304346, "twfe_se": 0.12450377843848578, "x": 4.213082674381813, "y": 4.3109487435806555, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09786606919884311, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.7090130611501043e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": 4.213082674381813, "display_y": 4.3109487435806555, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.709e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.02295029924928877, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 0.9944551499490927, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09789785511577183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.014525389094489763, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 0.9944551499490927, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01453; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.02491540528604237, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 1.1500765083806341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3557365880040043, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.23734132618960652, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 1.1500765083806341, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.03117275671188908, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 1.4240415652910021, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3880859137597521, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4570063473046029, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 1.4240415652910021, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.457; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P002", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-BASELINE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.7888758993762184, "modern": 0.7967550027391155, "twfe_se": 0.11904766121821768, "x": 6.626555207415515, "y": 6.692739652219134, "se_normalized_difference": 0.06618444480361932, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8081640057069475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8082; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P001", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C1", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.41430806278014465, "modern": 0.42527348656207975, "twfe_se": 0.1373506360351823, "x": 3.0164262411862426, "y": 3.096261501498589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.07983526031234624, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45211921681332806, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 3.0164262411862426, "display_y": 3.096261501498589, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4521; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P002", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C2", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.34659086917588267, "modern": 0.3645272632101659, "twfe_se": 0.1851776291667871, "x": 1.8716670622438565, "y": 1.9685275421786552, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09686047993479888, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2838842303671143, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 1.8716670622438565, "display_y": 1.9685275421786552, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2839; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 11, "study": "Hall of Mirrors", "specification_id": "S11-P001", "source_specification_id": "HALL-MIRRORS-F1-COCOMMENT", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1472449898121927, "modern": 0.1605524415240668, "twfe_se": 0.03234331016239992, "x": 4.552564010079879, "y": 4.964007725799009, "se_normalized_difference": 0.41144371571912974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.705583964423773e-89, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 11 (2021)", "display_x": 4.552564010079879, "display_y": 4.964007725799009, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.706e-89; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 18 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": -0.5138179527233715, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": -6.0305967709411, "se_normalized_difference": -0.046896934516610075, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5.812088427359851e-72, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 5.812e-72; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 20 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": false, "shape": "diamond", "size": 120, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#B5BD35", "#5C7C28", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#8C564B", "#D55E00", "#A95E00", "#56B4E9", "#009E73", "#B51F45", "#E6679E", "#8C2981", "#F09556", "#008F9C", "#332288", "#E63228", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#2DB6A4", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "homogeneity_test", "title": "Homogeneity F-test", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.capped && datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.3885253830076921, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 3.4147827899666137, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5288892869379433, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7528002318625951, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 3.4147827899666137, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7528; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.3328428430090348, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 2.4813782064818644, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7520064855512179, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40501845027573946, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 2.4813782064818644, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.405; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.385059491047323, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 3.1121304142542905, "se_normalized_difference": -0.025394052809753983, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47578789224074497, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 3.1121304142542905, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4758; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.20535587329137728, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.9403105956474556, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20629487713198497, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4755457444652286, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.9403105956474556, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4755; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.35038915647090907, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 3.6672865385561884, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4501909985412788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4912213849296376, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 3.6672865385561884, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4912; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.22224621433890407, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4105115212167811, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22319664872739578, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16584271954927018, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4105115212167811, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1658; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.42594215301119437, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 3.063135126493506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6077352836076337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 3.063135126493506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.0636290695671966, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.47601221502014696, "se_normalized_difference": 0.30256851691010567, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6238759371413234, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.47601221502014696, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6239; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.06153564561861635, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 0.6641303289063571, "se_normalized_difference": 0.28850940807882325, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9007339476341801, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 0.6641303289063571, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9007; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.2860739583907882, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.5245967953100297, "se_normalized_difference": 1.111778291083094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.744755025448304, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.5245967953100297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7448; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": -0.07239225849517301, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": -0.8438784517311982, "se_normalized_difference": -1.6804077637082337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1883135791121969, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": -0.8438784517311982, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1883; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": 0.2604059077160187, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": 2.7656284795470314, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0880875836783972, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7555106259415197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": 2.7656284795470314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7555; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.11764988087499709, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.883643182599003, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3382433676435073, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8775181204600441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.883643182599003, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8775; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.08860159710440971, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 0.9719592159911877, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31164434620889925, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11053990821571197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 0.9719592159911877, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1105; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": -0.10398415086730348, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": -1.0277453468056132, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4194402699439226, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6613097442013468, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": -1.0277453468056132, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.17528994011918686, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.579283320391719, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9192786009535644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8426154697309903, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.579283320391719, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.06328050733614857, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 0.6347730868317343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6451137650494003, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.904975638165574, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 0.6347730868317343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.039867497536061294, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.393115506998779, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4617745654598037, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9224037401332055, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.393115506998779, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9224; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 1.651153141158054, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22967394938499702, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 1.651153141158054, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.1685790387984038, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 1.8258833684449844, "se_normalized_difference": 0.27500155858422975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.12359234733591484, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 1.8258833684449844, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1236; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.04003771997148135, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 0.4431815934837828, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8604278797423379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8852716493371069, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 0.4431815934837828, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8853; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 1.2949695075512722, "se_normalized_difference": -0.39946129871962477, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 1.2949695075512722, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.5524011544647354, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 4.982732437148825, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1005293228826023, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.01714325715860586, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 4.982732437148825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01714; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.1065328086513135, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -1.014751306568505, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4016095808936353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9650240752385251, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -1.014751306568505, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.965; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": 0.2006988537785288, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": 1.612275723179677, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5748925503596426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6742386532450715, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": 1.612275723179677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6742; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": 0.06975588945735992, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": 0.4730545873038456, "se_normalized_difference": -0.578305632692984, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8493619630133346, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": 0.4730545873038456, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.24343173113939617, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 2.1429167471879733, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12928298396029417, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.368668192626714, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 2.1429167471879733, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3687; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": 0.22087079811454136, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": 1.6320398924198933, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5537940866718213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": 1.6320398924198933, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 2.448405761746198, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1714667306431985, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 2.448405761746198, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0894488186393951, "se_normalized_difference": -0.049675814622635504, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0894488186393951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.1508950291473108, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -2.3110066391030823, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2759274864151426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09612628893524412, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -2.3110066391030823, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.20707550078154957, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.3262722628899362, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2557703864165844, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3428608116390395, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.3262722628899362, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.11579504661744161, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 1.0937022099197315, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5151283473619641, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6833402896734146, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 1.0937022099197315, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1085905496696486, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.0565407513080447, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2346447510359829, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.05372630452950017, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.0565407513080447, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.12334687831889027, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.080433657834606, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22961822897067982, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.080433657834606, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": -0.021588580009078137, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": -0.15510186540209908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.022122764010544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": -0.15510186540209908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.2200701629813498, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -1.8561175264468608, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7136746991547429, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5312685394334519, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -1.8561175264468608, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5313; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": 0.019629505394895136, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": 0.15288052365790902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2693180289941803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.35019378980996957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": 0.15288052365790902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": -0.18143225297181387, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": -1.3874157380204908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2610500940171219, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.44892433741068394, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": -1.3874157380204908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4489; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": -0.1972046536126607, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": -1.3696511938562184, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6484590274995803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": -1.3696511938562184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.06076953126919374, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -0.5599313788877915, "se_normalized_difference": -0.014511269968484064, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6140200715446021, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -0.5599313788877915, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.614; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.08678442257440994, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.663058341854694, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8057170383258024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5307579151547169, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.663058341854694, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5308; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": 0.08080864784158243, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": 0.7545368107908907, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18806120158701928, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0502924517983174, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": 0.7545368107908907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05029; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.13312774663920757, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 1.37254658344467, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5497262605136766, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0384481776614768, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 1.37254658344467, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03845; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": 1.036530243767059, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0835143109148764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": 1.036530243767059, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.11748987923104534, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 0.7922914922158757, "se_normalized_difference": -0.006987762485435748, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.08317218243244932, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 0.7922914922158757, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.08317; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": -0.006545688292584825, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": -0.04810912669492938, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1143899187070034, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8156953081194223, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": -0.04810912669492938, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8157; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 0.49425217077821487, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6924049321882342, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 0.49425217077821487, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.06203785992970153, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -0.6726159239003874, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9228038799524354, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -0.6726159239003874, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P062", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3008887212720041, "modern": 0.3473935080976446, "twfe_se": 0.31083588666172546, "x": 0.9679986584028292, "y": 1.1176106846237603, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1496120262209312, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6998373490996154, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9679986584028292, "display_y": 1.1176106846237603, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P063", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.49306361679116867, "modern": 0.6471186994364466, "twfe_se": 0.18166472287589872, "x": 2.714140692730955, "y": 3.562159395572442, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8480187028414876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9989912166654179, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.714140692730955, "display_y": 3.562159395572442, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P064", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13450188332648486, "modern": -0.06464438569611686, "twfe_se": 0.4167804498641, "x": 0.3227163926963033, "y": -0.15510416987455988, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4778205625708632, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06784394081766397, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3227163926963033, "display_y": -0.15510416987455988, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06784; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P065", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658198080855093, "modern": -0.12842303879624975, "twfe_se": 0.4081892333040155, "x": -0.5305920958656024, "y": -0.3146164286518588, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21597566721374353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8829318262431582, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5305920958656024, "display_y": -0.3146164286518588, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8829; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P066", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13997365996268946, "modern": 0.1807103456031524, "twfe_se": 0.20009060583611854, "x": 0.6995513826237947, "y": 0.9031425780736589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20359119544986423, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8155361799666327, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6995513826237947, "display_y": 0.9031425780736589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8155; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P067", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4448736019775512, "modern": 0.34165081521349516, "twfe_se": 0.28926475842925403, "x": 1.53794608231322, "y": 1.1811007226345316, "se_normalized_difference": -0.35684535967868836, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8251925142753511, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.53794608231322, "display_y": 1.1811007226345316, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8252; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P068", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5483851615815729, "modern": 0.5148405121812912, "twfe_se": 0.27592838943462955, "x": 1.9874184120930816, "y": 1.8658482848980735, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12157012719500823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6503824307717044, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9874184120930816, "display_y": 1.8658482848980735, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6504; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P069", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18640506753037372, "modern": -0.5597970757619195, "twfe_se": 0.3193859691436377, "x": -0.5836357433927901, "y": -1.752729079686533, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1690933362937428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4502524658648966, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5836357433927901, "display_y": -1.752729079686533, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4503; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P070", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18520047564986342, "modern": 0.012421380811847016, "twfe_se": 0.39534645345353947, "x": -0.46845108646365513, "y": 0.03141897620009068, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4998700626637458, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4205575876619039, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.46845108646365513, "display_y": 0.03141897620009068, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4206; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P071", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22194506642235692, "modern": 0.38764788926886995, "twfe_se": 0.24948117419673407, "x": -0.8896265104449809, "y": 1.5538161968212534, "se_normalized_difference": 2.443442707266234, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8641356346203798, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8896265104449809, "display_y": 1.5538161968212534, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8641; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P072", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04440438154510488, "modern": 0.16878837243409034, "twfe_se": 0.2581006713311633, "x": 0.1720428750382078, "y": 0.653963321999739, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48192044696153113, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.030267294207242283, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1720428750382078, "display_y": 0.653963321999739, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03027; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P073", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.161233735547124, "modern": 0.16128810371104074, "twfe_se": 0.23175829526333874, "x": 0.6956977974139817, "y": 0.6959323873511185, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0002345899371367215, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.49816860286009496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6956977974139817, "display_y": 0.6959323873511185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4982; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.45984172770274206, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 3.260354618668821, "se_normalized_difference": 0.34959121811943566, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8734628894882257, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 3.260354618668821, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.34450545002681265, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 2.398021338683492, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1573927097569581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5421794687577995, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 2.398021338683492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5422; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.17714854287302012, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 1.819861143119684, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6158213790525858, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6432918537486636, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 1.819861143119684, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6433; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": 0.07075989313060833, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": 0.4681427154307966, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0920789767934687, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8612826733542684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": 0.4681427154307966, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.3223054726379633, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 2.7365508733470856, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4893059853913318, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8936855951413996, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 2.7365508733470856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.025541150642906123, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.14216282734383506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.015522274289653934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8330329896265545, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.14216282734383506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.07159163451959023, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.4469922187214222, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5520585507711355, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.00020231659013051603, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.4469922187214222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0002023; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": -0.02067761653089223, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": -0.11699838816876441, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0678679329240792, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4581735747017874, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": -0.11699838816876441, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4582; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": -0.25577428336671953, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": -1.2592413191907492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6164680810767089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7499233525260419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": -1.2592413191907492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7499; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": 0.04879427886184874, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": 0.3230439185568635, "se_normalized_difference": -0.08789101633244381, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1285965376483094, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": 0.3230439185568635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1286; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.11425085708872226, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 0.9064489961403578, "se_normalized_difference": -0.443019344105053, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.055514115135109246, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 0.9064489961403578, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05551; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.06042820415359978, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -0.4088311916526365, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6401967941459146, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8391664853751086, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -0.4088311916526365, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8392; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P086", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5308687052782026, "modern": 0.6101266467133601, "twfe_se": 0.24844672525912923, "x": 2.136750664451335, "y": 2.4557644946899573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31901383023862245, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.10106640442242432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.136750664451335, "display_y": 2.4557644946899573, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1011; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P087", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15166924638969265, "modern": 0.22914942410328415, "twfe_se": 0.17916704385202792, "x": 0.8465242442407801, "y": 1.2789708373630149, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4324465931222347, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8016167718102788, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8465242442407801, "display_y": 1.2789708373630149, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8016; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P088", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3320653723940968, "modern": 0.3871365784380185, "twfe_se": 0.21620740446726425, "x": 1.5358649404829912, "y": 1.7905796491656902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25471470868269924, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.015974233938446332, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5358649404829912, "display_y": 1.7905796491656902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01597; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P089", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38234882585818836, "modern": 0.4908149332691468, "twfe_se": 0.2472861682957992, "x": 1.5461795881799167, "y": 1.9848054448481849, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4386258566682682, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7479907029715333, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5461795881799167, "display_y": 1.9848054448481849, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.748; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P090", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.013652890780187027, "modern": 0.07752727058447548, "twfe_se": 0.15900157709156928, "x": 0.08586638591845101, "y": 0.48758806046198766, "se_normalized_difference": 0.40172167454353663, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45023964544400547, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.08586638591845101, "display_y": 0.48758806046198766, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P091", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5533939995776936, "modern": 0.44743787084264147, "twfe_se": 0.11947743667565217, "x": 4.631786678517415, "y": 3.7449570671432313, "se_normalized_difference": -0.886829611374183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3518130830232728, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 4.631786678517415, "display_y": 3.7449570671432313, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P092", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06267395216048637, "modern": 0.5141642001275655, "twfe_se": 0.24040116283962085, "x": 0.2607056946820932, "y": 2.138775844734913, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8780701500528199, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07500784724867739, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2607056946820932, "display_y": 2.138775844734913, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P093", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16706306048849764, "modern": -0.2136394317829444, "twfe_se": 0.1886167895820999, "x": -0.8857274098379218, "y": -1.1326639174396127, "se_normalized_difference": -0.24693650760169092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06517953503926142, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8857274098379218, "display_y": -1.1326639174396127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P094", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1606615496153213, "modern": -0.08054578016886683, "twfe_se": 0.2302547890410383, "x": 0.6977555180695356, "y": -0.3498115305411136, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0475670486106492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11143156050705309, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6977555180695356, "display_y": -0.3498115305411136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1114; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P095", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2020209774341155, "modern": 0.3867152084443397, "twfe_se": 0.20501189505896467, "x": 0.9854110044493325, "y": 1.8863061986384464, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9008951941891138, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8408310081916496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9854110044493325, "display_y": 1.8863061986384464, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8408; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P096", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18439267097790166, "modern": -0.21044983030886144, "twfe_se": 0.24010389880009209, "x": 0.7679703324244018, "y": -0.8764948481077339, "se_normalized_difference": -1.644465180532136, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1096167789729291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7679703324244018, "display_y": -0.8764948481077339, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1096; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P097", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19717701724999584, "modern": 0.09528105206321572, "twfe_se": 0.20729820707749333, "x": 0.9511757001173005, "y": 0.45963278412532166, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4915429159919788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37850866874177913, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9511757001173005, "display_y": 0.45963278412532166, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3785; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8648815281075595, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 52.68648865332906, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2784374559434193, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47983688921801004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4798; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.1506838359231915, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 1.4883319133012118, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0488170221190814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1078307178723161, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 1.4883319133012118, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1078; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.18632123492718622, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.432185451343945, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6053175924336561, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9766705419510177, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.432185451343945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9767; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2221519598503761, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.2290980840968975, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5557647120017833, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.29345806370975447, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.2290980840968975, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2935; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": -0.10378186951570695, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": -0.9703913291942493, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2994228674763574, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2937123391699629, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": -0.9703913291942493, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.05493625656459516, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 0.45011780174715565, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9177591117655919, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4327564058760361, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 0.45011780174715565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4328; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P019", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09881088092328953, "modern": -0.19702122681021703, "twfe_se": 0.041534411407364795, "x": -2.3790124278917455, "y": -4.743566121061767, "se_normalized_difference": -2.3645536931700213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9429154965763455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3790124278917455, "display_y": -4.743566121061767, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P020", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08182840209484749, "modern": -0.1044007606091853, "twfe_se": 0.04813993283519639, "x": -1.6998029967133763, "y": -2.1686935244923133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4688905277789369, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9979580492039667, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6998029967133763, "display_y": -2.1686935244923133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P022", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17108040462993862, "modern": -0.15152466684137159, "twfe_se": 0.09706403855215703, "x": -1.7625518902967254, "y": -1.5610793564905123, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20147253380621316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9954625342637035, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7625518902967254, "display_y": -1.5610793564905123, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9955; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P023", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22004242857243222, "modern": -0.2009834428455899, "twfe_se": 0.12222233244634166, "x": -1.8003455192530855, "y": -1.64440850393545, "se_normalized_difference": 0.15593701531763565, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7586733997657202, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.8003455192530855, "display_y": -1.64440850393545, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7587; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P024", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14886186739593033, "modern": -0.10647375061688505, "twfe_se": 0.138167725784353, "x": -1.0773997078613593, "y": -0.7706123120464854, "se_normalized_difference": 