{
  "schema": "did-replication-v2",
  "config": {
    "outcomes": [
      "y"
    ],
    "treatments": [
      "d"
    ],
    "unit": "unit",
    "time": "time",
    "cluster": "published_cluster",
    "covariates": [],
    "baseline_by_time": [],
    "weight": null,
    "period_step": 1,
    "period_values": null,
    "display_window": [
      -10,
      10
    ],
    "seed": 20261008,
    "panelview_max_units": 100,
    "test_mode": "classical",
    "test_horizon": null,
    "post_horizon": null,
    "post_weighting": "observations",
    "sample_query": null,
    "reversal_policy": "drop_post_untreated",
    "labels": {
      "y": "Auditor Assessment",
      "d": "Phone"
    },
    "allow_repeated_cells": true,
    "time_fe": null,
    "latest_cohort_control": true,
    "slug": "s04-p001",
    "study_id": 4,
    "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms",
    "citation": "Jensen and Miller (2018), AER. https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.20161965",
    "description": "Auditor Assessment",
    "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1",
    "specification_id": "S04-P001",
    "data": "repl-archives/twfe-microdata-replication-private/outputs/estimation_2026_10_06/group_a/MI-T4-C1.csv",
    "output_dir": "analyses/full-archive/results/S04-P001"
  },
  "source": {
    "file": "MI-T4-C1.csv",
    "bytes": 43505,
    "sha256": "68387cfde4ff81825776630896ed4efab0e218105e6ce499b04796921a2cd12e"
  },
  "versions": {
    "pyfixest": "0.60.0",
    "polars": "2.0.0",
    "duckreg": "0.4.1",
    "numpy": "2.5.3",
    "pandas": "3.0.6"
  },
  "specifications": {
    "y__d": {
      "sample": {
        "outcome": "y",
        "treatment": "d",
        "source_rows": 1524,
        "source_sd": 1.343503097108053,
        "rows": 1522,
        "units": 142,
        "clusters": 142,
        "treated_units": 105,
        "never_treated_units": 37,
        "treated_cohorts": 2,
        "latest_cohort_control_index": null,
        "unique_unit_period_cells": 1522,
        "initially_treated_units_removed": 1,
        "post_adoption_untreated_rows_