0.306787395814874, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7283317035604059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0773997078613593, "display_y": -0.7706123120464854, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7283; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.2030383904269613, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -5.454757808398558, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5366276102184089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.484369966916825, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4844; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.21522117011185216, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -5.140118555774866, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8327432034636664, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11394349161470584, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1139; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.037306221004405324, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.6275662609162148, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1818776506343336, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8589956912870166, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.6275662609162148, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.0025936652535203247, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.03659969088893413, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1819049474612453, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1255451611841135, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.03659969088893413, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1255; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P029", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0949616989865803, "modern": -0.10690884560481552, "twfe_se": 0.038049286231772846, "x": -2.4957550690473416, "y": -2.809746415572492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3139913465251503, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9702899415292684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.4957550690473416, "display_y": -2.809746415572492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9703; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P030", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09127764261905837, "modern": -0.06459281001888015, "twfe_se": 0.038194441354129714, "x": -2.3898148364772225, "y": -1.6911573445986834, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6986574918785391, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.724030079051392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3898148364772225, "display_y": -1.6911573445986834, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.724; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P032", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12649461371178825, "modern": -0.08542924465000176, "twfe_se": 0.04336430141456208, "x": -2.917021826375147, "y": -1.9700362248038876, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9469856015712593, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7412517325644989, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.917021826375147, "display_y": -1.9700362248038876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7413; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P033", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16654716073235562, "modern": -0.08625191848631315, "twfe_se": 0.07374191421984075, "x": -2.2585142044976236, "y": -1.1696457760667476, "se_normalized_difference": 1.088868428430876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8826731469363056, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.2585142044976236, "display_y": -1.1696457760667476, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8827; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P034", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07279015339305425, "modern": 0.01704381018527843, "twfe_se": 0.06863507827387309, "x": -1.0605386520082523, "y": 0.24832506371259427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3088637157208465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5287294560445291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0605386520082523, "display_y": 0.24832506371259427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5287; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P035", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12463507367894962, "modern": -0.2017528598254334, "twfe_se": 0.049849340233739076, "x": -2.50023517050671, "y": -4.047252358394963, "se_normalized_difference": -1.547017187888253, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8494017199900289, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.50023517050671, "display_y": -4.047252358394963, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P036", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.043926056251628945, "modern": -0.05883144652871759, "twfe_se": 0.06775212077722162, "x": -0.6483347790110352, "y": -0.868333652937058, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2199988739260228, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9998153761870533, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6483347790110352, "display_y": -0.868333652937058, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P037", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1628351506261486, "modern": -0.11445768260576336, "twfe_se": 0.13255912926737692, "x": -1.2283963505652165, "y": -0.8634462465040621, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3649501040611544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9749886262020702, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2283963505652165, "display_y": -0.8634462465040621, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.975; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P038", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21969405227287891, "modern": -0.19067453120151492, "twfe_se": 0.12417221322224024, "x": -1.7692690383127514, "y": -1.535565214258125, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23370382405462642, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8437358834062463, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7692690383127514, "display_y": -1.535565214258125, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8437; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P039", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17957745866693553, "modern": -0.14142155067261403, "twfe_se": 0.16968725044087066, "x": -1.0582849224108986, "y": -0.8334247287594178, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22486019365148083, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7607391303141677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0582849224108986, "display_y": -0.8334247287594178, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7607; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P040", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26058903381841686, "modern": -0.20611977391920205, "twfe_se": 0.048392318481709495, "x": -5.384925583115218, "y": -4.259349012118683, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1255765709965346, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.019002181513361277, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.259349012118683, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.019; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P041", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.27992479239217416, "modern": -0.19705826602738652, "twfe_se": 0.051856524198979286, "x": -5.398063150512583, "y": -3.8000669939090383, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5979961566035454, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0006513060327783259, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.8000669939090383, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0006513; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P042", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1991390977895775, "modern": -0.1032364219762335, "twfe_se": 0.07237834054272763, "x": -2.751363132897725, "y": -1.4263441411079216, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3250189917898032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8339898457445425, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.751363132897725, "display_y": -1.4263441411079216, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.834; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P043", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113344233100728, "modern": -0.013069438910426293, "twfe_se": 0.07177601502906009, "x": -1.4090144498835886, "y": -0.1820864379993072, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2269280118842814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40992872560893645, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.4090144498835886, "display_y": -0.1820864379993072, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4099; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P044", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10837223305188158, "modern": -0.11974799382173384, "twfe_se": 0.04140854184295684, "x": -2.6171468066392336, "y": -2.89186695527415, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2747201486349165, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7996425394527843, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.6171468066392336, "display_y": -2.89186695527415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P045", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10566714520974, "modern": -0.07583447636706275, "twfe_se": 0.043653148547609565, "x": -2.420607647452873, "y": -1.7372051934433819, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6834024540094914, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37814114698857904, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.420607647452873, "display_y": -1.7372051934433819, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3781; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P046", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14629841804187504, "modern": -0.08617568094208841, "twfe_se": 0.04993271739678495, "x": -2.9299110016250562, "y": -1.7258359936092136, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2040750080158424, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3283672765607059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.9299110016250562, "display_y": -1.7258359936092136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3284; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P047", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14827651156083027, "modern": -0.04561761497369614, "twfe_se": 0.06730218782328327, "x": -2.203145489863761, "y": -0.677802853801354, "se_normalized_difference": 1.525342636062407, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9827773985566427, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.203145489863761, "display_y": -0.677802853801354, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9828; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P048", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08214515452042444, "modern": 0.004458662587853971, "twfe_se": 0.06549133531049521, "x": -1.2542904207247152, "y": 0.06808019055826847, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223706112829838, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8745609470697958, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2542904207247152, "display_y": 0.06808019055826847, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": 0.17550353597810928, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": 2.1728699927870183, "se_normalized_difference": 0.16007252895007676, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999624123905335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": 2.1728699927870183, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P050", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.106052751043436, "modern": 0.20027928776966455, "twfe_se": 0.08556206429156468, "x": 1.2394833144984259, "y": 2.340748665053065, "se_normalized_difference": 1.101265350554639, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9929672736576767, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.2394833144984259, "display_y": 2.340748665053065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.993; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P051", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1791064414013867, "modern": 0.18109188522066355, "twfe_se": 0.10907175575553293, "x": 1.6420973528914802, "y": 1.6603004505268286, "se_normalized_difference": 0.018203097635348442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9996434964466455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.6420973528914802, "display_y": 1.6603004505268286, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P052", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29588760263791564, "modern": 0.45520704034638326, "twfe_se": 0.1917331060707312, "x": 1.5432264604776254, "y": 2.374170270722341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8309438102447158, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9905191040017244, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.5432264604776254, "display_y": 2.374170270722341, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.21330251090649066, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.97838641702771, "se_normalized_difference": 1.15462796952067, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7240551444770145, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.97838641702771, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7241; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P054", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.31697833977317097, "modern": -0.22634360501738188, "twfe_se": 0.05435043811509917, "x": -5.832121152398049, "y": -4.164522179895751, "se_normalized_difference": 1.6675989725022977, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.022610883654263465, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.164522179895751, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02261; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P055", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1687796323024688, "modern": -0.14439005880064443, "twfe_se": 0.05054143946022593, "x": -3.3394306554187394, "y": -2.856864789422422, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4825658659963176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7349488855609596, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.3394306554187394, "display_y": -2.856864789422422, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7349; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P056", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658618154426823, "modern": -0.24440024114240916, "twfe_se": 0.09394992184708006, "x": -2.3053364737950517, "y": -2.60138844543387, "se_normalized_difference": -0.29605197163881813, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9168659980691416, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3053364737950517, "display_y": -2.60138844543387, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9169; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P058", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.3045492169792317, "modern": -0.18906972486722454, "twfe_se": 0.05422852223290661, "x": -5.616033858920593, "y": -3.48653655091664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1294973080039536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0005341070513687012, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.48653655091664, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0005341; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P060", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09540291291902506, "modern": 0.173457904334113, "twfe_se": 0.09911675406483009, "x": 0.9625306419601283, "y": 1.7500361666470434, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7875055246869153, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2731253467631985, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9625306419601283, "display_y": 1.7500361666470434, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2731; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P062", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.30677046832251936, "modern": -0.011322300818976672, "twfe_se": 0.3383154181902291, "x": 0.9067587577401733, "y": -0.03346670062967787, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9402254583698512, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8243296898940367, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9067587577401733, "display_y": -0.03346670062967787, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8243; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P064", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4225868461420414, "modern": 1.0743855666103255, "twfe_se": 0.15998925084723942, "x": 2.6413452397844828, "y": 6.715360944068474, "se_normalized_difference": 4.0740157042839895, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8319015184116749, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.6413452397844828, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8319; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P065", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T3-C6-TERMINATED-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08618892957737644, "modern": -0.14819726143869597, "twfe_se": 0.1130095983710691, "x": -0.7626691079316422, "y": -1.3113688003039135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5486996923722711, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17373851467052231, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7626691079316422, "display_y": -1.3113688003039135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1737; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P067", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.20669876701357798, "modern": 0.3501846101921218, "twfe_se": 0.1564704858157978, "x": 1.321008022285497, "y": 2.2380234097590175, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9170153874735206, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.3709648141606276e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.321008022285497, "display_y": 2.2380234097590175, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.371e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P069", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2615822418401665, "modern": 0.3868750332009083, "twfe_se": 0.17074781937748124, "x": 1.531979985418571, "y": 2.265768515295784, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7337885298772129, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.967188280417718e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.531979985418571, "display_y": 2.265768515295784, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.967e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P071", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2911068444010106, "modern": 0.4347640408285339, "twfe_se": 0.16302856058516044, "x": 1.7856186876467361, "y": 2.6667967825271224, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8811780948803865, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1205056782398701e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.7856186876467361, "display_y": 2.6667967825271224, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.121e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P073", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C8", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.33394441883176845, "modern": 0.419648540500346, "twfe_se": 0.16330693154006856, "x": 2.04488820947464, "y": 2.5696921529468706, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5248039434722305, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.3171782546872654e-14, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.04488820947464, "display_y": 2.5696921529468706, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.317e-14; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": -0.24338332196265441, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": -3.179768282364263, "se_normalized_difference": -0.28382556804003484, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9859921749777952, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": -3.179768282364263, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.986; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P075", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25765529203915105, "modern": -0.344269166229137, "twfe_se": 0.08021491852307107, "x": -3.2120620052122266, "y": -4.291834643329094, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0797726381168666, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6619100875775956, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.2120620052122266, "display_y": -4.291834643329094, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6619; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.34457526577661013, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 1.5863188700356177, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21498495671490114, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8000304677613004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 1.5863188700356177, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P077", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3348681094062555, "modern": 0.2767375857891446, "twfe_se": 0.1816872107624597, "x": 1.8431022635053085, "y": 1.523153911757471, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3199483517478373, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8576075637925102, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.8431022635053085, "display_y": 1.523153911757471, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8576; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.07573369102387349, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.1016210693909236, "se_normalized_difference": -3.569727963103465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999046342844691, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.1016210693909236, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P079", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.31104951098651784, "modern": 0.17914790760750995, "twfe_se": 0.06478036066813606, "x": 4.801602025342162, "y": 2.7654663506007404, "se_normalized_difference": -2.036135674741422, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.997361150037311, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.801602025342162, "display_y": 2.7654663506007404, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9974; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.10302790726298905, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.25691030838496554, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3741348815843343, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8074659022654093, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.25691030838496554, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8075; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P081", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.46043384283435496, "modern": 0.506695440824378, "twfe_se": 0.35319495551450636, "x": 1.3036251952229372, "y": 1.4346055426705184, "se_normalized_difference": 0.13098034744758127, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9744293819883441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3036251952229372, "display_y": 1.4346055426705184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9744; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": -0.13636564414696845, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": -1.9478414580890306, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5207175730959082, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7146713307312601, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": -1.9478414580890306, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7147; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P083", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1548516162623062, "modern": -0.10001320593217983, "twfe_se": 0.15762235225053767, "x": -0.982421681007352, "y": -0.634511568341594, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3479101126657581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4859193566492677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.982421681007352, "display_y": -0.634511568341594, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": 0.16070124937302005, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": 0.6548286465105709, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3944161269696218, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9384416169802532, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": 0.6548286465105709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9384; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P085", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6055333092652331, "modern": 0.32752083888341826, "twfe_se": 0.3494745746633342, "x": 1.732696319463505, "y": 0.9371807353909364, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7955155840725686, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8013690990268173, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.732696319463505, "display_y": 0.9371807353909364, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8014; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P001", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04554503237764617, "modern": 0.029550752772808053, "twfe_se": 0.02214473217513982, "x": -2.0566982710577126, "y": 1.3344371265859065, "se_normalized_difference": 3.3911353976436196, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.057662324201833e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0566982710577126, "display_y": 1.3344371265859065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.058e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P002", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02025550108463945, "modern": 0.11301216145047226, "twfe_se": 0.019400337721032605, "x": -1.044079818398199, "y": 5.825267738919395, "se_normalized_difference": 6.869347557317594, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.41858595740735e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.044079818398199, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.419e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P003", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04983128423661516, "modern": -0.009579258164665427, "twfe_se": 0.023269833494926877, "x": -2.1414542672803836, "y": -0.41165993588883343, "se_normalized_difference": 1.72979433139155, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.998841751158025e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.1414542672803836, "display_y": -0.41165993588883343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.999e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P004", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04076683043015399, "modern": 0.010150339041711602, "twfe_se": 0.021710065555831447, "x": -1.8777847687891385, "y": 0.46754069054320124, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3453254593323396, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0018548029548275384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8777847687891385, "display_y": 0.46754069054320124, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001855; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P005", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03944842134729418, "modern": -0.11030284624353281, "twfe_se": 0.026703389928004674, "x": -1.4772814033593313, "y": -4.130668298703709, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6533868953443775, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.694515805421165e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.4772814033593313, "display_y": -4.130668298703709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.695e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P006", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.030553147071442598, "modern": -0.10393021827196601, "twfe_se": 0.026538468786438795, "x": -1.1512776911626232, "y": -3.9162100537267825, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7649323625641595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7350396651094451, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1512776911626232, "display_y": -3.9162100537267825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P007", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0561026714314866, "modern": -0.016185880907912578, "twfe_se": 0.02278196935693539, "x": -2.46259094429023, "y": -0.7104689087374793, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7521220355527507, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.579660878741057e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.46259094429023, "display_y": -0.7104689087374793, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.58e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P008", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.040398117292382595, "modern": -0.0021529395683037534, "twfe_se": 0.021098261973614172, "x": -1.9147604358551018, "y": -0.10204345604373737, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8127169798113647, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.011974045630053888, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.9147604358551018, "display_y": -0.10204345604373737, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01197; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P009", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12289171381143947, "modern": -0.18562971917089063, "twfe_se": 0.03767341904728827, "x": 3.2620270981294226, "y": -4.927339324787201, "se_normalized_difference": -8.189366422916622, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.2381304926856194e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2620270981294226, "display_y": -4.927339324787201, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.238e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P010", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0857946819641765, "modern": -0.02319214683225769, "twfe_se": 0.02708791177167179, "x": 3.1672682149644156, "y": -0.8561806841275876, "se_normalized_difference": -4.023448899092004, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.34142504222450115, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1672682149644156, "display_y": -0.8561806841275876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3414; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P011", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1292085737760996, "modern": -0.17418418270666433, "twfe_se": 0.038865479579806766, "x": 3.3245073822074267, "y": -4.481719628571488, "se_normalized_difference": -7.8062270107789145, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.8645232175731985e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.3245073822074267, "display_y": -4.481719628571488, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.865e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P012", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09307990409843145, "modern": -0.023350193242507977, "twfe_se": 0.027324633105262498, "x": 3.406446620522236, "y": -0.8545473658349295, "se_normalized_difference": -4.260993986357166, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3017849118765784, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.406446620522236, "display_y": -0.8545473658349295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3018; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P013", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12085226786022098, "modern": -0.1856924837110375, "twfe_se": 0.038486828046456936, "x": 3.140094260673855, "y": -4.824832108452549, "se_normalized_difference": -7.964926369126403, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.617018334686794e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.140094260673855, "display_y": -4.824832108452549, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.617e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P014", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08796266153707287, "modern": -0.020070455626947314, "twfe_se": 0.02834927992300201, "x": 3.1028181941828374, "y": -0.7079705615613386, "se_normalized_difference": -3.810788755744176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.30425121086324036, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1028181941828374, "display_y": -0.7079705615613386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3043; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P015", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12565713848218707, "modern": -0.18256258165552525, "twfe_se": 0.03829978372654898, "x": 3.280883761102885, "y": -4.766673957194565, "se_normalized_difference": -8.047557718297451, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.4639532829167243e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.280883761102885, "display_y": -4.766673957194565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.464e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P016", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09121693194489162, "modern": -0.021343277699230473, "twfe_se": 0.02830998448046361, "x": 3.2220763670089387, "y": -0.7539134369345635, "se_normalized_difference": -3.975989803943502, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.31275516804953524, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2220763670089387, "display_y": -0.7539134369345635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3128; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P001", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113341599942652, "modern": 0.027090612439988726, "twfe_se": 0.04422121045668668, "x": -2.28698886699367, "y": 0.6126158049545738, "se_normalized_difference": 2.8996046719482442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0019379119886445725, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.28698886699367, "display_y": 0.6126158049545738, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001938; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P002", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20999936204812777, "modern": -0.05455407583706689, "twfe_se": 0.1608196559046698, "x": -1.3058065624304693, "y": -0.33922517449860295, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9665813879318663, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.3058065624304693, "display_y": -0.33922517449860295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P004", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14123366851820662, "modern": -0.016239084998918595, "twfe_se": 0.05193064802837583, "x": -2.7196592740578556, "y": -0.31270715108437064, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4069521229734847, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.797442420089926e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.7196592740578556, "display_y": -0.31270715108437064, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.797e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P006", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.032262235476981815, "modern": 0.07063437888563168, "twfe_se": 0.029038712745296222, "x": -1.111007769523384, "y": 2.4324211443247687, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5434289138481523, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0014348250836651384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.111007769523384, "display_y": 2.4324211443247687, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001435; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P007", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21617031982145912, "modern": -0.13345018549320065, "twfe_se": 0.12472637721842869, "x": -1.7331564071879362, "y": -1.0699435714347276, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6632128357532086, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.7331564071879362, "display_y": -1.0699435714347276, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P009", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08543758521702213, "modern": -0.02445158515512512, "twfe_se": 0.040893257759548066, "x": -2.0892829257916854, "y": -0.5979368359180427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4913460898736428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17464635282314106, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0892829257916854, "display_y": -0.5979368359180427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P011", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.012582455766935948, "modern": 0.13060802678741046, "twfe_se": 0.03446282272370412, "x": -0.3651022978533189, "y": 3.7898238294211466, "se_normalized_difference": 4.154926127274465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.0512315146171582e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -0.3651022978533189, "display_y": 3.7898238294211466, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.051e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P012", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2531616672939931, "modern": -0.11174530127867455, "twfe_se": 0.13764845254350458, "x": -1.8391900716354215, "y": -0.8118166184495014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.02737345318592, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8391900716354215, "display_y": -0.8118166184495014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P014", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08296560274959391, "modern": 0.04343236573361355, "twfe_se": 0.04480111686807485, "x": -1.8518646085074493, "y": 0.9694482809771945, "se_normalized_difference": 2.821312889484644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.1353089477552046e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8518646085074493, "display_y": 0.9694482809771945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.135e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P016", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.021554538786991286, "modern": -0.01927011682842492, "twfe_se": 0.012795115243670585, "x": -1.6845912191102588, "y": -1.5060526194132837, "se_normalized_difference": 0.17853859969697514, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9895992509023763, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6845912191102588, "display_y": -1.5060526194132837, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9896; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P017", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02325612733538412, "modern": -0.003759562756685654, "twfe_se": 0.013863174184456761, "x": -1.6775470773106664, "y": -0.2711906167132225, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4063564605974441, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6775470773106664, "display_y": -0.2711906167132225, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P019", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018531623316536978, "modern": 0.0015926812435597668, "twfe_se": 0.011687651791437265, "x": -1.5855728462165357, "y": 0.1362704221498637, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7218432683663996, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9881657238350432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.5855728462165357, "display_y": 0.1362704221498637, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9882; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P021", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T3-R3-NOTEXAS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00909454819923924, "modern": -0.034258677903352436, "twfe_se": 0.02098480773457043, "x": 0.43338725397311395, "y": -1.6325466659822951, "se_normalized_difference": -2.0659339199554094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6636804273830385, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": 0.43338725397311395, "display_y": -1.6325466659822951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6637; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.21942540341940092, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -4.183521304173129, "se_normalized_difference": -0.533622863721691, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7746975579662475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -4.183521304173129, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7747; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.39004080168212313, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -4.6945839576442845, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4542001499974968, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.13655863769778254, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -4.6945839576442845, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1366; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.29713651030571087, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -3.300894888930935, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3702091580447464, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4673589737110796, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -3.300894888930935, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4674; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.08217984532708654, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 4.268427836198346, "se_normalized_difference": 4.233769081212633, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5483424989161068, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 4.268427836198346, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5483; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.7556108038524608, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -7.9040677243779935, "se_normalized_difference": -5.2058390898486975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.03837020810449744, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03837; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.0006006236053846155, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 0.00698211411303128, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1700982524934386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.32226475891060424, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 0.00698211411303128, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3223; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.7527971699077467, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -7.704823329530131, "se_normalized_difference": -5.0557270090267945, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.02415707991283878, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02416; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.31707319306393916, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -8.256140032352649, "se_normalized_difference": -6.366720071619492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.024815342319498553, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02482; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.06979885590258547, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -1.8955743108907968, "se_normalized_difference": -1.774024555430823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5449672404714518, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -1.8955743108907968, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.545; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.2891986864187225, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -7.975017752597051, "se_normalized_difference": -6.194704159920209, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.031737607081148915, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03174; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0732397096110735, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.727415759980426, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0483174410274692, "homogeneity_pvalue": 9.006184276208503e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.727415759980426, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 9.006e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.3195547289469939, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 1.0028908207552323, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5890444720030076, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0003085680686237034, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 1.0028908207552323, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0003086; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 0.6109798366681785, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 1.7683050110499188, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6096230865684332, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1443603186589448e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 1.7683050110499188, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.144e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 0.5029079612799268, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 1.3794392032159444, "se_normalized_difference": -0.497469958736628, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.874202670498193e-20, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 1.3794392032159444, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.874e-20; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P001", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-LAND-EXPROPRIATION", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.014222863663783235, "modern": 0.08590158133443866, "twfe_se": 0.05506328730150922, "x": -0.25830030063231263, "y": 1.5600518157237626, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8183521163560752, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.25830030063231263, "display_y": 1.5600518157237626, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P002", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-ONE-CHILD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13470016920109934, "modern": 0.45462879236198217, "twfe_se": 0.21610578173287492, "x": -0.6233066423350032, "y": 2.1037326660882303, "se_normalized_difference": 2.727039308423233, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9990884746380607, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.6233066423350032, "display_y": 2.1037326660882303, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9991; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P003", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-PUBLIC-GOODS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00022117981059667995, "modern": 0.024392634950034197, "twfe_se": 0.017307556205773494, "x": -0.012779378438355051, "y": 1.409363324320579, "se_normalized_difference": 1.422142702758934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.454558695624506e-13, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.012779378438355051, "display_y": 1.409363324320579, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.455e-13; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P004", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-VC-UNILATERAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18886559326788294, "modern": -0.02743138018452337, "twfe_se": 0.15723477497681523, "x": 1.2011693551616158, "y": -0.1744612805186907, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3756306356803065, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999986824082961, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": 1.2011693551616158, "display_y": -0.1744612805186907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.2766581646581663, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 9.636297708898367, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7570821868595536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5e-324, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.941e-324; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.12953180482722826, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 2.8884240238938004, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7714333905217267, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.210703514378873e-222, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 2.8884240238938004, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.211e-222; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.26912176061253434, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 9.2839051347098, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4932417463303462, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.1173112187944399, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 2.5635974610464127, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06993961363032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.8236958397887627e-228, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 2.5635974610464127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.824e-228; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P001", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C1-LOGPAY", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11362857677249297, "modern": 0.02654938615172501, "twfe_se": 0.0007785365526435424, "x": 145.95149885598047, "y": 34.101656578070525, "se_normalized_difference": -111.84984227790997, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P002", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C3-TRANSFER-NONSES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06328442003596428, "modern": 0.2187590186566654, "twfe_se": 0.002687404261144327, "x": 23.548530063361984, "y": 81.40160444767447, "se_normalized_difference": 57.8530743843125, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P003", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C5-TRANSFER-SES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.010174911842129224, "modern": 0.002885450203221245, "twfe_se": 0.017429567710625926, "x": 0.5837730465297826, "y": 0.16554915481134577, "se_normalized_difference": -0.41822389171843677, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09480814692180335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 0.5837730465297826, "display_y": 0.16554915481134577, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09481; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P001", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-ANNOTATED-SCALAR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5836461717054291, "modern": 0.7570914198400018, "twfe_se": 0.15493282774663392, "x": 3.7670917144808223, "y": 4.886578466624872, "se_normalized_difference": 1.11948675214405, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7040545930389419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 3.7670917144808223, "display_y": 4.886578466624872, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7041; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P001", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4317959225682691, "modern": 0.2950029536826313, "twfe_se": 0.15175510253551105, "x": 2.845346979138496, "y": 1.9439409202968967, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9014060588415992, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.19866011805386e-06, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.845346979138496, "display_y": 1.9439409202968967, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.199e-06; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P002", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6914907581397147, "modern": 0.6098171388765059, "twfe_se": 0.23881176300149767, "x": 2.895547310772033, "y": 2.553547326195492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3419999845765412, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0006442741347147e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.895547310772033, "display_y": 2.553547326195492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.001e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P001", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C4-ALL-OPIOIDS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2053142392239101, "modern": -0.1461503407935394, "twfe_se": 0.031203796039542576, "x": -6.5797840417790345, "y": -4.683735934189943, "se_normalized_difference": 1.896048107589092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.683735934189943, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P002", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C9-OXYCONTIN", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18941714291972508, "modern": -0.06487917894497999, "twfe_se": 0.05441628787667782, "x": -3.480890562564578, "y": -1.192274987445192, "se_normalized_difference": 2.288615575119386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -3.480890562564578, "display_y": -1.192274987445192, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 6, "study": "Railroads of the Raj", "specification_id": "S06-P001", "source_specification_id": "RRR-T4-C1-REAL-INCOME", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00357296649567496, "modern": 0.012993242286345331, "twfe_se": 0.20218780330947986, "x": -0.017671523391576592, "y": 0.06426323484239628, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08193475823397287, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999999900060716, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 6 (2018)", "display_x": -0.017671523391576592, "display_y": 0.06426323484239628, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 19 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.42594215301121846, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 3.0029270883907704, "se_normalized_difference": 0.44412233935242995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 3.0029270883907704, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.2847501748827035, "se_normalized_difference": 0.39889329152629266, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.2847501748827035, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 1.1814139520448312, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3347048082591956, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 1.1814139520448312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": 0.2208707981145346, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": 1.3905677584074576, "se_normalized_difference": -0.47112704329156324, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": 1.3905677584074576, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 1.5744969021871882, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3918160548713041, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 1.5744969021871882, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.908486123049834, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12875187161505738, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.908486123049834, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.12334687831890981, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.0571567897993446, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25207684340939934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.0571567897993446, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": -0.02158858000909039, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": -0.09431343900620366, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31881155493175717, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": -0.09431343900620366, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": -0.19720465361266512, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": -0.9300878109696857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11687930840934309, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": -0.9300878109696857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": 0.8617823674953772, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08725381187999684, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": 0.8617823674953772, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 0.4636211521472953, "se_normalized_difference": -0.034013242652897, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 0.4636211521472953, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.062037859929712315, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -0.6674725889205914, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1557707726822974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -0.6674725889205914, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P001", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F1B-SIZE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2985242372686371, "modern": 0.29781256170431736, "twfe_se": 0.07399533091199685, "x": 4.034365865917594, "y": 4.024748021716503, "se_normalized_difference": -0.009617844201090544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 4.034365865917594, "display_y": 4.024748021716503, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P002", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F2A-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2407326507382832, "modern": 0.23333207064136352, "twfe_se": 0.07563931534096853, "x": 3.1826392088968998, "y": 3.084798819100149, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09784038979675042, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1826392088968998, "display_y": 3.084798819100149, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P005", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C1-VANISH-CONFLICT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.029729548421959906, "modern": -0.03784763410230067, "twfe_se": 0.014259074918511055, "x": -2.0849563237349407, "y": -2.654283978350312, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5693276546153714, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0849563237349407, "display_y": -2.654283978350312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P006", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C3-VANISH-PURCHASE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00822835391523646, "modern": 0.008619450261432418, "twfe_se": 0.01566429802296934, "x": -0.5252934988322372, "y": 0.5502608702153962, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0755543690476335, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -0.5252934988322372, "display_y": 0.5502608702153962, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P007", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C5-VANISH-EXTINCTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03852214346804064, "modern": 0.021842430436026128, "twfe_se": 0.028415889530356387, "x": 1.3556550262798515, "y": 0.7686695998973425, "se_normalized_difference": -0.586985426382509, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.3556550262798515, "display_y": 0.7686695998973425, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P008", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C1-SIZE-SINGLE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22154054083078928, "modern": 0.21409243802411873, "twfe_se": 0.06337713349981079, "x": 3.4955910530641257, "y": 3.3780707047086294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11752034835549613, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.4955910530641257, "display_y": 3.3780707047086294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P009", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C3-SIZE-UNCONTESTED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18935657850842058, "modern": 0.18408504027258502, "twfe_se": 0.058511023120722476, "x": 3.2362547842947795, "y": 3.1461599960877935, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09009478820698623, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.2362547842947795, "display_y": 3.1461599960877935, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P010", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C5-SIZE-ALL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18010933839074345, "modern": 0.17835022690352453, "twfe_se": 0.061075085940861945, "x": 2.9489821523156023, "y": 2.920179712497143, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028802439818459397, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 2.9489821523156023, "display_y": 2.920179712497143, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P011", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T4-C1-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18420481067124622, "modern": 0.16377852353219974, "twfe_se": 0.05919483001785045, "x": 3.1118395071951133, "y": 2.7667707379649817, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3450687692301313, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1118395071951133, "display_y": 2.7667707379649817, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P014", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T9-C1-VANISH-NOEXT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02920270024836768, "modern": -0.0264029996624148, "twfe_se": 0.013853448593025026, "x": -2.1079733361894264, "y": -1.9058792101562536, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2020941260331727, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1079733361894264, "display_y": -1.9058792101562536, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.2413395907640687, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -2.9015929435621812, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8464469197062248, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2047592728987791, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -2.9015929435621812, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2048; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.2139493432167725, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -3.0784826173169857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.990609631562876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -3.0784826173169857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.1300820525159727, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -1.838100744312126, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5383408583452726, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24264765541323957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -1.838100744312126, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P005", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1976322869564458, "modern": -0.2806193113899418, "twfe_se": 0.08995321908555387, "x": -2.1970563028820473, "y": -3.1196138864474294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.922557583565382, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16617954483812042, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1970563028820473, "display_y": -3.1196138864474294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1662; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.3140427393678433, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -3.2242629699367296, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6987952305532722, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -3.2242629699367296, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.23839113430397812, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -2.4538694021145138, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25048152488725295, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.14208227793353256, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -2.4538694021145138, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1421; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P003", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8A-INITIAL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.05065020247399928, "modern": 0.05315485520642897, "twfe_se": 0.02398136966268965, "x": 2.1120646229310727, "y": 2.216506227712573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.10444160478150014, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9775744925581922, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 2.1120646229310727, "display_y": 2.216506227712573, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9776; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P004", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8B-FULL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07467736218313017, "modern": -0.08795761261594937, "twfe_se": 0.04482978193546973, "x": -1.6657980244165491, "y": -1.9620352546563806, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2962372302398316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45013102997146764, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6657980244165491, "display_y": -1.9620352546563806, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P006", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C1-INITIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13734681236512186, "modern": 0.1349766057015137, "twfe_se": 0.03220903817063694, "x": 4.264232034421095, "y": 4.19064378720144, "se_normalized_difference": -0.07358824721965558, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9994420850606988, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 4.264232034421095, "display_y": 4.19064378720144, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9994; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P007", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C2-FULL-EXCL-PARTIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.039721651217501285, "modern": -0.05744106277769158, "twfe_se": 0.050805728533818637, "x": -0.7818341034330553, "y": -1.1306020882951449, "se_normalized_difference": -0.34876798486208965, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.33223047213496354, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7818341034330553, "display_y": -1.1306020882951449, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3322; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P008", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C3-FULL-DROP-LIMITED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03441024653904987, "modern": -0.0451620507156221, "twfe_se": 0.049669708930519536, "x": -0.6927813204459209, "y": -0.9092473398383918, "se_normalized_difference": -0.21646601939247087, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16306560648547455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6927813204459209, "display_y": -0.9092473398383918, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1631; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P009", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C4-FULL-DMSP-2013", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06437742135856342, "modern": -0.06775557959636926, "twfe_se": 0.05407466514201637, "x": -1.1905283405729634, "y": -1.2530004470378628, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0624721064648995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0008678643456103258, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.1905283405729634, "display_y": -1.2530004470378628, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0008679; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P010", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C5-FULL-DMSP-RAW", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.034129483049029005, "modern": 0.009146639060140477, "twfe_se": 0.04398867224053275, "x": -0.7758698162655809, "y": 0.20793169228036926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.98380150854595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7657199822961114, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7758698162655809, "display_y": 0.20793169228036926, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7657; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P011", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C7-FULL-DISTRICT-YEAR", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04961829037148674, "modern": -0.06304837327176609, "twfe_se": 0.05810665275823827, "x": -0.8539175467210497, "y": -1.0850456923424692, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2311281456214194, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6646258531167744, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.8539175467210497, "display_y": -1.0850456923424692, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6646; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P001", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20015904475694235, "modern": -0.2302701389429832, "twfe_se": 0.09099161176045499, "x": -2.1997527121937583, "y": -2.530674360942123, "se_normalized_difference": -0.33092164874836466, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07256341097820927, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.1997527121937583, "display_y": -2.530674360942123, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07256; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P002", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5866666266332619, "modern": -0.3587760057249104, "twfe_se": 0.21439777269866464, "x": -2.7363466478628946, "y": -1.673412933394457, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0629337144684379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6478429577611663, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.7363466478628946, "display_y": -1.673412933394457, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6478; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P003", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2180655094585218, "modern": -0.04366520037802251, "twfe_se": 0.3747435754693577, "x": -0.5819059317705441, "y": -0.11652021071564163, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4653857210549024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.654702301900471, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.5819059317705441, "display_y": -0.11652021071564163, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6547; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P004", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.32443914047906564, "modern": -0.553339409278403, "twfe_se": 0.09291827843087484, "x": -3.491661123709123, "y": -5.9551190424825995, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4634579187734764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8117889624508522, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -3.491661123709123, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8118; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P005", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.7502544624743879, "modern": -0.7502544624743879, "twfe_se": 0.16706519637830788, "x": -4.490788498973102, "y": -4.490788498973102, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -4.490788498973102, "display_y": -4.490788498973102, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P006", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08658480067380339, "modern": -0.08658461544704904, "twfe_se": 0.36856303915072125, "x": -0.23492534919757688, "y": -0.23492484663292804, "se_normalized_difference": 5.025646488535392e-07, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.23492534919757688, "display_y": -0.23492484663292804, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P007", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PC-C1-TRIPS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5245447118342563, "modern": 0.5367294072304346, "twfe_se": 0.12450377843848578, "x": 4.213082674381813, "y": 4.3109487435806555, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09786606919884311, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.7090130611501043e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": 4.213082674381813, "display_y": 4.3109487435806555, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.709e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.02295029924928877, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 0.9944551499490927, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09789785511577183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.014525389094489763, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 0.9944551499490927, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01453; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.02491540528604237, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 1.1500765083806341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3557365880040043, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.23734132618960652, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 1.1500765083806341, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.03117275671188908, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 1.4240415652910021, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3880859137597521, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4570063473046029, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 1.4240415652910021, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.457; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P002", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-BASELINE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.7888758993762184, "modern": 0.7967550027391155, "twfe_se": 0.11904766121821768, "x": 6.626555207415515, "y": 6.692739652219134, "se_normalized_difference": 0.06618444480361932, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8081640057069475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8082; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P001", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C1", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.41430806278014465, "modern": 0.42527348656207975, "twfe_se": 0.1373506360351823, "x": 3.0164262411862426, "y": 3.096261501498589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.07983526031234624, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45211921681332806, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 3.0164262411862426, "display_y": 3.096261501498589, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4521; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P002", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C2", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.34659086917588267, "modern": 0.3645272632101659, "twfe_se": 0.1851776291667871, "x": 1.8716670622438565, "y": 1.9685275421786552, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09686047993479888, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2838842303671143, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 1.8716670622438565, "display_y": 1.9685275421786552, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2839; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 11, "study": "Hall of Mirrors", "specification_id": "S11-P001", "source_specification_id": "HALL-MIRRORS-F1-COCOMMENT", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1472449898121927, "modern": 0.1605524415240668, "twfe_se": 0.03234331016239992, "x": 4.552564010079879, "y": 4.964007725799009, "se_normalized_difference": 0.41144371571912974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.705583964423773e-89, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 11 (2021)", "display_x": 4.552564010079879, "display_y": 4.964007725799009, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.706e-89; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 18 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": -0.5138179527233715, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": -6.0305967709411, "se_normalized_difference": -0.046896934516610075, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5.812088427359851e-72, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 5.812e-72; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 20 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#B5BD35", "#5C7C28", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#8C564B", "#D55E00", "#A95E00", "#56B4E9", "#009E73", "#B51F45", "#E6679E", "#8C2981", "#F09556", "#008F9C", "#332288", "#E63228", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#2DB6A4", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "homogeneity_test", "title": "Homogeneity F-test", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "!datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.3885253830076921, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 3.4147827899666137, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5288892869379433, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7528002318625951, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 3.4147827899666137, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7528; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.3328428430090348, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 2.4813782064818644, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7520064855512179, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40501845027573946, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 2.4813782064818644, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.405; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.385059491047323, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 3.1121304142542905, "se_normalized_difference": -0.025394052809753983, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47578789224074497, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 3.1121304142542905, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4758; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.20535587329137728, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.9403105956474556, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20629487713198497, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4755457444652286, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.9403105956474556, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4755; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.35038915647090907, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 3.6672865385561884, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4501909985412788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4912213849296376, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 3.6672865385561884, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4912; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.22224621433890407, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4105115212167811, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22319664872739578, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16584271954927018, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4105115212167811, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1658; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.42594215301119437, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 3.063135126493506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6077352836076337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 3.063135126493506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.0636290695671966, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.47601221502014696, "se_normalized_difference": 0.30256851691010567, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6238759371413234, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.47601221502014696, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6239; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.06153564561861635, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 0.6641303289063571, "se_normalized_difference": 0.28850940807882325, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9007339476341801, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 0.6641303289063571, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9007; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.2860739583907882, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.5245967953100297, "se_normalized_difference": 1.111778291083094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.744755025448304, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.5245967953100297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7448; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": -0.07239225849517301, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": -0.8438784517311982, "se_normalized_difference": -1.6804077637082337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1883135791121969, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": -0.8438784517311982, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1883; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": 0.2604059077160187, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": 2.7656284795470314, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0880875836783972, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7555106259415197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": 2.7656284795470314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7555; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.11764988087499709, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.883643182599003, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3382433676435073, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8775181204600441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.883643182599003, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8775; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.08860159710440971, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 0.9719592159911877, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31164434620889925, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11053990821571197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 0.9719592159911877, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1105; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": -0.10398415086730348, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": -1.0277453468056132, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4194402699439226, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6613097442013468, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": -1.0277453468056132, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.17528994011918686, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.579283320391719, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9192786009535644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8426154697309903, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.579283320391719, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.06328050733614857, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 0.6347730868317343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6451137650494003, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.904975638165574, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 0.6347730868317343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.039867497536061294, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.393115506998779, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4617745654598037, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9224037401332055, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.393115506998779, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9224; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 1.651153141158054, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22967394938499702, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 1.651153141158054, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.1685790387984038, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 1.8258833684449844, "se_normalized_difference": 0.27500155858422975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.12359234733591484, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 1.8258833684449844, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1236; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.04003771997148135, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 0.4431815934837828, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8604278797423379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8852716493371069, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 0.4431815934837828, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8853; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 1.2949695075512722, "se_normalized_difference": -0.39946129871962477, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 1.2949695075512722, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.5524011544647354, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 4.982732437148825, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1005293228826023, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.01714325715860586, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 4.982732437148825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01714; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.1065328086513135, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -1.014751306568505, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4016095808936353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9650240752385251, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -1.014751306568505, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.965; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": 0.2006988537785288, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": 1.612275723179677, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5748925503596426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6742386532450715, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": 1.612275723179677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6742; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": 0.06975588945735992, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": 0.4730545873038456, "se_normalized_difference": -0.578305632692984, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8493619630133346, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": 0.4730545873038456, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.24343173113939617, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 2.1429167471879733, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12928298396029417, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.368668192626714, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 2.1429167471879733, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3687; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": 0.22087079811454136, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": 1.6320398924198933, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5537940866718213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": 1.6320398924198933, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 2.448405761746198, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1714667306431985, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 2.448405761746198, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0894488186393951, "se_normalized_difference": -0.049675814622635504, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0894488186393951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.1508950291473108, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -2.3110066391030823, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2759274864151426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09612628893524412, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -2.3110066391030823, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.20707550078154957, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.3262722628899362, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2557703864165844, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3428608116390395, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.3262722628899362, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.11579504661744161, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 1.0937022099197315, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5151283473619641, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6833402896734146, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 1.0937022099197315, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1085905496696486, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.0565407513080447, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2346447510359829, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.05372630452950017, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.0565407513080447, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.12334687831889027, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.080433657834606, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22961822897067982, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.080433657834606, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": -0.021588580009078137, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": -0.15510186540209908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.022122764010544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": -0.15510186540209908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.2200701629813498, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -1.8561175264468608, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7136746991547429, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5312685394334519, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -1.8561175264468608, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5313; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": 0.019629505394895136, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": 0.15288052365790902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2693180289941803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.35019378980996957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": 0.15288052365790902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": -0.18143225297181387, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": -1.3874157380204908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2610500940171219, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.44892433741068394, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": -1.3874157380204908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4489; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": -0.1972046536126607, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": -1.3696511938562184, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6484590274995803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": -1.3696511938562184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.06076953126919374, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -0.5599313788877915, "se_normalized_difference": -0.014511269968484064, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6140200715446021, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -0.5599313788877915, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.614; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.08678442257440994, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.663058341854694, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8057170383258024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5307579151547169, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.663058341854694, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5308; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": 0.08080864784158243, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": 0.7545368107908907, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18806120158701928, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0502924517983174, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": 0.7545368107908907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05029; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.13312774663920757, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 1.37254658344467, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5497262605136766, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0384481776614768, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 1.37254658344467, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03845; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": 1.036530243767059, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0835143109148764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": 1.036530243767059, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.11748987923104534, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 0.7922914922158757, "se_normalized_difference": -0.006987762485435748, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.08317218243244932, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 0.7922914922158757, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.08317; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": -0.006545688292584825, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": -0.04810912669492938, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1143899187070034, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8156953081194223, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": -0.04810912669492938, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8157; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 0.49425217077821487, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6924049321882342, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 0.49425217077821487, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.06203785992970153, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -0.6726159239003874, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9228038799524354, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -0.6726159239003874, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P062", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3008887212720041, "modern": 0.3473935080976446, "twfe_se": 0.31083588666172546, "x": 0.9679986584028292, "y": 1.1176106846237603, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1496120262209312, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6998373490996154, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9679986584028292, "display_y": 1.1176106846237603, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P063", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.49306361679116867, "modern": 0.6471186994364466, "twfe_se": 0.18166472287589872, "x": 2.714140692730955, "y": 3.562159395572442, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8480187028414876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9989912166654179, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.714140692730955, "display_y": 3.562159395572442, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P064", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13450188332648486, "modern": -0.06464438569611686, "twfe_se": 0.4167804498641, "x": 0.3227163926963033, "y": -0.15510416987455988, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4778205625708632, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06784394081766397, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3227163926963033, "display_y": -0.15510416987455988, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06784; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P065", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658198080855093, "modern": -0.12842303879624975, "twfe_se": 0.4081892333040155, "x": -0.5305920958656024, "y": -0.3146164286518588, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21597566721374353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8829318262431582, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5305920958656024, "display_y": -0.3146164286518588, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8829; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P066", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13997365996268946, "modern": 0.1807103456031524, "twfe_se": 0.20009060583611854, "x": 0.6995513826237947, "y": 0.9031425780736589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20359119544986423, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8155361799666327, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6995513826237947, "display_y": 0.9031425780736589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8155; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P067", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4448736019775512, "modern": 0.34165081521349516, "twfe_se": 0.28926475842925403, "x": 1.53794608231322, "y": 1.1811007226345316, "se_normalized_difference": -0.35684535967868836, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8251925142753511, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.53794608231322, "display_y": 1.1811007226345316, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8252; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P068", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5483851615815729, "modern": 0.5148405121812912, "twfe_se": 0.27592838943462955, "x": 1.9874184120930816, "y": 1.8658482848980735, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12157012719500823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6503824307717044, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9874184120930816, "display_y": 1.8658482848980735, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6504; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P069", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18640506753037372, "modern": -0.5597970757619195, "twfe_se": 0.3193859691436377, "x": -0.5836357433927901, "y": -1.752729079686533, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1690933362937428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4502524658648966, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5836357433927901, "display_y": -1.752729079686533, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4503; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P070", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18520047564986342, "modern": 0.012421380811847016, "twfe_se": 0.39534645345353947, "x": -0.46845108646365513, "y": 0.03141897620009068, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4998700626637458, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4205575876619039, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.46845108646365513, "display_y": 0.03141897620009068, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4206; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P071", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22194506642235692, "modern": 0.38764788926886995, "twfe_se": 0.24948117419673407, "x": -0.8896265104449809, "y": 1.5538161968212534, "se_normalized_difference": 2.443442707266234, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8641356346203798, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8896265104449809, "display_y": 1.5538161968212534, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8641; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P072", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04440438154510488, "modern": 0.16878837243409034, "twfe_se": 0.2581006713311633, "x": 0.1720428750382078, "y": 0.653963321999739, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48192044696153113, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.030267294207242283, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1720428750382078, "display_y": 0.653963321999739, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03027; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P073", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.161233735547124, "modern": 0.16128810371104074, "twfe_se": 0.23175829526333874, "x": 0.6956977974139817, "y": 0.6959323873511185, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0002345899371367215, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.49816860286009496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6956977974139817, "display_y": 0.6959323873511185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4982; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.45984172770274206, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 3.260354618668821, "se_normalized_difference": 0.34959121811943566, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8734628894882257, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 3.260354618668821, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.34450545002681265, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 2.398021338683492, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1573927097569581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5421794687577995, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 2.398021338683492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5422; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.17714854287302012, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 1.819861143119684, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6158213790525858, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6432918537486636, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 1.819861143119684, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6433; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": 0.07075989313060833, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": 0.4681427154307966, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0920789767934687, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8612826733542684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": 0.4681427154307966, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.3223054726379633, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 2.7365508733470856, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4893059853913318, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8936855951413996, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 2.7365508733470856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.025541150642906123, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.14216282734383506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.015522274289653934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8330329896265545, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.14216282734383506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.07159163451959023, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.4469922187214222, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5520585507711355, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.00020231659013051603, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.4469922187214222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0002023; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": -0.02067761653089223, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": -0.11699838816876441, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0678679329240792, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4581735747017874, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": -0.11699838816876441, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4582; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": -0.25577428336671953, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": -1.2592413191907492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6164680810767089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7499233525260419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": -1.2592413191907492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7499; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": 0.04879427886184874, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": 0.3230439185568635, "se_normalized_difference": -0.08789101633244381, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1285965376483094, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": 0.3230439185568635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1286; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.11425085708872226, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 0.9064489961403578, "se_normalized_difference": -0.443019344105053, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.055514115135109246, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 0.9064489961403578, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05551; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.06042820415359978, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -0.4088311916526365, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6401967941459146, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8391664853751086, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -0.4088311916526365, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8392; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P086", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5308687052782026, "modern": 0.6101266467133601, "twfe_se": 0.24844672525912923, "x": 2.136750664451335, "y": 2.4557644946899573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31901383023862245, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.10106640442242432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.136750664451335, "display_y": 2.4557644946899573, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1011; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P087", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15166924638969265, "modern": 0.22914942410328415, "twfe_se": 0.17916704385202792, "x": 0.8465242442407801, "y": 1.2789708373630149, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4324465931222347, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8016167718102788, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8465242442407801, "display_y": 1.2789708373630149, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8016; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P088", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3320653723940968, "modern": 0.3871365784380185, "twfe_se": 0.21620740446726425, "x": 1.5358649404829912, "y": 1.7905796491656902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25471470868269924, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.015974233938446332, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5358649404829912, "display_y": 1.7905796491656902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01597; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P089", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38234882585818836, "modern": 0.4908149332691468, "twfe_se": 0.2472861682957992, "x": 1.5461795881799167, "y": 1.9848054448481849, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4386258566682682, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7479907029715333, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5461795881799167, "display_y": 1.9848054448481849, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.748; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P090", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.013652890780187027, "modern": 0.07752727058447548, "twfe_se": 0.15900157709156928, "x": 0.08586638591845101, "y": 0.48758806046198766, "se_normalized_difference": 0.40172167454353663, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45023964544400547, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.08586638591845101, "display_y": 0.48758806046198766, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P091", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5533939995776936, "modern": 0.44743787084264147, "twfe_se": 0.11947743667565217, "x": 4.631786678517415, "y": 3.7449570671432313, "se_normalized_difference": -0.886829611374183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3518130830232728, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 4.631786678517415, "display_y": 3.7449570671432313, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P092", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06267395216048637, "modern": 0.5141642001275655, "twfe_se": 0.24040116283962085, "x": 0.2607056946820932, "y": 2.138775844734913, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8780701500528199, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07500784724867739, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2607056946820932, "display_y": 2.138775844734913, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P093", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16706306048849764, "modern": -0.2136394317829444, "twfe_se": 0.1886167895820999, "x": -0.8857274098379218, "y": -1.1326639174396127, "se_normalized_difference": -0.24693650760169092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06517953503926142, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8857274098379218, "display_y": -1.1326639174396127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P094", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1606615496153213, "modern": -0.08054578016886683, "twfe_se": 0.2302547890410383, "x": 0.6977555180695356, "y": -0.3498115305411136, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0475670486106492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11143156050705309, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6977555180695356, "display_y": -0.3498115305411136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1114; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P095", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2020209774341155, "modern": 0.3867152084443397, "twfe_se": 0.20501189505896467, "x": 0.9854110044493325, "y": 1.8863061986384464, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9008951941891138, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8408310081916496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9854110044493325, "display_y": 1.8863061986384464, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8408; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P096", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18439267097790166, "modern": -0.21044983030886144, "twfe_se": 0.24010389880009209, "x": 0.7679703324244018, "y": -0.8764948481077339, "se_normalized_difference": -1.644465180532136, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1096167789729291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7679703324244018, "display_y": -0.8764948481077339, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1096; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P097", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19717701724999584, "modern": 0.09528105206321572, "twfe_se": 0.20729820707749333, "x": 0.9511757001173005, "y": 0.45963278412532166, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4915429159919788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37850866874177913, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9511757001173005, "display_y": 0.45963278412532166, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3785; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8648815281075595, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 52.68648865332906, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2784374559434193, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47983688921801004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4798; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.1506838359231915, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 1.4883319133012118, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0488170221190814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1078307178723161, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 1.4883319133012118, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1078; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.18632123492718622, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.432185451343945, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6053175924336561, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9766705419510177, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.432185451343945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9767; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2221519598503761, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.2290980840968975, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5557647120017833, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.29345806370975447, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.2290980840968975, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2935; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": -0.10378186951570695, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": -0.9703913291942493, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2994228674763574, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2937123391699629, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": -0.9703913291942493, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.05493625656459516, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 0.45011780174715565, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9177591117655919, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4327564058760361, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 0.45011780174715565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4328; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P019", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09881088092328953, "modern": -0.19702122681021703, "twfe_se": 0.041534411407364795, "x": -2.3790124278917455, "y": -4.743566121061767, "se_normalized_difference": -2.3645536931700213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9429154965763455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3790124278917455, "display_y": -4.743566121061767, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P020", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08182840209484749, "modern": -0.1044007606091853, "twfe_se": 0.04813993283519639, "x": -1.6998029967133763, "y": -2.1686935244923133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4688905277789369, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9979580492039667, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6998029967133763, "display_y": -2.1686935244923133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P022", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17108040462993862, "modern": -0.15152466684137159, "twfe_se": 0.09706403855215703, "x": -1.7625518902967254, "y": -1.5610793564905123, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20147253380621316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9954625342637035, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7625518902967254, "display_y": -1.5610793564905123, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9955; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P023", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22004242857243222, "modern": -0.2009834428455899, "twfe_se": 0.12222233244634166, "x": -1.8003455192530855, "y": -1.64440850393545, "se_normalized_difference": 0.15593701531763565, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7586733997657202, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.8003455192530855, "display_y": -1.64440850393545, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7587; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P024", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14886186739593033, "modern": -0.10647375061688505, "twfe_se": 0.138167725784353, "x": -1.0773997078613593, "y": -0.7706123120464854, "se_normalized_difference": 0.306787395814874, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7283317035604059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0773997078613593, "display_y": -0.7706123120464854, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7283; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.2030383904269613, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -5.454757808398558, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5366276102184089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.484369966916825, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4844; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.21522117011185216, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -5.140118555774866, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8327432034636664, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11394349161470584, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1139; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.037306221004405324, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.6275662609162148, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1818776506343336, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8589956912870166, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.6275662609162148, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.0025936652535203247, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.03659969088893413, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1819049474612453, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1255451611841135, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.03659969088893413, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1255; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P029", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0949616989865803, "modern": -0.10690884560481552, "twfe_se": 0.038049286231772846, "x": -2.4957550690473416, "y": -2.809746415572492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3139913465251503, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9702899415292684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.4957550690473416, "display_y": -2.809746415572492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9703; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P030", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09127764261905837, "modern": -0.06459281001888015, "twfe_se": 0.038194441354129714, "x": -2.3898148364772225, "y": -1.6911573445986834, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6986574918785391, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.724030079051392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3898148364772225, "display_y": -1.6911573445986834, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.724; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P032", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12649461371178825, "modern": -0.08542924465000176, "twfe_se": 0.04336430141456208, "x": -2.917021826375147, "y": -1.9700362248038876, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9469856015712593, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7412517325644989, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.917021826375147, "display_y": -1.9700362248038876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7413; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P033", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16654716073235562, "modern": -0.08625191848631315, "twfe_se": 0.07374191421984075, "x": -2.2585142044976236, "y": -1.1696457760667476, "se_normalized_difference": 1.088868428430876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8826731469363056, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.2585142044976236, "display_y": -1.1696457760667476, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8827; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P034", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07279015339305425, "modern": 0.01704381018527843, "twfe_se": 0.06863507827387309, "x": -1.0605386520082523, "y": 0.24832506371259427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3088637157208465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5287294560445291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0605386520082523, "display_y": 0.24832506371259427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5287; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P035", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12463507367894962, "modern": -0.2017528598254334, "twfe_se": 0.049849340233739076, "x": -2.50023517050671, "y": -4.047252358394963, "se_normalized_difference": -1.547017187888253, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8494017199900289, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.50023517050671, "display_y": -4.047252358394963, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P036", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.043926056251628945, "modern": -0.05883144652871759, "twfe_se": 0.06775212077722162, "x": -0.6483347790110352, "y": -0.868333652937058, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2199988739260228, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9998153761870533, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6483347790110352, "display_y": -0.868333652937058, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P037", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1628351506261486, "modern": -0.11445768260576336, "twfe_se": 0.13255912926737692, "x": -1.2283963505652165, "y": -0.8634462465040621, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3649501040611544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9749886262020702, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2283963505652165, "display_y": -0.8634462465040621, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.975; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P038", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21969405227287891, "modern": -0.19067453120151492, "twfe_se": 0.12417221322224024, "x": -1.7692690383127514, "y": -1.535565214258125, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23370382405462642, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8437358834062463, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7692690383127514, "display_y": -1.535565214258125, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8437; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P039", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17957745866693553, "modern": -0.14142155067261403, "twfe_se": 0.16968725044087066, "x": -1.0582849224108986, "y": -0.8334247287594178, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22486019365148083, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7607391303141677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0582849224108986, "display_y": -0.8334247287594178, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7607; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P040", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26058903381841686, "modern": -0.20611977391920205, "twfe_se": 0.048392318481709495, "x": -5.384925583115218, "y": -4.259349012118683, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1255765709965346, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.019002181513361277, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.259349012118683, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.019; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P041", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.27992479239217416, "modern": -0.19705826602738652, "twfe_se": 0.051856524198979286, "x": -5.398063150512583, "y": -3.8000669939090383, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5979961566035454, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0006513060327783259, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.8000669939090383, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0006513; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P042", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1991390977895775, "modern": -0.1032364219762335, "twfe_se": 0.07237834054272763, "x": -2.751363132897725, "y": -1.4263441411079216, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3250189917898032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8339898457445425, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.751363132897725, "display_y": -1.4263441411079216, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.834; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P043", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113344233100728, "modern": -0.013069438910426293, "twfe_se": 0.07177601502906009, "x": -1.4090144498835886, "y": -0.1820864379993072, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2269280118842814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40992872560893645, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.4090144498835886, "display_y": -0.1820864379993072, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4099; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P044", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10837223305188158, "modern": -0.11974799382173384, "twfe_se": 0.04140854184295684, "x": -2.6171468066392336, "y": -2.89186695527415, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2747201486349165, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7996425394527843, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.6171468066392336, "display_y": -2.89186695527415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P045", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10566714520974, "modern": -0.07583447636706275, "twfe_se": 0.043653148547609565, "x": -2.420607647452873, "y": -1.7372051934433819, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6834024540094914, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37814114698857904, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.420607647452873, "display_y": -1.7372051934433819, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3781; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P046", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14629841804187504, "modern": -0.08617568094208841, "twfe_se": 0.04993271739678495, "x": -2.9299110016250562, "y": -1.7258359936092136, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2040750080158424, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3283672765607059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.9299110016250562, "display_y": -1.7258359936092136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3284; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P047", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14827651156083027, "modern": -0.04561761497369614, "twfe_se": 0.06730218782328327, "x": -2.203145489863761, "y": -0.677802853801354, "se_normalized_difference": 1.525342636062407, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9827773985566427, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.203145489863761, "display_y": -0.677802853801354, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9828; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P048", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08214515452042444, "modern": 0.004458662587853971, "twfe_se": 0.06549133531049521, "x": -1.2542904207247152, "y": 0.06808019055826847, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223706112829838, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8745609470697958, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2542904207247152, "display_y": 0.06808019055826847, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": 0.17550353597810928, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": 2.1728699927870183, "se_normalized_difference": 0.16007252895007676, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999624123905335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": 2.1728699927870183, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P050", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.106052751043436, "modern": 0.20027928776966455, "twfe_se": 0.08556206429156468, "x": 1.2394833144984259, "y": 2.340748665053065, "se_normalized_difference": 1.101265350554639, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9929672736576767, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.2394833144984259, "display_y": 2.340748665053065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.993; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P051", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1791064414013867, "modern": 0.18109188522066355, "twfe_se": 0.10907175575553293, "x": 1.6420973528914802, "y": 1.6603004505268286, "se_normalized_difference": 0.018203097635348442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9996434964466455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.6420973528914802, "display_y": 1.6603004505268286, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P052", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29588760263791564, "modern": 0.45520704034638326, "twfe_se": 0.1917331060707312, "x": 1.5432264604776254, "y": 2.374170270722341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8309438102447158, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9905191040017244, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.5432264604776254, "display_y": 2.374170270722341, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.21330251090649066, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.97838641702771, "se_normalized_difference": 1.15462796952067, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7240551444770145, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.97838641702771, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7241; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P054", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.31697833977317097, "modern": -0.22634360501738188, "twfe_se": 0.05435043811509917, "x": -5.832121152398049, "y": -4.164522179895751, "se_normalized_difference": 1.6675989725022977, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.022610883654263465, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.164522179895751, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02261; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P055", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1687796323024688, "modern": -0.14439005880064443, "twfe_se": 0.05054143946022593, "x": -3.3394306554187394, "y": -2.856864789422422, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4825658659963176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7349488855609596, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.3394306554187394, "display_y": -2.856864789422422, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7349; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P056", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658618154426823, "modern": -0.24440024114240916, "twfe_se": 0.09394992184708006, "x": -2.3053364737950517, "y": -2.60138844543387, "se_normalized_difference": -0.29605197163881813, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9168659980691416, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3053364737950517, "display_y": -2.60138844543387, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9169; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P058", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.3045492169792317, "modern": -0.18906972486722454, "twfe_se": 0.05422852223290661, "x": -5.616033858920593, "y": -3.48653655091664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1294973080039536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0005341070513687012, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.48653655091664, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0005341; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P060", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09540291291902506, "modern": 0.173457904334113, "twfe_se": 0.09911675406483009, "x": 0.9625306419601283, "y": 1.7500361666470434, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7875055246869153, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2731253467631985, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9625306419601283, "display_y": 1.7500361666470434, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2731; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P062", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.30677046832251936, "modern": -0.011322300818976672, "twfe_se": 0.3383154181902291, "x": 0.9067587577401733, "y": -0.03346670062967787, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9402254583698512, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8243296898940367, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9067587577401733, "display_y": -0.03346670062967787, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8243; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P064", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4225868461420414, "modern": 1.0743855666103255, "twfe_se": 0.15998925084723942, "x": 2.6413452397844828, "y": 6.715360944068474, "se_normalized_difference": 4.0740157042839895, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8319015184116749, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.6413452397844828, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8319; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P065", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T3-C6-TERMINATED-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08618892957737644, "modern": -0.14819726143869597, "twfe_se": 0.1130095983710691, "x": -0.7626691079316422, "y": -1.3113688003039135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5486996923722711, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17373851467052231, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7626691079316422, "display_y": -1.3113688003039135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1737; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P067", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.20669876701357798, "modern": 0.3501846101921218, "twfe_se": 0.1564704858157978, "x": 1.321008022285497, "y": 2.2380234097590175, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9170153874735206, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.3709648141606276e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.321008022285497, "display_y": 2.2380234097590175, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.371e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P069", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2615822418401665, "modern": 0.3868750332009083, "twfe_se": 0.17074781937748124, "x": 1.531979985418571, "y": 2.265768515295784, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7337885298772129, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.967188280417718e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.531979985418571, "display_y": 2.265768515295784, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.967e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P071", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2911068444010106, "modern": 0.4347640408285339, "twfe_se": 0.16302856058516044, "x": 1.7856186876467361, "y": 2.6667967825271224, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8811780948803865, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1205056782398701e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.7856186876467361, "display_y": 2.6667967825271224, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.121e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P073", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C8", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.33394441883176845, "modern": 0.419648540500346, "twfe_se": 0.16330693154006856, "x": 2.04488820947464, "y": 2.5696921529468706, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5248039434722305, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.3171782546872654e-14, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.04488820947464, "display_y": 2.5696921529468706, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.317e-14; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": -0.24338332196265441, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": -3.179768282364263, "se_normalized_difference": -0.28382556804003484, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9859921749777952, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": -3.179768282364263, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.986; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P075", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25765529203915105, "modern": -0.344269166229137, "twfe_se": 0.08021491852307107, "x": -3.2120620052122266, "y": -4.291834643329094, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0797726381168666, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6619100875775956, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.2120620052122266, "display_y": -4.291834643329094, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6619; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.34457526577661013, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 1.5863188700356177, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21498495671490114, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8000304677613004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 1.5863188700356177, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P077", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3348681094062555, "modern": 0.2767375857891446, "twfe_se": 0.1816872107624597, "x": 1.8431022635053085, "y": 1.523153911757471, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3199483517478373, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8576075637925102, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.8431022635053085, "display_y": 1.523153911757471, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8576; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.07573369102387349, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.1016210693909236, "se_normalized_difference": -3.569727963103465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999046342844691, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.1016210693909236, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P079", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.31104951098651784, "modern": 0.17914790760750995, "twfe_se": 0.06478036066813606, "x": 4.801602025342162, "y": 2.7654663506007404, "se_normalized_difference": -2.036135674741422, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.997361150037311, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.801602025342162, "display_y": 2.7654663506007404, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9974; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.10302790726298905, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.25691030838496554, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3741348815843343, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8074659022654093, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.25691030838496554, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8075; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P081", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.46043384283435496, "modern": 0.506695440824378, "twfe_se": 0.35319495551450636, "x": 1.3036251952229372, "y": 1.4346055426705184, "se_normalized_difference": 0.13098034744758127, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9744293819883441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3036251952229372, "display_y": 1.4346055426705184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9744; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": -0.13636564414696845, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": -1.9478414580890306, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5207175730959082, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7146713307312601, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": -1.9478414580890306, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7147; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P083", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1548516162623062, "modern": -0.10001320593217983, "twfe_se": 0.15762235225053767, "x": -0.982421681007352, "y": -0.634511568341594, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3479101126657581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4859193566492677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.982421681007352, "display_y": -0.634511568341594, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": 0.16070124937302005, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": 0.6548286465105709, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3944161269696218, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9384416169802532, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": 0.6548286465105709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9384; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P085", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6055333092652331, "modern": 0.32752083888341826, "twfe_se": 0.3494745746633342, "x": 1.732696319463505, "y": 0.9371807353909364, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7955155840725686, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8013690990268173, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.732696319463505, "display_y": 0.9371807353909364, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8014; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P001", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04554503237764617, "modern": 0.029550752772808053, "twfe_se": 0.02214473217513982, "x": -2.0566982710577126, "y": 1.3344371265859065, "se_normalized_difference": 3.3911353976436196, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.057662324201833e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0566982710577126, "display_y": 1.3344371265859065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.058e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P002", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02025550108463945, "modern": 0.11301216145047226, "twfe_se": 0.019400337721032605, "x": -1.044079818398199, "y": 5.825267738919395, "se_normalized_difference": 6.869347557317594, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.41858595740735e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.044079818398199, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.419e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P003", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04983128423661516, "modern": -0.009579258164665427, "twfe_se": 0.023269833494926877, "x": -2.1414542672803836, "y": -0.41165993588883343, "se_normalized_difference": 1.72979433139155, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.998841751158025e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.1414542672803836, "display_y": -0.41165993588883343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.999e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P004", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04076683043015399, "modern": 0.010150339041711602, "twfe_se": 0.021710065555831447, "x": -1.8777847687891385, "y": 0.46754069054320124, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3453254593323396, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0018548029548275384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8777847687891385, "display_y": 0.46754069054320124, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001855; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P005", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03944842134729418, "modern": -0.11030284624353281, "twfe_se": 0.026703389928004674, "x": -1.4772814033593313, "y": -4.130668298703709, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6533868953443775, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.694515805421165e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.4772814033593313, "display_y": -4.130668298703709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.695e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P006", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.030553147071442598, "modern": -0.10393021827196601, "twfe_se": 0.026538468786438795, "x": -1.1512776911626232, "y": -3.9162100537267825, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7649323625641595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7350396651094451, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1512776911626232, "display_y": -3.9162100537267825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P007", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0561026714314866, "modern": -0.016185880907912578, "twfe_se": 0.02278196935693539, "x": -2.46259094429023, "y": -0.7104689087374793, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7521220355527507, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.579660878741057e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.46259094429023, "display_y": -0.7104689087374793, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.58e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P008", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.040398117292382595, "modern": -0.0021529395683037534, "twfe_se": 0.021098261973614172, "x": -1.9147604358551018, "y": -0.10204345604373737, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8127169798113647, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.011974045630053888, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.9147604358551018, "display_y": -0.10204345604373737, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01197; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P009", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12289171381143947, "modern": -0.18562971917089063, "twfe_se": 0.03767341904728827, "x": 3.2620270981294226, "y": -4.927339324787201, "se_normalized_difference": -8.189366422916622, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.2381304926856194e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2620270981294226, "display_y": -4.927339324787201, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.238e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P010", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0857946819641765, "modern": -0.02319214683225769, "twfe_se": 0.02708791177167179, "x": 3.1672682149644156, "y": -0.8561806841275876, "se_normalized_difference": -4.023448899092004, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.34142504222450115, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1672682149644156, "display_y": -0.8561806841275876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3414; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P011", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1292085737760996, "modern": -0.17418418270666433, "twfe_se": 0.038865479579806766, "x": 3.3245073822074267, "y": -4.481719628571488, "se_normalized_difference": -7.8062270107789145, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.8645232175731985e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.3245073822074267, "display_y": -4.481719628571488, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.865e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P012", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09307990409843145, "modern": -0.023350193242507977, "twfe_se": 0.027324633105262498, "x": 3.406446620522236, "y": -0.8545473658349295, "se_normalized_difference": -4.260993986357166, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3017849118765784, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.406446620522236, "display_y": -0.8545473658349295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3018; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P013", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12085226786022098, "modern": -0.1856924837110375, "twfe_se": 0.038486828046456936, "x": 3.140094260673855, "y": -4.824832108452549, "se_normalized_difference": -7.964926369126403, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.617018334686794e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.140094260673855, "display_y": -4.824832108452549, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.617e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P014", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08796266153707287, "modern": -0.020070455626947314, "twfe_se": 0.02834927992300201, "x": 3.1028181941828374, "y": -0.7079705615613386, "se_normalized_difference": -3.810788755744176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.30425121086324036, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1028181941828374, "display_y": -0.7079705615613386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3043; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P015", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12565713848218707, "modern": -0.18256258165552525, "twfe_se": 0.03829978372654898, "x": 3.280883761102885, "y": -4.766673957194565, "se_normalized_difference": -8.047557718297451, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.4639532829167243e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.280883761102885, "display_y": -4.766673957194565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.464e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P016", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09121693194489162, "modern": -0.021343277699230473, "twfe_se": 0.02830998448046361, "x": 3.2220763670089387, "y": -0.7539134369345635, "se_normalized_difference": -3.975989803943502, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.31275516804953524, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2220763670089387, "display_y": -0.7539134369345635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3128; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P001", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113341599942652, "modern": 0.027090612439988726, "twfe_se": 0.04422121045668668, "x": -2.28698886699367, "y": 0.6126158049545738, "se_normalized_difference": 2.8996046719482442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0019379119886445725, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.28698886699367, "display_y": 0.6126158049545738, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001938; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P002", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20999936204812777, "modern": -0.05455407583706689, "twfe_se": 0.1608196559046698, "x": -1.3058065624304693, "y": -0.33922517449860295, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9665813879318663, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.3058065624304693, "display_y": -0.33922517449860295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P004", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14123366851820662, "modern": -0.016239084998918595, "twfe_se": 0.05193064802837583, "x": -2.7196592740578556, "y": -0.31270715108437064, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4069521229734847, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.797442420089926e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.7196592740578556, "display_y": -0.31270715108437064, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.797e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P006", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.032262235476981815, "modern": 0.07063437888563168, "twfe_se": 0.029038712745296222, "x": -1.111007769523384, "y": 2.4324211443247687, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5434289138481523, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0014348250836651384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.111007769523384, "display_y": 2.4324211443247687, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001435; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P007", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21617031982145912, "modern": -0.13345018549320065, "twfe_se": 0.12472637721842869, "x": -1.7331564071879362, "y": -1.0699435714347276, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6632128357532086, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.7331564071879362, "display_y": -1.0699435714347276, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P009", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08543758521702213, "modern": -0.02445158515512512, "twfe_se": 0.040893257759548066, "x": -2.0892829257916854, "y": -0.5979368359180427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4913460898736428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17464635282314106, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0892829257916854, "display_y": -0.5979368359180427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P011", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.012582455766935948, "modern": 0.13060802678741046, "twfe_se": 0.03446282272370412, "x": -0.3651022978533189, "y": 3.7898238294211466, "se_normalized_difference": 4.154926127274465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.0512315146171582e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -0.3651022978533189, "display_y": 3.7898238294211466, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.051e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P012", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2531616672939931, "modern": -0.11174530127867455, "twfe_se": 0.13764845254350458, "x": -1.8391900716354215, "y": -0.8118166184495014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.02737345318592, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8391900716354215, "display_y": -0.8118166184495014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P014", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08296560274959391, "modern": 0.04343236573361355, "twfe_se": 0.04480111686807485, "x": -1.8518646085074493, "y": 0.9694482809771945, "se_normalized_difference": 2.821312889484644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.1353089477552046e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8518646085074493, "display_y": 0.9694482809771945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.135e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P016", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.021554538786991286, "modern": -0.01927011682842492, "twfe_se": 0.012795115243670585, "x": -1.6845912191102588, "y": -1.5060526194132837, "se_normalized_difference": 0.17853859969697514, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9895992509023763, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6845912191102588, "display_y": -1.5060526194132837, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9896; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P017", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02325612733538412, "modern": -0.003759562756685654, "twfe_se": 0.013863174184456761, "x": -1.6775470773106664, "y": -0.2711906167132225, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4063564605974441, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6775470773106664, "display_y": -0.2711906167132225, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P019", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018531623316536978, "modern": 0.0015926812435597668, "twfe_se": 0.011687651791437265, "x": -1.5855728462165357, "y": 0.1362704221498637, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7218432683663996, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9881657238350432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.5855728462165357, "display_y": 0.1362704221498637, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9882; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P021", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T3-R3-NOTEXAS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00909454819923924, "modern": -0.034258677903352436, "twfe_se": 0.02098480773457043, "x": 0.43338725397311395, "y": -1.6325466659822951, "se_normalized_difference": -2.0659339199554094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6636804273830385, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": 0.43338725397311395, "display_y": -1.6325466659822951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6637; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.21942540341940092, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -4.183521304173129, "se_normalized_difference": -0.533622863721691, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7746975579662475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -4.183521304173129, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7747; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.39004080168212313, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -4.6945839576442845, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4542001499974968, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.13655863769778254, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -4.6945839576442845, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1366; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.29713651030571087, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -3.300894888930935, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3702091580447464, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4673589737110796, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -3.300894888930935, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4674; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.08217984532708654, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 4.268427836198346, "se_normalized_difference": 4.233769081212633, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5483424989161068, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 4.268427836198346, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5483; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.7556108038524608, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -7.9040677243779935, "se_normalized_difference": -5.2058390898486975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.03837020810449744, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03837; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.0006006236053846155, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 0.00698211411303128, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1700982524934386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.32226475891060424, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 0.00698211411303128, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3223; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.7527971699077467, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -7.704823329530131, "se_normalized_difference": -5.0557270090267945, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.02415707991283878, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02416; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.31707319306393916, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -8.256140032352649, "se_normalized_difference": -6.366720071619492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.024815342319498553, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02482; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.06979885590258547, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -1.8955743108907968, "se_normalized_difference": -1.774024555430823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5449672404714518, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -1.8955743108907968, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.545; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.2891986864187225, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -7.975017752597051, "se_normalized_difference": -6.194704159920209, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.031737607081148915, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03174; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0732397096110735, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.727415759980426, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0483174410274692, "homogeneity_pvalue": 9.006184276208503e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.727415759980426, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 9.006e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.3195547289469939, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 1.0028908207552323, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5890444720030076, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0003085680686237034, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 1.0028908207552323, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0003086; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 0.6109798366681785, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 1.7683050110499188, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6096230865684332, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1443603186589448e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 1.7683050110499188, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.144e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 0.5029079612799268, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 1.3794392032159444, "se_normalized_difference": -0.497469958736628, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.874202670498193e-20, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 1.3794392032159444, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.874e-20; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P001", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-LAND-EXPROPRIATION", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.014222863663783235, "modern": 0.08590158133443866, "twfe_se": 0.05506328730150922, "x": -0.25830030063231263, "y": 1.5600518157237626, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8183521163560752, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.25830030063231263, "display_y": 1.5600518157237626, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P002", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-ONE-CHILD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13470016920109934, "modern": 0.45462879236198217, "twfe_se": 0.21610578173287492, "x": -0.6233066423350032, "y": 2.1037326660882303, "se_normalized_difference": 2.727039308423233, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9990884746380607, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.6233066423350032, "display_y": 2.1037326660882303, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9991; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P003", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-PUBLIC-GOODS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00022117981059667995, "modern": 0.024392634950034197, "twfe_se": 0.017307556205773494, "x": -0.012779378438355051, "y": 1.409363324320579, "se_normalized_difference": 1.422142702758934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.454558695624506e-13, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.012779378438355051, "display_y": 1.409363324320579, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.455e-13; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P004", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-VC-UNILATERAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18886559326788294, "modern": -0.02743138018452337, "twfe_se": 0.15723477497681523, "x": 1.2011693551616158, "y": -0.1744612805186907, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3756306356803065, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999986824082961, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": 1.2011693551616158, "display_y": -0.1744612805186907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.2766581646581663, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 9.636297708898367, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7570821868595536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5e-324, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.941e-324; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.12953180482722826, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 2.8884240238938004, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7714333905217267, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.210703514378873e-222, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 2.8884240238938004, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.211e-222; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.26912176061253434, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 9.2839051347098, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4932417463303462, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.1173112187944399, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 2.5635974610464127, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06993961363032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.8236958397887627e-228, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 2.5635974610464127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.824e-228; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P001", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C1-LOGPAY", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11362857677249297, "modern": 0.02654938615172501, "twfe_se": 0.0007785365526435424, "x": 145.95149885598047, "y": 34.101656578070525, "se_normalized_difference": -111.84984227790997, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P002", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C3-TRANSFER-NONSES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06328442003596428, "modern": 0.2187590186566654, "twfe_se": 0.002687404261144327, "x": 23.548530063361984, "y": 81.40160444767447, "se_normalized_difference": 57.8530743843125, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P003", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C5-TRANSFER-SES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.010174911842129224, "modern": 0.002885450203221245, "twfe_se": 0.017429567710625926, "x": 0.5837730465297826, "y": 0.16554915481134577, "se_normalized_difference": -0.41822389171843677, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09480814692180335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 0.5837730465297826, "display_y": 0.16554915481134577, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09481; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P001", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-ANNOTATED-SCALAR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5836461717054291, "modern": 0.7570914198400018, "twfe_se": 0.15493282774663392, "x": 3.7670917144808223, "y": 4.886578466624872, "se_normalized_difference": 1.11948675214405, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7040545930389419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 3.7670917144808223, "display_y": 4.886578466624872, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7041; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P001", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4317959225682691, "modern": 0.2950029536826313, "twfe_se": 0.15175510253551105, "x": 2.845346979138496, "y": 1.9439409202968967, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9014060588415992, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.19866011805386e-06, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.845346979138496, "display_y": 1.9439409202968967, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.199e-06; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P002", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6914907581397147, "modern": 0.6098171388765059, "twfe_se": 0.23881176300149767, "x": 2.895547310772033, "y": 2.553547326195492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3419999845765412, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0006442741347147e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.895547310772033, "display_y": 2.553547326195492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.001e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P001", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C4-ALL-OPIOIDS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2053142392239101, "modern": -0.1461503407935394, "twfe_se": 0.031203796039542576, "x": -6.5797840417790345, "y": -4.683735934189943, "se_normalized_difference": 1.896048107589092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.683735934189943, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P002", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C9-OXYCONTIN", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18941714291972508, "modern": -0.06487917894497999, "twfe_se": 0.05441628787667782, "x": -3.480890562564578, "y": -1.192274987445192, "se_normalized_difference": 2.288615575119386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -3.480890562564578, "display_y": -1.192274987445192, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 6, "study": "Railroads of the Raj", "specification_id": "S06-P001", "source_specification_id": "RRR-T4-C1-REAL-INCOME", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00357296649567496, "modern": 0.012993242286345331, "twfe_se": 0.20218780330947986, "x": -0.017671523391576592, "y": 0.06426323484239628, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08193475823397287, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999999900060716, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 6 (2018)", "display_x": -0.017671523391576592, "display_y": 0.06426323484239628, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 19 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.42594215301121846, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 3.0029270883907704, "se_normalized_difference": 0.44412233935242995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 3.0029270883907704, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.2847501748827035, "se_normalized_difference": 0.39889329152629266, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.2847501748827035, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 1.1814139520448312, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3347048082591956, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 1.1814139520448312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": 0.2208707981145346, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": 1.3905677584074576, "se_normalized_difference": -0.47112704329156324, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": 1.3905677584074576, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 1.5744969021871882, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3918160548713041, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 1.5744969021871882, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.908486123049834, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12875187161505738, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.908486123049834, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.12334687831890981, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.0571567897993446, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25207684340939934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.0571567897993446, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": -0.02158858000909039, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": -0.09431343900620366, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31881155493175717, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": -0.09431343900620366, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": -0.19720465361266512, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": -0.9300878109696857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11687930840934309, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": -0.9300878109696857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": 0.8617823674953772, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08725381187999684, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": 0.8617823674953772, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 0.4636211521472953, "se_normalized_difference": -0.034013242652897, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 0.4636211521472953, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.062037859929712315, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -0.6674725889205914, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1557707726822974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -0.6674725889205914, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P001", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F1B-SIZE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2985242372686371, "modern": 0.29781256170431736, "twfe_se": 0.07399533091199685, "x": 4.034365865917594, "y": 4.024748021716503, "se_normalized_difference": -0.009617844201090544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 4.034365865917594, "display_y": 4.024748021716503, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P002", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F2A-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2407326507382832, "modern": 0.23333207064136352, "twfe_se": 0.07563931534096853, "x": 3.1826392088968998, "y": 3.084798819100149, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09784038979675042, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1826392088968998, "display_y": 3.084798819100149, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P005", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C1-VANISH-CONFLICT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.029729548421959906, "modern": -0.03784763410230067, "twfe_se": 0.014259074918511055, "x": -2.0849563237349407, "y": -2.654283978350312, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5693276546153714, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0849563237349407, "display_y": -2.654283978350312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P006", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C3-VANISH-PURCHASE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00822835391523646, "modern": 0.008619450261432418, "twfe_se": 0.01566429802296934, "x": -0.5252934988322372, "y": 0.5502608702153962, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0755543690476335, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -0.5252934988322372, "display_y": 0.5502608702153962, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P007", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C5-VANISH-EXTINCTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03852214346804064, "modern": 0.021842430436026128, "twfe_se": 0.028415889530356387, "x": 1.3556550262798515, "y": 0.7686695998973425, "se_normalized_difference": -0.586985426382509, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.3556550262798515, "display_y": 0.7686695998973425, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P008", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C1-SIZE-SINGLE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22154054083078928, "modern": 0.21409243802411873, "twfe_se": 0.06337713349981079, "x": 3.4955910530641257, "y": 3.3780707047086294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11752034835549613, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.4955910530641257, "display_y": 3.3780707047086294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P009", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C3-SIZE-UNCONTESTED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18935657850842058, "modern": 0.18408504027258502, "twfe_se": 0.058511023120722476, "x": 3.2362547842947795, "y": 3.1461599960877935, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09009478820698623, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.2362547842947795, "display_y": 3.1461599960877935, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P010", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C5-SIZE-ALL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18010933839074345, "modern": 0.17835022690352453, "twfe_se": 0.061075085940861945, "x": 2.9489821523156023, "y": 2.920179712497143, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028802439818459397, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 2.9489821523156023, "display_y": 2.920179712497143, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P011", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T4-C1-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18420481067124622, "modern": 0.16377852353219974, "twfe_se": 0.05919483001785045, "x": 3.1118395071951133, "y": 2.7667707379649817, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3450687692301313, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1118395071951133, "display_y": 2.7667707379649817, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P014", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T9-C1-VANISH-NOEXT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02920270024836768, "modern": -0.0264029996624148, "twfe_se": 0.013853448593025026, "x": -2.1079733361894264, "y": -1.9058792101562536, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2020941260331727, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1079733361894264, "display_y": -1.9058792101562536, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.2413395907640687, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -2.9015929435621812, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8464469197062248, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2047592728987791, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -2.9015929435621812, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2048; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.2139493432167725, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -3.0784826173169857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.990609631562876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -3.0784826173169857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.1300820525159727, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -1.838100744312126, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5383408583452726, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24264765541323957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -1.838100744312126, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P005", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1976322869564458, "modern": -0.2806193113899418, "twfe_se": 0.08995321908555387, "x": -2.1970563028820473, "y": -3.1196138864474294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.922557583565382, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16617954483812042, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1970563028820473, "display_y": -3.1196138864474294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1662; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.3140427393678433, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -3.2242629699367296, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6987952305532722, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -3.2242629699367296, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.23839113430397812, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -2.4538694021145138, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25048152488725295, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.14208227793353256, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -2.4538694021145138, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1421; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P003", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8A-INITIAL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.05065020247399928, "modern": 0.05315485520642897, "twfe_se": 0.02398136966268965, "x": 2.1120646229310727, "y": 2.216506227712573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.10444160478150014, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9775744925581922, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 2.1120646229310727, "display_y": 2.216506227712573, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9776; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P004", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8B-FULL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07467736218313017, "modern": -0.08795761261594937, "twfe_se": 0.04482978193546973, "x": -1.6657980244165491, "y": -1.9620352546563806, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2962372302398316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45013102997146764, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6657980244165491, "display_y": -1.9620352546563806, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P006", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C1-INITIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13734681236512186, "modern": 0.1349766057015137, "twfe_se": 0.03220903817063694, "x": 4.264232034421095, "y": 4.19064378720144, "se_normalized_difference": -0.07358824721965558, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9994420850606988, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 4.264232034421095, "display_y": 4.19064378720144, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9994; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P007", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C2-FULL-EXCL-PARTIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.039721651217501285, "modern": -0.05744106277769158, "twfe_se": 0.050805728533818637, "x": -0.7818341034330553, "y": -1.1306020882951449, "se_normalized_difference": -0.34876798486208965, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.33223047213496354, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7818341034330553, "display_y": -1.1306020882951449, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3322; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P008", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C3-FULL-DROP-LIMITED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03441024653904987, "modern": -0.0451620507156221, "twfe_se": 0.049669708930519536, "x": -0.6927813204459209, "y": -0.9092473398383918, "se_normalized_difference": -0.21646601939247087, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16306560648547455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6927813204459209, "display_y": -0.9092473398383918, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1631; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P009", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C4-FULL-DMSP-2013", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06437742135856342, "modern": -0.06775557959636926, "twfe_se": 0.05407466514201637, "x": -1.1905283405729634, "y": -1.2530004470378628, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0624721064648995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0008678643456103258, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.1905283405729634, "display_y": -1.2530004470378628, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0008679; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P010", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C5-FULL-DMSP-RAW", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.034129483049029005, "modern": 0.009146639060140477, "twfe_se": 0.04398867224053275, "x": -0.7758698162655809, "y": 0.20793169228036926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.98380150854595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7657199822961114, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7758698162655809, "display_y": 0.20793169228036926, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7657; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P011", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C7-FULL-DISTRICT-YEAR", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04961829037148674, "modern": -0.06304837327176609, "twfe_se": 0.05810665275823827, "x": -0.8539175467210497, "y": -1.0850456923424692, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2311281456214194, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6646258531167744, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.8539175467210497, "display_y": -1.0850456923424692, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6646; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P001", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20015904475694235, "modern": -0.2302701389429832, "twfe_se": 0.09099161176045499, "x": -2.1997527121937583, "y": -2.530674360942123, "se_normalized_difference": -0.33092164874836466, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07256341097820927, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.1997527121937583, "display_y": -2.530674360942123, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07256; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P002", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5866666266332619, "modern": -0.3587760057249104, "twfe_se": 0.21439777269866464, "x": -2.7363466478628946, "y": -1.673412933394457, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0629337144684379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6478429577611663, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.7363466478628946, "display_y": -1.673412933394457, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6478; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P003", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2180655094585218, "modern": -0.04366520037802251, "twfe_se": 0.3747435754693577, "x": -0.5819059317705441, "y": -0.11652021071564163, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4653857210549024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.654702301900471, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.5819059317705441, "display_y": -0.11652021071564163, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6547; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P004", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.32443914047906564, "modern": -0.553339409278403, "twfe_se": 0.09291827843087484, "x": -3.491661123709123, "y": -5.9551190424825995, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4634579187734764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8117889624508522, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -3.491661123709123, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8118; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P005", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.7502544624743879, "modern": -0.7502544624743879, "twfe_se": 0.16706519637830788, "x": -4.490788498973102, "y": -4.490788498973102, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -4.490788498973102, "display_y": -4.490788498973102, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P006", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08658480067380339, "modern": -0.08658461544704904, "twfe_se": 0.36856303915072125, "x": -0.23492534919757688, "y": -0.23492484663292804, "se_normalized_difference": 5.025646488535392e-07, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.23492534919757688, "display_y": -0.23492484663292804, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P007", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PC-C1-TRIPS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5245447118342563, "modern": 0.5367294072304346, "twfe_se": 0.12450377843848578, "x": 4.213082674381813, "y": 4.3109487435806555, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09786606919884311, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.7090130611501043e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": 4.213082674381813, "display_y": 4.3109487435806555, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.709e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.02295029924928877, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 0.9944551499490927, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09789785511577183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.014525389094489763, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 0.9944551499490927, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01453; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.02491540528604237, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 1.1500765083806341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3557365880040043, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.23734132618960652, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 1.1500765083806341, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.03117275671188908, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 1.4240415652910021, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3880859137597521, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4570063473046029, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 1.4240415652910021, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.457; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P002", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-BASELINE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.7888758993762184, "modern": 0.7967550027391155, "twfe_se": 0.11904766121821768, "x": 6.626555207415515, "y": 6.692739652219134, "se_normalized_difference": 0.06618444480361932, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8081640057069475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8082; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P001", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C1", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.41430806278014465, "modern": 0.42527348656207975, "twfe_se": 0.1373506360351823, "x": 3.0164262411862426, "y": 3.096261501498589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.07983526031234624, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45211921681332806, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 3.0164262411862426, "display_y": 3.096261501498589, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4521; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P002", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C2", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.34659086917588267, "modern": 0.3645272632101659, "twfe_se": 0.1851776291667871, "x": 1.8716670622438565, "y": 1.9685275421786552, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09686047993479888, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2838842303671143, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 1.8716670622438565, "display_y": 1.9685275421786552, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2839; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 11, "study": "Hall of Mirrors", "specification_id": "S11-P001", "source_specification_id": "HALL-MIRRORS-F1-COCOMMENT", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1472449898121927, "modern": 0.1605524415240668, "twfe_se": 0.03234331016239992, "x": 4.552564010079879, "y": 4.964007725799009, "se_normalized_difference": 0.41144371571912974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.705583964423773e-89, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 11 (2021)", "display_x": 4.552564010079879, "display_y": 4.964007725799009, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.706e-89; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 18 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": -0.5138179527233715, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": -6.0305967709411, "se_normalized_difference": -0.046896934516610075, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5.812088427359851e-72, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 5.812e-72; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 20 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#B5BD35", "#5C7C28", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#8C564B", "#D55E00", "#A95E00", "#56B4E9", "#009E73", "#B51F45", "#E6679E", "#8C2981", "#F09556", "#008F9C", "#332288", "#E63228", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#2DB6A4", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 2 (2017)", "Study 3 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 6 (2018)", "Study 7 (2019)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 9 (2020)", "Study 10 (2021)", "Study 11 (2021)", "Study 12 (2022)", "Study 13 (2023)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 15 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 17 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 21 (2025)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "homogeneity_test", "title": "Homogeneity F-test", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.3885253830076921, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 3.4147827899666137, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5288892869379433, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7528002318625951, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 3.4147827899666137, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7528; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.3328428430090348, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 2.4813782064818644, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7520064855512179, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40501845027573946, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 2.4813782064818644, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.405; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.385059491047323, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 3.1121304142542905, "se_normalized_difference": -0.025394052809753983, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47578789224074497, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 3.1121304142542905, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4758; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.20535587329137728, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.9403105956474556, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20629487713198497, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4755457444652286, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.9403105956474556, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4755; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.35038915647090907, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 3.6672865385561884, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4501909985412788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4912213849296376, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 3.6672865385561884, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4912; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.22224621433890407, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4105115212167811, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22319664872739578, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16584271954927018, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4105115212167811, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1658; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.42594215301119437, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 3.063135126493506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6077352836076337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 3.063135126493506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.0636290695671966, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.47601221502014696, "se_normalized_difference": 0.30256851691010567, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6238759371413234, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.47601221502014696, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6239; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.06153564561861635, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 0.6641303289063571, "se_normalized_difference": 0.28850940807882325, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9007339476341801, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 0.6641303289063571, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9007; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.2860739583907882, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.5245967953100297, "se_normalized_difference": 1.111778291083094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.744755025448304, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.5245967953100297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7448; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": -0.07239225849517301, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": -0.8438784517311982, "se_normalized_difference": -1.6804077637082337, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1883135791121969, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": -0.8438784517311982, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1883; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": 0.2604059077160187, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": 2.7656284795470314, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0880875836783972, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7555106259415197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": 2.7656284795470314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7555; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.11764988087499709, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.883643182599003, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3382433676435073, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8775181204600441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.883643182599003, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8775; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.08860159710440971, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 0.9719592159911877, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31164434620889925, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11053990821571197, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 0.9719592159911877, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1105; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": -0.10398415086730348, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": -1.0277453468056132, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4194402699439226, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6613097442013468, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": -1.0277453468056132, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.17528994011918686, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.579283320391719, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9192786009535644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8426154697309903, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.579283320391719, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.06328050733614857, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 0.6347730868317343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6451137650494003, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.904975638165574, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 0.6347730868317343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.039867497536061294, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.393115506998779, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4617745654598037, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9224037401332055, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.393115506998779, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9224; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 1.651153141158054, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22967394938499702, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 1.651153141158054, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.1685790387984038, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 1.8258833684449844, "se_normalized_difference": 0.27500155858422975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.12359234733591484, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 1.8258833684449844, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1236; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.04003771997148135, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 0.4431815934837828, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8604278797423379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8852716493371069, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 0.4431815934837828, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8853; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 1.2949695075512722, "se_normalized_difference": -0.39946129871962477, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 1.2949695075512722, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.5524011544647354, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 4.982732437148825, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1005293228826023, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.01714325715860586, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 4.982732437148825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01714; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.1065328086513135, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -1.014751306568505, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4016095808936353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9650240752385251, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -1.014751306568505, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.965; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": 0.2006988537785288, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": 1.612275723179677, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5748925503596426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6742386532450715, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": 1.612275723179677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6742; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": 0.06975588945735992, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": 0.4730545873038456, "se_normalized_difference": -0.578305632692984, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8493619630133346, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": 0.4730545873038456, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.24343173113939617, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 2.1429167471879733, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12928298396029417, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.368668192626714, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 2.1429167471879733, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3687; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": 0.22087079811454136, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": 1.6320398924198933, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5537940866718213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": 1.6320398924198933, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 2.448405761746198, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1714667306431985, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 2.448405761746198, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0894488186393951, "se_normalized_difference": -0.049675814622635504, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0894488186393951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.1508950291473108, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -2.3110066391030823, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2759274864151426, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09612628893524412, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -2.3110066391030823, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.20707550078154957, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.3262722628899362, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2557703864165844, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3428608116390395, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.3262722628899362, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.11579504661744161, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 1.0937022099197315, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5151283473619641, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6833402896734146, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 1.0937022099197315, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1085905496696486, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.0565407513080447, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2346447510359829, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.05372630452950017, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.0565407513080447, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.12334687831889027, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.080433657834606, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22961822897067982, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.080433657834606, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": -0.021588580009078137, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": -0.15510186540209908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.022122764010544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": -0.15510186540209908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.2200701629813498, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -1.8561175264468608, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7136746991547429, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5312685394334519, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -1.8561175264468608, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5313; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": 0.019629505394895136, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": 0.15288052365790902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2693180289941803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.35019378980996957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": 0.15288052365790902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": -0.18143225297181387, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": -1.3874157380204908, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2610500940171219, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.44892433741068394, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": -1.3874157380204908, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4489; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": -0.1972046536126607, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": -1.3696511938562184, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6484590274995803, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": -1.3696511938562184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.06076953126919374, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -0.5599313788877915, "se_normalized_difference": -0.014511269968484064, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6140200715446021, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -0.5599313788877915, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.614; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.08678442257440994, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.663058341854694, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8057170383258024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5307579151547169, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.663058341854694, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5308; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": 0.08080864784158243, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": 0.7545368107908907, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18806120158701928, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0502924517983174, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": 0.7545368107908907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05029; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.13312774663920757, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 1.37254658344467, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5497262605136766, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0384481776614768, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 1.37254658344467, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03845; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": 1.036530243767059, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0835143109148764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": 1.036530243767059, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.11748987923104534, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 0.7922914922158757, "se_normalized_difference": -0.006987762485435748, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.08317218243244932, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 0.7922914922158757, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.08317; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": -0.006545688292584825, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": -0.04810912669492938, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1143899187070034, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8156953081194223, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": -0.04810912669492938, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8157; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 0.49425217077821487, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6924049321882342, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 0.49425217077821487, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.06203785992970153, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -0.6726159239003874, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9228038799524354, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -0.6726159239003874, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P062", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3008887212720041, "modern": 0.3473935080976446, "twfe_se": 0.31083588666172546, "x": 0.9679986584028292, "y": 1.1176106846237603, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1496120262209312, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6998373490996154, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9679986584028292, "display_y": 1.1176106846237603, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P063", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.49306361679116867, "modern": 0.6471186994364466, "twfe_se": 0.18166472287589872, "x": 2.714140692730955, "y": 3.562159395572442, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8480187028414876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9989912166654179, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.714140692730955, "display_y": 3.562159395572442, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P064", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13450188332648486, "modern": -0.06464438569611686, "twfe_se": 0.4167804498641, "x": 0.3227163926963033, "y": -0.15510416987455988, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4778205625708632, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06784394081766397, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3227163926963033, "display_y": -0.15510416987455988, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06784; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P065", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658198080855093, "modern": -0.12842303879624975, "twfe_se": 0.4081892333040155, "x": -0.5305920958656024, "y": -0.3146164286518588, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21597566721374353, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8829318262431582, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5305920958656024, "display_y": -0.3146164286518588, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8829; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P066", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13997365996268946, "modern": 0.1807103456031524, "twfe_se": 0.20009060583611854, "x": 0.6995513826237947, "y": 0.9031425780736589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20359119544986423, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8155361799666327, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6995513826237947, "display_y": 0.9031425780736589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8155; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P067", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4448736019775512, "modern": 0.34165081521349516, "twfe_se": 0.28926475842925403, "x": 1.53794608231322, "y": 1.1811007226345316, "se_normalized_difference": -0.35684535967868836, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8251925142753511, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.53794608231322, "display_y": 1.1811007226345316, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8252; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P068", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5483851615815729, "modern": 0.5148405121812912, "twfe_se": 0.27592838943462955, "x": 1.9874184120930816, "y": 1.8658482848980735, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12157012719500823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6503824307717044, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9874184120930816, "display_y": 1.8658482848980735, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6504; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P069", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18640506753037372, "modern": -0.5597970757619195, "twfe_se": 0.3193859691436377, "x": -0.5836357433927901, "y": -1.752729079686533, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1690933362937428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4502524658648966, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5836357433927901, "display_y": -1.752729079686533, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4503; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P070", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18520047564986342, "modern": 0.012421380811847016, "twfe_se": 0.39534645345353947, "x": -0.46845108646365513, "y": 0.03141897620009068, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4998700626637458, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4205575876619039, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.46845108646365513, "display_y": 0.03141897620009068, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4206; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P071", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22194506642235692, "modern": 0.38764788926886995, "twfe_se": 0.24948117419673407, "x": -0.8896265104449809, "y": 1.5538161968212534, "se_normalized_difference": 2.443442707266234, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8641356346203798, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8896265104449809, "display_y": 1.5538161968212534, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8641; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P072", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04440438154510488, "modern": 0.16878837243409034, "twfe_se": 0.2581006713311633, "x": 0.1720428750382078, "y": 0.653963321999739, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48192044696153113, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.030267294207242283, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1720428750382078, "display_y": 0.653963321999739, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03027; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P073", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-B-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.161233735547124, "modern": 0.16128810371104074, "twfe_se": 0.23175829526333874, "x": 0.6956977974139817, "y": 0.6959323873511185, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0002345899371367215, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.49816860286009496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6956977974139817, "display_y": 0.6959323873511185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4982; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.45984172770274206, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 3.260354618668821, "se_normalized_difference": 0.34959121811943566, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8734628894882257, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 3.260354618668821, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.34450545002681265, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 2.398021338683492, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1573927097569581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5421794687577995, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 2.398021338683492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5422; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.17714854287302012, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 1.819861143119684, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6158213790525858, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6432918537486636, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 1.819861143119684, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6433; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": 0.07075989313060833, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": 0.4681427154307966, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0920789767934687, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8612826733542684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": 0.4681427154307966, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8613; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.3223054726379633, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 2.7365508733470856, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4893059853913318, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8936855951413996, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 2.7365508733470856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.025541150642906123, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.14216282734383506, "se_normalized_difference": 0.015522274289653934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8330329896265545, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.14216282734383506, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.833; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.07159163451959023, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.4469922187214222, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5520585507711355, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.00020231659013051603, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.4469922187214222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0002023; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": -0.02067761653089223, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": -0.11699838816876441, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0678679329240792, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4581735747017874, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": -0.11699838816876441, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4582; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": -0.25577428336671953, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": -1.2592413191907492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6164680810767089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7499233525260419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": -1.2592413191907492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7499; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": 0.04879427886184874, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": 0.3230439185568635, "se_normalized_difference": -0.08789101633244381, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1285965376483094, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": 0.3230439185568635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1286; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.11425085708872226, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 0.9064489961403578, "se_normalized_difference": -0.443019344105053, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.055514115135109246, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 0.9064489961403578, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.05551; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.06042820415359978, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -0.4088311916526365, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6401967941459146, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8391664853751086, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -0.4088311916526365, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8392; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P086", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5308687052782026, "modern": 0.6101266467133601, "twfe_se": 0.24844672525912923, "x": 2.136750664451335, "y": 2.4557644946899573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31901383023862245, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.10106640442242432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.136750664451335, "display_y": 2.4557644946899573, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1011; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P087", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15166924638969265, "modern": 0.22914942410328415, "twfe_se": 0.17916704385202792, "x": 0.8465242442407801, "y": 1.2789708373630149, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4324465931222347, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8016167718102788, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8465242442407801, "display_y": 1.2789708373630149, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8016; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P088", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3320653723940968, "modern": 0.3871365784380185, "twfe_se": 0.21620740446726425, "x": 1.5358649404829912, "y": 1.7905796491656902, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25471470868269924, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.015974233938446332, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5358649404829912, "display_y": 1.7905796491656902, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01597; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P089", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.38234882585818836, "modern": 0.4908149332691468, "twfe_se": 0.2472861682957992, "x": 1.5461795881799167, "y": 1.9848054448481849, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4386258566682682, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7479907029715333, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5461795881799167, "display_y": 1.9848054448481849, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.748; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P090", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.013652890780187027, "modern": 0.07752727058447548, "twfe_se": 0.15900157709156928, "x": 0.08586638591845101, "y": 0.48758806046198766, "se_normalized_difference": 0.40172167454353663, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45023964544400547, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.08586638591845101, "display_y": 0.48758806046198766, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4502; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P091", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5533939995776936, "modern": 0.44743787084264147, "twfe_se": 0.11947743667565217, "x": 4.631786678517415, "y": 3.7449570671432313, "se_normalized_difference": -0.886829611374183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3518130830232728, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 4.631786678517415, "display_y": 3.7449570671432313, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P092", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06267395216048637, "modern": 0.5141642001275655, "twfe_se": 0.24040116283962085, "x": 0.2607056946820932, "y": 2.138775844734913, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8780701500528199, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07500784724867739, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2607056946820932, "display_y": 2.138775844734913, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P093", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16706306048849764, "modern": -0.2136394317829444, "twfe_se": 0.1886167895820999, "x": -0.8857274098379218, "y": -1.1326639174396127, "se_normalized_difference": -0.24693650760169092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.06517953503926142, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8857274098379218, "display_y": -1.1326639174396127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.06518; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P094", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1606615496153213, "modern": -0.08054578016886683, "twfe_se": 0.2302547890410383, "x": 0.6977555180695356, "y": -0.3498115305411136, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0475670486106492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11143156050705309, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6977555180695356, "display_y": -0.3498115305411136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1114; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P095", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2020209774341155, "modern": 0.3867152084443397, "twfe_se": 0.20501189505896467, "x": 0.9854110044493325, "y": 1.8863061986384464, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9008951941891138, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8408310081916496, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9854110044493325, "display_y": 1.8863061986384464, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8408; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P096", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18439267097790166, "modern": -0.21044983030886144, "twfe_se": 0.24010389880009209, "x": 0.7679703324244018, "y": -0.8764948481077339, "se_normalized_difference": -1.644465180532136, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1096167789729291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7679703324244018, "display_y": -0.8764948481077339, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1096; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P097", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-D-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19717701724999584, "modern": 0.09528105206321572, "twfe_se": 0.20729820707749333, "x": 0.9511757001173005, "y": 0.45963278412532166, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4915429159919788, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37850866874177913, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9511757001173005, "display_y": 0.45963278412532166, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3785; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8648815281075595, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 52.68648865332906, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2784374559434193, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.47983688921801004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4798; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.1506838359231915, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 1.4883319133012118, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0488170221190814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1078307178723161, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 1.4883319133012118, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1078; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.18632123492718622, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.432185451343945, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6053175924336561, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9766705419510177, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.432185451343945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9767; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2221519598503761, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.2290980840968975, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5557647120017833, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.29345806370975447, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.2290980840968975, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2935; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": -0.10378186951570695, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": -0.9703913291942493, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2994228674763574, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2937123391699629, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": -0.9703913291942493, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2937; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.05493625656459516, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 0.45011780174715565, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9177591117655919, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4327564058760361, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 0.45011780174715565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4328; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P019", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09881088092328953, "modern": -0.19702122681021703, "twfe_se": 0.041534411407364795, "x": -2.3790124278917455, "y": -4.743566121061767, "se_normalized_difference": -2.3645536931700213, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9429154965763455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3790124278917455, "display_y": -4.743566121061767, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9429; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P020", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08182840209484749, "modern": -0.1044007606091853, "twfe_se": 0.04813993283519639, "x": -1.6998029967133763, "y": -2.1686935244923133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4688905277789369, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9979580492039667, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6998029967133763, "display_y": -2.1686935244923133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P022", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17108040462993862, "modern": -0.15152466684137159, "twfe_se": 0.09706403855215703, "x": -1.7625518902967254, "y": -1.5610793564905123, "se_normalized_difference": 0.20147253380621316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9954625342637035, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7625518902967254, "display_y": -1.5610793564905123, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9955; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P023", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22004242857243222, "modern": -0.2009834428455899, "twfe_se": 0.12222233244634166, "x": -1.8003455192530855, "y": -1.64440850393545, "se_normalized_difference": 0.15593701531763565, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7586733997657202, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.8003455192530855, "display_y": -1.64440850393545, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7587; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P024", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14886186739593033, "modern": -0.10647375061688505, "twfe_se": 0.138167725784353, "x": -1.0773997078613593, "y": -0.7706123120464854, "se_normalized_difference": 0.306787395814874, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7283317035604059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0773997078613593, "display_y": -0.7706123120464854, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7283; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.2030383904269613, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -5.454757808398558, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5366276102184089, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.484369966916825, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4844; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.21522117011185216, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -5.140118555774866, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8327432034636664, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11394349161470584, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1139; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.037306221004405324, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.6275662609162148, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1818776506343336, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8589956912870166, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.6275662609162148, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.0025936652535203247, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.03659969088893413, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1819049474612453, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.1255451611841135, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.03659969088893413, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1255; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P029", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0949616989865803, "modern": -0.10690884560481552, "twfe_se": 0.038049286231772846, "x": -2.4957550690473416, "y": -2.809746415572492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3139913465251503, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9702899415292684, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.4957550690473416, "display_y": -2.809746415572492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9703; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P030", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09127764261905837, "modern": -0.06459281001888015, "twfe_se": 0.038194441354129714, "x": -2.3898148364772225, "y": -1.6911573445986834, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6986574918785391, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.724030079051392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3898148364772225, "display_y": -1.6911573445986834, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.724; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P032", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12649461371178825, "modern": -0.08542924465000176, "twfe_se": 0.04336430141456208, "x": -2.917021826375147, "y": -1.9700362248038876, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9469856015712593, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7412517325644989, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.917021826375147, "display_y": -1.9700362248038876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7413; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P033", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.16654716073235562, "modern": -0.08625191848631315, "twfe_se": 0.07374191421984075, "x": -2.2585142044976236, "y": -1.1696457760667476, "se_normalized_difference": 1.088868428430876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8826731469363056, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.2585142044976236, "display_y": -1.1696457760667476, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8827; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P034", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07279015339305425, "modern": 0.01704381018527843, "twfe_se": 0.06863507827387309, "x": -1.0605386520082523, "y": 0.24832506371259427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3088637157208465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5287294560445291, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0605386520082523, "display_y": 0.24832506371259427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5287; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P035", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.12463507367894962, "modern": -0.2017528598254334, "twfe_se": 0.049849340233739076, "x": -2.50023517050671, "y": -4.047252358394963, "se_normalized_difference": -1.547017187888253, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8494017199900289, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.50023517050671, "display_y": -4.047252358394963, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8494; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P036", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.043926056251628945, "modern": -0.05883144652871759, "twfe_se": 0.06775212077722162, "x": -0.6483347790110352, "y": -0.868333652937058, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2199988739260228, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9998153761870533, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6483347790110352, "display_y": -0.868333652937058, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9998; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P037", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1628351506261486, "modern": -0.11445768260576336, "twfe_se": 0.13255912926737692, "x": -1.2283963505652165, "y": -0.8634462465040621, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3649501040611544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9749886262020702, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2283963505652165, "display_y": -0.8634462465040621, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.975; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P038", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21969405227287891, "modern": -0.19067453120151492, "twfe_se": 0.12417221322224024, "x": -1.7692690383127514, "y": -1.535565214258125, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23370382405462642, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8437358834062463, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.7692690383127514, "display_y": -1.535565214258125, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8437; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P039", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FELGA-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17957745866693553, "modern": -0.14142155067261403, "twfe_se": 0.16968725044087066, "x": -1.0582849224108986, "y": -0.8334247287594178, "se_normalized_difference": 0.22486019365148083, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7607391303141677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.0582849224108986, "display_y": -0.8334247287594178, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7607; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P040", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26058903381841686, "modern": -0.20611977391920205, "twfe_se": 0.048392318481709495, "x": -5.384925583115218, "y": -4.259349012118683, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1255765709965346, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.019002181513361277, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.259349012118683, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.019; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P041", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.27992479239217416, "modern": -0.19705826602738652, "twfe_se": 0.051856524198979286, "x": -5.398063150512583, "y": -3.8000669939090383, "se_normalized_difference": 1.5979961566035454, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0006513060327783259, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.8000669939090383, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0006513; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P042", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1991390977895775, "modern": -0.1032364219762335, "twfe_se": 0.07237834054272763, "x": -2.751363132897725, "y": -1.4263441411079216, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3250189917898032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8339898457445425, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.751363132897725, "display_y": -1.4263441411079216, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.834; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P043", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113344233100728, "modern": -0.013069438910426293, "twfe_se": 0.07177601502906009, "x": -1.4090144498835886, "y": -0.1820864379993072, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2269280118842814, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.40992872560893645, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.4090144498835886, "display_y": -0.1820864379993072, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4099; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P044", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10837223305188158, "modern": -0.11974799382173384, "twfe_se": 0.04140854184295684, "x": -2.6171468066392336, "y": -2.89186695527415, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2747201486349165, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7996425394527843, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.6171468066392336, "display_y": -2.89186695527415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P045", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10566714520974, "modern": -0.07583447636706275, "twfe_se": 0.043653148547609565, "x": -2.420607647452873, "y": -1.7372051934433819, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6834024540094914, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.37814114698857904, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.420607647452873, "display_y": -1.7372051934433819, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3781; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P046", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRDINNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14629841804187504, "modern": -0.08617568094208841, "twfe_se": 0.04993271739678495, "x": -2.9299110016250562, "y": -1.7258359936092136, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2040750080158424, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3283672765607059, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.9299110016250562, "display_y": -1.7258359936092136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3284; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P047", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14827651156083027, "modern": -0.04561761497369614, "twfe_se": 0.06730218782328327, "x": -2.203145489863761, "y": -0.677802853801354, "se_normalized_difference": 1.525342636062407, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9827773985566427, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.203145489863761, "display_y": -0.677802853801354, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9828; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P048", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLSPATIAL-SHNONE-FESTATE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08214515452042444, "modern": 0.004458662587853971, "twfe_se": 0.06549133531049521, "x": -1.2542904207247152, "y": 0.06808019055826847, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223706112829838, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8745609470697958, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -1.2542904207247152, "display_y": 0.06808019055826847, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": 0.17550353597810928, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": 2.1728699927870183, "se_normalized_difference": 0.16007252895007676, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999624123905335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": 2.1728699927870183, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P050", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.106052751043436, "modern": 0.20027928776966455, "twfe_se": 0.08556206429156468, "x": 1.2394833144984259, "y": 2.340748665053065, "se_normalized_difference": 1.101265350554639, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9929672736576767, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.2394833144984259, "display_y": 2.340748665053065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.993; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P051", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1791064414013867, "modern": 0.18109188522066355, "twfe_se": 0.10907175575553293, "x": 1.6420973528914802, "y": 1.6603004505268286, "se_normalized_difference": 0.018203097635348442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9996434964466455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.6420973528914802, "display_y": 1.6603004505268286, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9996; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P052", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29588760263791564, "modern": 0.45520704034638326, "twfe_se": 0.1917331060707312, "x": 1.5432264604776254, "y": 2.374170270722341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8309438102447158, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9905191040017244, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.5432264604776254, "display_y": 2.374170270722341, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9905; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.21330251090649066, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.97838641702771, "se_normalized_difference": 1.15462796952067, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7240551444770145, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.97838641702771, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7241; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P054", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.31697833977317097, "modern": -0.22634360501738188, "twfe_se": 0.05435043811509917, "x": -5.832121152398049, "y": -4.164522179895751, "se_normalized_difference": 1.6675989725022977, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.022610883654263465, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.164522179895751, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02261; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P055", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1687796323024688, "modern": -0.14439005880064443, "twfe_se": 0.05054143946022593, "x": -3.3394306554187394, "y": -2.856864789422422, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4825658659963176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7349488855609596, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.3394306554187394, "display_y": -2.856864789422422, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7349; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P056", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21658618154426823, "modern": -0.24440024114240916, "twfe_se": 0.09394992184708006, "x": -2.3053364737950517, "y": -2.60138844543387, "se_normalized_difference": -0.29605197163881813, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9168659980691416, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.3053364737950517, "display_y": -2.60138844543387, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9169; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P058", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.3045492169792317, "modern": -0.18906972486722454, "twfe_se": 0.05422852223290661, "x": -5.616033858920593, "y": -3.48653655091664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.1294973080039536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0005341070513687012, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.48653655091664, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0005341; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P060", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PA-ONSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09540291291902506, "modern": 0.173457904334113, "twfe_se": 0.09911675406483009, "x": 0.9625306419601283, "y": 1.7500361666470434, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7875055246869153, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2731253467631985, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9625306419601283, "display_y": 1.7500361666470434, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2731; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P062", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.30677046832251936, "modern": -0.011322300818976672, "twfe_se": 0.3383154181902291, "x": 0.9067587577401733, "y": -0.03346670062967787, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9402254583698512, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8243296898940367, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.9067587577401733, "display_y": -0.03346670062967787, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8243; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P064", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T2-PB-OFFSHORE-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4225868461420414, "modern": 1.0743855666103255, "twfe_se": 0.15998925084723942, "x": 2.6413452397844828, "y": 6.715360944068474, "se_normalized_difference": 4.0740157042839895, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8319015184116749, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.6413452397844828, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8319; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P065", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T3-C6-TERMINATED-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08618892957737644, "modern": -0.14819726143869597, "twfe_se": 0.1130095983710691, "x": -0.7626691079316422, "y": -1.3113688003039135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5486996923722711, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17373851467052231, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7626691079316422, "display_y": -1.3113688003039135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1737; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P067", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.20669876701357798, "modern": 0.3501846101921218, "twfe_se": 0.1564704858157978, "x": 1.321008022285497, "y": 2.2380234097590175, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9170153874735206, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.3709648141606276e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.321008022285497, "display_y": 2.2380234097590175, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.371e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P069", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2615822418401665, "modern": 0.3868750332009083, "twfe_se": 0.17074781937748124, "x": 1.531979985418571, "y": 2.265768515295784, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7337885298772129, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.967188280417718e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.531979985418571, "display_y": 2.265768515295784, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.967e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P071", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2911068444010106, "modern": 0.4347640408285339, "twfe_se": 0.16302856058516044, "x": 1.7856186876467361, "y": 2.6667967825271224, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8811780948803865, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1205056782398701e-12, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.7856186876467361, "display_y": 2.6667967825271224, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.121e-12; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P073", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T4-C8", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.33394441883176845, "modern": 0.419648540500346, "twfe_se": 0.16330693154006856, "x": 2.04488820947464, "y": 2.5696921529468706, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5248039434722305, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.3171782546872654e-14, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.04488820947464, "display_y": 2.5696921529468706, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.317e-14; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": -0.24338332196265441, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": -3.179768282364263, "se_normalized_difference": -0.28382556804003484, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9859921749777952, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": -3.179768282364263, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.986; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P075", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25765529203915105, "modern": -0.344269166229137, "twfe_se": 0.08021491852307107, "x": -3.2120620052122266, "y": -4.291834643329094, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0797726381168666, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6619100875775956, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -3.2120620052122266, "display_y": -4.291834643329094, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6619; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.34457526577661013, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 1.5863188700356177, "se_normalized_difference": 0.21498495671490114, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8000304677613004, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 1.5863188700356177, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P077", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3348681094062555, "modern": 0.2767375857891446, "twfe_se": 0.1816872107624597, "x": 1.8431022635053085, "y": 1.523153911757471, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3199483517478373, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8576075637925102, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.8431022635053085, "display_y": 1.523153911757471, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8576; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.07573369102387349, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.1016210693909236, "se_normalized_difference": -3.569727963103465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999046342844691, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.1016210693909236, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9999; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P079", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.31104951098651784, "modern": 0.17914790760750995, "twfe_se": 0.06478036066813606, "x": 4.801602025342162, "y": 2.7654663506007404, "se_normalized_difference": -2.036135674741422, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.997361150037311, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.801602025342162, "display_y": 2.7654663506007404, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9974; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.10302790726298905, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.25691030838496554, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3741348815843343, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8074659022654093, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.25691030838496554, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8075; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P081", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C4-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.46043384283435496, "modern": 0.506695440824378, "twfe_se": 0.35319495551450636, "x": 1.3036251952229372, "y": 1.4346055426705184, "se_normalized_difference": 0.13098034744758127, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9744293819883441, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3036251952229372, "display_y": 1.4346055426705184, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9744; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": -0.13636564414696845, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": -1.9478414580890306, "se_normalized_difference": 0.5207175730959082, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7146713307312601, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": -1.9478414580890306, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7147; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P083", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C6-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1548516162623062, "modern": -0.10001320593217983, "twfe_se": 0.15762235225053767, "x": -0.982421681007352, "y": -0.634511568341594, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3479101126657581, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4859193566492677, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -0.982421681007352, "display_y": -0.634511568341594, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4859; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": 0.16070124937302005, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": 0.6548286465105709, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3944161269696218, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9384416169802532, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": 0.6548286465105709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9384; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P085", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C8-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6055333092652331, "modern": 0.32752083888341826, "twfe_se": 0.3494745746633342, "x": 1.732696319463505, "y": 0.9371807353909364, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7955155840725686, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8013690990268173, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.732696319463505, "display_y": 0.9371807353909364, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8014; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P001", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04554503237764617, "modern": 0.029550752772808053, "twfe_se": 0.02214473217513982, "x": -2.0566982710577126, "y": 1.3344371265859065, "se_normalized_difference": 3.3911353976436196, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.057662324201833e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0566982710577126, "display_y": 1.3344371265859065, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.058e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P002", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02025550108463945, "modern": 0.11301216145047226, "twfe_se": 0.019400337721032605, "x": -1.044079818398199, "y": 5.825267738919395, "se_normalized_difference": 6.869347557317594, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.41858595740735e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.044079818398199, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.419e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P003", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04983128423661516, "modern": -0.009579258164665427, "twfe_se": 0.023269833494926877, "x": -2.1414542672803836, "y": -0.41165993588883343, "se_normalized_difference": 1.72979433139155, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.998841751158025e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.1414542672803836, "display_y": -0.41165993588883343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.999e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P004", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04076683043015399, "modern": 0.010150339041711602, "twfe_se": 0.021710065555831447, "x": -1.8777847687891385, "y": 0.46754069054320124, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3453254593323396, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0018548029548275384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8777847687891385, "display_y": 0.46754069054320124, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001855; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P005", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03944842134729418, "modern": -0.11030284624353281, "twfe_se": 0.026703389928004674, "x": -1.4772814033593313, "y": -4.130668298703709, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6533868953443775, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.694515805421165e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.4772814033593313, "display_y": -4.130668298703709, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.695e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P006", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.030553147071442598, "modern": -0.10393021827196601, "twfe_se": 0.026538468786438795, "x": -1.1512776911626232, "y": -3.9162100537267825, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7649323625641595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7350396651094451, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1512776911626232, "display_y": -3.9162100537267825, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.735; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P007", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.0561026714314866, "modern": -0.016185880907912578, "twfe_se": 0.02278196935693539, "x": -2.46259094429023, "y": -0.7104689087374793, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7521220355527507, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.579660878741057e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -2.46259094429023, "display_y": -0.7104689087374793, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.58e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P008", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PA-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.040398117292382595, "modern": -0.0021529395683037534, "twfe_se": 0.021098261973614172, "x": -1.9147604358551018, "y": -0.10204345604373737, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8127169798113647, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.011974045630053888, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": -1.9147604358551018, "display_y": -0.10204345604373737, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01197; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P009", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12289171381143947, "modern": -0.18562971917089063, "twfe_se": 0.03767341904728827, "x": 3.2620270981294226, "y": -4.927339324787201, "se_normalized_difference": -8.189366422916622, "homogeneity_pvalue": 4.2381304926856194e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2620270981294226, "display_y": -4.927339324787201, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.238e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P010", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-ALL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0857946819641765, "modern": -0.02319214683225769, "twfe_se": 0.02708791177167179, "x": 3.1672682149644156, "y": -0.8561806841275876, "se_normalized_difference": -4.023448899092004, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.34142504222450115, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1672682149644156, "display_y": -0.8561806841275876, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3414; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P011", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1292085737760996, "modern": -0.17418418270666433, "twfe_se": 0.038865479579806766, "x": 3.3245073822074267, "y": -4.481719628571488, "se_normalized_difference": -7.8062270107789145, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.8645232175731985e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.3245073822074267, "display_y": -4.481719628571488, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.865e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P012", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09307990409843145, "modern": -0.023350193242507977, "twfe_se": 0.027324633105262498, "x": 3.406446620522236, "y": -0.8545473658349295, "se_normalized_difference": -4.260993986357166, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3017849118765784, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.406446620522236, "display_y": -0.8545473658349295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3018; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P013", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12085226786022098, "modern": -0.1856924837110375, "twfe_se": 0.038486828046456936, "x": 3.140094260673855, "y": -4.824832108452549, "se_normalized_difference": -7.964926369126403, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.617018334686794e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.140094260673855, "display_y": -4.824832108452549, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.617e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P014", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTX-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08796266153707287, "modern": -0.020070455626947314, "twfe_se": 0.02834927992300201, "x": 3.1028181941828374, "y": -0.7079705615613386, "se_normalized_difference": -3.810788755744176, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.30425121086324036, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1028181941828374, "display_y": -0.7079705615613386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3043; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P015", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-CHGEMP", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12565713848218707, "modern": -0.18256258165552525, "twfe_se": 0.03829978372654898, "x": 3.280883761102885, "y": -4.766673957194565, "se_normalized_difference": -8.047557718297451, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.4639532829167243e-07, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.280883761102885, "display_y": -4.766673957194565, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.464e-07; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 3, "study": "Reply: Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S03-P016", "source_specification_id": "PP-REPLY-T1-PB-NOTXOIL-SALESGR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09121693194489162, "modern": -0.021343277699230473, "twfe_se": 0.02830998448046361, "x": 3.2220763670089387, "y": -0.7539134369345635, "se_normalized_difference": -3.975989803943502, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.31275516804953524, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 3 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2220763670089387, "display_y": -0.7539134369345635, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3128; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P001", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.10113341599942652, "modern": 0.027090612439988726, "twfe_se": 0.04422121045668668, "x": -2.28698886699367, "y": 0.6126158049545738, "se_normalized_difference": 2.8996046719482442, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0019379119886445725, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.28698886699367, "display_y": 0.6126158049545738, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001938; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P002", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20999936204812777, "modern": -0.05455407583706689, "twfe_se": 0.1608196559046698, "x": -1.3058065624304693, "y": -0.33922517449860295, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9665813879318663, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.3058065624304693, "display_y": -0.33922517449860295, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P004", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-CAPEX-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14123366851820662, "modern": -0.016239084998918595, "twfe_se": 0.05193064802837583, "x": -2.7196592740578556, "y": -0.31270715108437064, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4069521229734847, "homogeneity_pvalue": 8.797442420089926e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.7196592740578556, "display_y": -0.31270715108437064, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 8.797e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P006", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.032262235476981815, "modern": 0.07063437888563168, "twfe_se": 0.029038712745296222, "x": -1.111007769523384, "y": 2.4324211443247687, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5434289138481523, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0014348250836651384, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.111007769523384, "display_y": 2.4324211443247687, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.001435; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P007", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21617031982145912, "modern": -0.13345018549320065, "twfe_se": 0.12472637721842869, "x": -1.7331564071879362, "y": -1.0699435714347276, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6632128357532086, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.7331564071879362, "display_y": -1.0699435714347276, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P009", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DEMP-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08543758521702213, "modern": -0.02445158515512512, "twfe_se": 0.040893257759548066, "x": -2.0892829257916854, "y": -0.5979368359180427, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4913460898736428, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.17464635282314106, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -2.0892829257916854, "display_y": -0.5979368359180427, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1746; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P011", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.012582455766935948, "modern": 0.13060802678741046, "twfe_se": 0.03446282272370412, "x": -0.3651022978533189, "y": 3.7898238294211466, "se_normalized_difference": 4.154926127274465, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.0512315146171582e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -0.3651022978533189, "display_y": 3.7898238294211466, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.051e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P012", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2531616672939931, "modern": -0.11174530127867455, "twfe_se": 0.13764845254350458, "x": -1.8391900716354215, "y": -0.8118166184495014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.02737345318592, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8391900716354215, "display_y": -0.8118166184495014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P014", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-DSALES-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08296560274959391, "modern": 0.04343236573361355, "twfe_se": 0.04480111686807485, "x": -1.8518646085074493, "y": 0.9694482809771945, "se_normalized_difference": 2.821312889484644, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.1353089477552046e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.8518646085074493, "display_y": 0.9694482809771945, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.135e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P016", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-ACTUAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.021554538786991286, "modern": -0.01927011682842492, "twfe_se": 0.012795115243670585, "x": -1.6845912191102588, "y": -1.5060526194132837, "se_normalized_difference": 0.17853859969697514, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9895992509023763, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6845912191102588, "display_y": -1.5060526194132837, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9896; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P017", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-NOOV-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02325612733538412, "modern": -0.003759562756685654, "twfe_se": 0.013863174184456761, "x": -1.6775470773106664, "y": -0.2711906167132225, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4063564605974441, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.6775470773106664, "display_y": -0.2711906167132225, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P019", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T2-RD-QP-M1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.018531623316536978, "modern": 0.0015926812435597668, "twfe_se": 0.011687651791437265, "x": -1.5855728462165357, "y": 0.1362704221498637, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7218432683663996, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9881657238350432, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": -1.5855728462165357, "display_y": 0.1362704221498637, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9882; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 2, "study": "Do Powerful Politicians Really Cause Corporate Downsizing?", "specification_id": "S02-P021", "source_specification_id": "AM005-P2587-T3-R3-NOTEXAS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.00909454819923924, "modern": -0.034258677903352436, "twfe_se": 0.02098480773457043, "x": 0.43338725397311395, "y": -1.6325466659822951, "se_normalized_difference": -2.0659339199554094, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6636804273830385, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 2 (2017)", "display_x": 0.43338725397311395, "display_y": -1.6325466659822951, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6637; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.21942540341940092, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -4.183521304173129, "se_normalized_difference": -0.533622863721691, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7746975579662475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -4.183521304173129, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7747; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.39004080168212313, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -4.6945839576442845, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4542001499974968, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.13655863769778254, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -4.6945839576442845, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1366; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.29713651030571087, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -3.300894888930935, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3702091580447464, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4673589737110796, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -3.300894888930935, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4674; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.08217984532708654, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 4.268427836198346, "se_normalized_difference": 4.233769081212633, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5483424989161068, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 4.268427836198346, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5483; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.7556108038524608, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -7.9040677243779935, "se_normalized_difference": -5.2058390898486975, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.03837020810449744, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03837; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.0006006236053846155, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 0.00698211411303128, "se_normalized_difference": 0.1700982524934386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.32226475891060424, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 0.00698211411303128, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3223; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.7527971699077467, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -7.704823329530131, "se_normalized_difference": -5.0557270090267945, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.02415707991283878, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02416; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.31707319306393916, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -8.256140032352649, "se_normalized_difference": -6.366720071619492, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.024815342319498553, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.02482; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.06979885590258547, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -1.8955743108907968, "se_normalized_difference": -1.774024555430823, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5449672404714518, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -1.8955743108907968, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.545; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.2891986864187225, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -7.975017752597051, "se_normalized_difference": -6.194704159920209, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.031737607081148915, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.03174; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0732397096110735, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.727415759980426, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0483174410274692, "homogeneity_pvalue": 9.006184276208503e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.727415759980426, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 9.006e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.3195547289469939, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 1.0028908207552323, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5890444720030076, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0003085680686237034, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 1.0028908207552323, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0003086; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 0.6109798366681785, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 1.7683050110499188, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6096230865684332, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.1443603186589448e-11, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 1.7683050110499188, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.144e-11; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 0.5029079612799268, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 1.3794392032159444, "se_normalized_difference": -0.497469958736628, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.874202670498193e-20, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 1.3794392032159444, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.874e-20; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P001", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-LAND-EXPROPRIATION", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.014222863663783235, "modern": 0.08590158133443866, "twfe_se": 0.05506328730150922, "x": -0.25830030063231263, "y": 1.5600518157237626, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8183521163560752, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.25830030063231263, "display_y": 1.5600518157237626, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P002", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-ONE-CHILD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.13470016920109934, "modern": 0.45462879236198217, "twfe_se": 0.21610578173287492, "x": -0.6233066423350032, "y": 2.1037326660882303, "se_normalized_difference": 2.727039308423233, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9990884746380607, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.6233066423350032, "display_y": 2.1037326660882303, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9991; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P003", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-PUBLIC-GOODS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00022117981059667995, "modern": 0.024392634950034197, "twfe_se": 0.017307556205773494, "x": -0.012779378438355051, "y": 1.409363324320579, "se_normalized_difference": 1.422142702758934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.454558695624506e-13, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": -0.012779378438355051, "display_y": 1.409363324320579, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.455e-13; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 12, "study": "The Rise and Fall of Local Elections in China", "specification_id": "S12-P004", "source_specification_id": "LOCAL-ELECTIONS-T5-C3-VC-UNILATERAL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18886559326788294, "modern": -0.02743138018452337, "twfe_se": 0.15723477497681523, "x": 1.2011693551616158, "y": -0.1744612805186907, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3756306356803065, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999986824082961, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 12 (2022)", "display_x": 1.2011693551616158, "display_y": -0.1744612805186907, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.2766581646581663, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 9.636297708898367, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7570821868595536, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5e-324, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 4.941e-324; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.12953180482722826, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 2.8884240238938004, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7714333905217267, "homogeneity_pvalue": 3.210703514378873e-222, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 2.8884240238938004, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 3.211e-222; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.26912176061253434, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 9.2839051347098, "se_normalized_difference": 1.4932417463303462, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.1173112187944399, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 2.5635974610464127, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06993961363032, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.8236958397887627e-228, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 2.5635974610464127, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.824e-228; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P001", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C1-LOGPAY", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.11362857677249297, "modern": 0.02654938615172501, "twfe_se": 0.0007785365526435424, "x": 145.95149885598047, "y": 34.101656578070525, "se_normalized_difference": -111.84984227790997, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P002", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C3-TRANSFER-NONSES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.06328442003596428, "modern": 0.2187590186566654, "twfe_se": 0.002687404261144327, "x": 23.548530063361984, "y": 81.40160444767447, "se_normalized_difference": 57.8530743843125, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 13, "study": "Ideology and Performance in Public Organizations", "specification_id": "S13-P003", "source_specification_id": "IPPO-T3-C5-TRANSFER-SES", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.010174911842129224, "modern": 0.002885450203221245, "twfe_se": 0.017429567710625926, "x": 0.5837730465297826, "y": 0.16554915481134577, "se_normalized_difference": -0.41822389171843677, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.09480814692180335, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 13 (2023)", "display_x": 0.5837730465297826, "display_y": 0.16554915481134577, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.09481; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P001", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-ANNOTATED-SCALAR", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5836461717054291, "modern": 0.7570914198400018, "twfe_se": 0.15493282774663392, "x": 3.7670917144808223, "y": 4.886578466624872, "se_normalized_difference": 1.11948675214405, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7040545930389419, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 3.7670917144808223, "display_y": 4.886578466624872, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7041; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P001", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.4317959225682691, "modern": 0.2950029536826313, "twfe_se": 0.15175510253551105, "x": 2.845346979138496, "y": 1.9439409202968967, "se_normalized_difference": -0.9014060588415992, "homogeneity_pvalue": 2.19866011805386e-06, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.845346979138496, "display_y": 1.9439409202968967, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 2.199e-06; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 10, "study": "Leadership in Social Movements", "specification_id": "S10-P002", "source_specification_id": "paper_c1d607ca2b0f194bccaf989b_table4_col4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.6914907581397147, "modern": 0.6098171388765059, "twfe_se": 0.23881176300149767, "x": 2.895547310772033, "y": 2.553547326195492, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3419999845765412, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0006442741347147e-08, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 10 (2021)", "display_x": 2.895547310772033, "display_y": 2.553547326195492, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.001e-08; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P001", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C4-ALL-OPIOIDS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2053142392239101, "modern": -0.1461503407935394, "twfe_se": 0.031203796039542576, "x": -6.5797840417790345, "y": -4.683735934189943, "se_normalized_difference": 1.896048107589092, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.683735934189943, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 15, "study": "Retail Pharmacies and Drug Diversion", "specification_id": "S15-P002", "source_specification_id": "RPD-T3-C9-OXYCONTIN", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.18941714291972508, "modern": -0.06487917894497999, "twfe_se": 0.05441628787667782, "x": -3.480890562564578, "y": -1.192274987445192, "se_normalized_difference": 2.288615575119386, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 15 (2023)", "display_x": -3.480890562564578, "display_y": -1.192274987445192, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 6, "study": "Railroads of the Raj", "specification_id": "S06-P001", "source_specification_id": "RRR-T4-C1-REAL-INCOME", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00357296649567496, "modern": 0.012993242286345331, "twfe_se": 0.20218780330947986, "x": -0.017671523391576592, "y": 0.06426323484239628, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08193475823397287, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9999999900060716, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 6 (2018)", "display_x": -0.017671523391576592, "display_y": 0.06426323484239628, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 19 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.42594215301121846, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 3.0029270883907704, "se_normalized_difference": 0.44412233935242995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5688713367811945, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 3.0029270883907704, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5689; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.18473694309364502, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.2847501748827035, "se_normalized_difference": 0.39889329152629266, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9542921703889923, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.2847501748827035, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9543; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.1175087094060933, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 1.1814139520448312, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3347048082591956, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2754161303392452, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 1.1814139520448312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2754; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": 0.2208707981145346, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": 1.3905677584074576, "se_normalized_difference": -0.47112704329156324, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6854788675821428, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": 1.3905677584074576, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6855; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.26144575205381165, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 1.5744969021871882, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3918160548713041, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.5106115374240232, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 1.5744969021871882, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.5106; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.14704642912415578, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.908486123049834, "se_normalized_difference": -0.12875187161505738, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.43471124320206456, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.908486123049834, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4347; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.12334687831890981, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.0571567897993446, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25207684340939934, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.11446671685987606, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.0571567897993446, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1145; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": -0.02158858000909039, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": -0.09431343900620366, "se_normalized_difference": 0.31881155493175717, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2837801924891031, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": -0.09431343900620366, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2838; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": -0.19720465361266512, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": -0.9300878109696857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11687930840934309, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24689359680752646, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": -0.9300878109696857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2469; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": 0.10141506672078578, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": 0.8617823674953772, "se_normalized_difference": 0.08725381187999684, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.442574462425947, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": 0.8617823674953772, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.07072027635641516, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 0.4636211521472953, "se_normalized_difference": -0.034013242652897, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.20733533371107649, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 0.4636211521472953, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2073; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.062037859929712315, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -0.6674725889205914, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1557707726822974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7644261615040241, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -0.6674725889205914, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7644; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P001", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F1B-SIZE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2985242372686371, "modern": 0.29781256170431736, "twfe_se": 0.07399533091199685, "x": 4.034365865917594, "y": 4.024748021716503, "se_normalized_difference": -0.009617844201090544, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 4.034365865917594, "display_y": 4.024748021716503, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P002", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F2A-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.2407326507382832, "modern": 0.23333207064136352, "twfe_se": 0.07563931534096853, "x": 3.1826392088968998, "y": 3.084798819100149, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09784038979675042, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1826392088968998, "display_y": 3.084798819100149, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P005", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C1-VANISH-CONFLICT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.029729548421959906, "modern": -0.03784763410230067, "twfe_se": 0.014259074918511055, "x": -2.0849563237349407, "y": -2.654283978350312, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5693276546153714, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0849563237349407, "display_y": -2.654283978350312, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P006", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C3-VANISH-PURCHASE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.00822835391523646, "modern": 0.008619450261432418, "twfe_se": 0.01566429802296934, "x": -0.5252934988322372, "y": 0.5502608702153962, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0755543690476335, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -0.5252934988322372, "display_y": 0.5502608702153962, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P007", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T2-C5-VANISH-EXTINCTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.03852214346804064, "modern": 0.021842430436026128, "twfe_se": 0.028415889530356387, "x": 1.3556550262798515, "y": 0.7686695998973425, "se_normalized_difference": -0.586985426382509, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.3556550262798515, "display_y": 0.7686695998973425, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P008", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C1-SIZE-SINGLE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.22154054083078928, "modern": 0.21409243802411873, "twfe_se": 0.06337713349981079, "x": 3.4955910530641257, "y": 3.3780707047086294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.11752034835549613, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.4955910530641257, "display_y": 3.3780707047086294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P009", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C3-SIZE-UNCONTESTED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18935657850842058, "modern": 0.18408504027258502, "twfe_se": 0.058511023120722476, "x": 3.2362547842947795, "y": 3.1461599960877935, "se_normalized_difference": -0.09009478820698623, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.2362547842947795, "display_y": 3.1461599960877935, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P010", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T3-C5-SIZE-ALL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18010933839074345, "modern": 0.17835022690352453, "twfe_se": 0.061075085940861945, "x": 2.9489821523156023, "y": 2.920179712497143, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028802439818459397, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 2.9489821523156023, "display_y": 2.920179712497143, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P011", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T4-C1-COMPACT-TERRITORY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.18420481067124622, "modern": 0.16377852353219974, "twfe_se": 0.05919483001785045, "x": 3.1118395071951133, "y": 2.7667707379649817, "se_normalized_difference": -0.3450687692301313, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 3.1118395071951133, "display_y": 2.7667707379649817, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P014", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T9-C1-VANISH-NOEXT", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.02920270024836768, "modern": -0.0264029996624148, "twfe_se": 0.013853448593025026, "x": -2.1079733361894264, "y": -1.9058792101562536, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2020941260331727, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.0, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1079733361894264, "display_y": -1.9058792101562536, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.2413395907640687, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -2.9015929435621812, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8464469197062248, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2047592728987791, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -2.9015929435621812, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2048; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.2139493432167725, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -3.0784826173169857, "se_normalized_difference": -0.990609631562876, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -3.0784826173169857, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.1300820525159727, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -1.838100744312126, "se_normalized_difference": -0.5383408583452726, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.24264765541323957, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -1.838100744312126, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2426; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P005", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.1976322869564458, "modern": -0.2806193113899418, "twfe_se": 0.08995321908555387, "x": -2.1970563028820473, "y": -3.1196138864474294, "se_normalized_difference": -0.922557583565382, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16617954483812042, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.1970563028820473, "display_y": -3.1196138864474294, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1662; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.3140427393678433, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -3.2242629699367296, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6987952305532722, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.3215879750210392, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -3.2242629699367296, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3216; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.23839113430397812, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -2.4538694021145138, "se_normalized_difference": -0.25048152488725295, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.14208227793353256, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -2.4538694021145138, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1421; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P003", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8A-INITIAL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.05065020247399928, "modern": 0.05315485520642897, "twfe_se": 0.02398136966268965, "x": 2.1120646229310727, "y": 2.216506227712573, "se_normalized_difference": 0.10444160478150014, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9775744925581922, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 2.1120646229310727, "display_y": 2.216506227712573, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9776; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P004", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-F8B-FULL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.07467736218313017, "modern": -0.08795761261594937, "twfe_se": 0.04482978193546973, "x": -1.6657980244165491, "y": -1.9620352546563806, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2962372302398316, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45013102997146764, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.6657980244165491, "display_y": -1.9620352546563806, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4501; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P006", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C1-INITIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.13734681236512186, "modern": 0.1349766057015137, "twfe_se": 0.03220903817063694, "x": 4.264232034421095, "y": 4.19064378720144, "se_normalized_difference": -0.07358824721965558, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.9994420850606988, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": 4.264232034421095, "display_y": 4.19064378720144, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.9994; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P007", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C2-FULL-EXCL-PARTIAL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.039721651217501285, "modern": -0.05744106277769158, "twfe_se": 0.050805728533818637, "x": -0.7818341034330553, "y": -1.1306020882951449, "se_normalized_difference": -0.34876798486208965, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.33223047213496354, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7818341034330553, "display_y": -1.1306020882951449, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.3322; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P008", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C3-FULL-DROP-LIMITED", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.03441024653904987, "modern": -0.0451620507156221, "twfe_se": 0.049669708930519536, "x": -0.6927813204459209, "y": -0.9092473398383918, "se_normalized_difference": -0.21646601939247087, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.16306560648547455, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.6927813204459209, "display_y": -0.9092473398383918, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.1631; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P009", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C4-FULL-DMSP-2013", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.06437742135856342, "modern": -0.06775557959636926, "twfe_se": 0.05407466514201637, "x": -1.1905283405729634, "y": -1.2530004470378628, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0624721064648995, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.0008678643456103258, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -1.1905283405729634, "display_y": -1.2530004470378628, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.0008679; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P010", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C5-FULL-DMSP-RAW", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.034129483049029005, "modern": 0.009146639060140477, "twfe_se": 0.04398867224053275, "x": -0.7758698162655809, "y": 0.20793169228036926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.98380150854595, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.7657199822961114, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.7758698162655809, "display_y": 0.20793169228036926, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.7657; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 21, "study": "Landmines and Spatial Development", "specification_id": "S21-P011", "source_specification_id": "LANDMINES-T2-C7-FULL-DISTRICT-YEAR", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.04961829037148674, "modern": -0.06304837327176609, "twfe_se": 0.05810665275823827, "x": -0.8539175467210497, "y": -1.0850456923424692, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2311281456214194, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6646258531167744, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 21 (2025)", "display_x": -0.8539175467210497, "display_y": -1.0850456923424692, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6646; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P001", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.20015904475694235, "modern": -0.2302701389429832, "twfe_se": 0.09099161176045499, "x": -2.1997527121937583, "y": -2.530674360942123, "se_normalized_difference": -0.33092164874836466, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.07256341097820927, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.1997527121937583, "display_y": -2.530674360942123, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.07256; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P002", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5866666266332619, "modern": -0.3587760057249104, "twfe_se": 0.21439777269866464, "x": -2.7363466478628946, "y": -1.673412933394457, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0629337144684379, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.6478429577611663, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -2.7363466478628946, "display_y": -1.673412933394457, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6478; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P003", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PA-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.2180655094585218, "modern": -0.04366520037802251, "twfe_se": 0.3747435754693577, "x": -0.5819059317705441, "y": -0.11652021071564163, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4653857210549024, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.654702301900471, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.5819059317705441, "display_y": -0.11652021071564163, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.6547; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P004", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C1-QUANTITY", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.32443914047906564, "modern": -0.553339409278403, "twfe_se": 0.09291827843087484, "x": -3.491661123709123, "y": -5.9551190424825995, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4634579187734764, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8117889624508522, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -3.491661123709123, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8118; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P005", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C2-DISTANCE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.7502544624743879, "modern": -0.7502544624743879, "twfe_se": 0.16706519637830788, "x": -4.490788498973102, "y": -4.490788498973102, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -4.490788498973102, "display_y": -4.490788498973102, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P006", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PB-C3-TIMESEA", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.08658480067380339, "modern": -0.08658461544704904, "twfe_se": 0.36856303915072125, "x": -0.23492534919757688, "y": -0.23492484663292804, "se_normalized_difference": 5.025646488535392e-07, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": -0.23492534919757688, "display_y": -0.23492484663292804, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 9, "study": "Vertical Integration Supplier Behavior and Quality Upgrading", "specification_id": "S09-P007", "source_specification_id": "HHLT-T5-PC-C1-TRIPS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.5245447118342563, "modern": 0.5367294072304346, "twfe_se": 0.12450377843848578, "x": 4.213082674381813, "y": 4.3109487435806555, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09786606919884311, "homogeneity_pvalue": 1.7090130611501043e-05, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 9 (2020)", "display_x": 4.213082674381813, "display_y": 4.3109487435806555, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 1.709e-05; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.02295029924928877, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 0.9944551499490927, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09789785511577183, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.014525389094489763, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 0.9944551499490927, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.01453; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.02491540528604237, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 1.1500765083806341, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3557365880040043, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.23734132618960652, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 1.1500765083806341, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2373; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.03117275671188908, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 1.4240415652910021, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3880859137597521, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.4570063473046029, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 1.4240415652910021, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.457; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 17, "study": "Trading Nontradables", "specification_id": "S17-P002", "source_specification_id": "TN-F2-BASELINE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.7888758993762184, "modern": 0.7967550027391155, "twfe_se": 0.11904766121821768, "x": 6.626555207415515, "y": 6.692739652219134, "se_normalized_difference": 0.06618444480361932, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.8081640057069475, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 17 (2024)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.8082; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P001", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C1", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.41430806278014465, "modern": 0.42527348656207975, "twfe_se": 0.1373506360351823, "x": 3.0164262411862426, "y": 3.096261501498589, "se_normalized_difference": 0.07983526031234624, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.45211921681332806, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 3.0164262411862426, "display_y": 3.096261501498589, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.4521; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 7, "study": "The Arrival of Fast Internet and Employment in Africa", "specification_id": "S07-P002", "source_specification_id": "FIA-T2-C2", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.34659086917588267, "modern": 0.3645272632101659, "twfe_se": 0.1851776291667871, "x": 1.8716670622438565, "y": 1.9685275421786552, "se_normalized_difference": 0.09686047993479888, "homogeneity_pvalue": 0.2838842303671143, "homogeneity_reject_005": false, "paper": "Study 7 (2019)", "display_x": 1.8716670622438565, "display_y": 1.9685275421786552, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 0.2839; does not reject at 5%", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 11, "study": "Hall of Mirrors", "specification_id": "S11-P001", "source_specification_id": "HALL-MIRRORS-F1-COCOMMENT", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": 0.1472449898121927, "modern": 0.1605524415240668, "twfe_se": 0.03234331016239992, "x": 4.552564010079879, "y": 4.964007725799009, "se_normalized_difference": 0.41144371571912974, "homogeneity_pvalue": 7.705583964423773e-89, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 11 (2021)", "display_x": 4.552564010079879, "display_y": 4.964007725799009, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "p = 7.706e-89; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 18 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": -0.5138179527233715, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": -6.0305967709411, "se_normalized_difference": -0.046896934516610075, "homogeneity_pvalue": 5.812088427359851e-72, "homogeneity_reject_005": true, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "p = 5.812e-72; reject at 5%", "draw_order": 20 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": false, "shape": "circle", "size": 215, "stroke": "#111", "strokeWidth": 1.2 }, "encoding": { "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "homogeneity_test", "title": "Homogeneity F-test", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Sun\u2013Abraham estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.homogeneity_reject_005 === true" } ] } ], "height": 720, "title": { "text": "Sun\u2013Abraham vs TWFE", "anchor": "start", "fontSize": 21, "offset": 18, "subtitle": "259 comparisons; 22 capped (diamonds)", "subtitleColor": "#5A6873", "subtitleFontSize": 12, "subtitlePadding": 8 }, "usermeta": { "estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "comparisons": 259, "capped": 22, "homogeneity_rings": 52, "view": "capped" }, "width": 720, "$schema": "https://vega.github.io/schema/vega-lite/v6.4.1.json" }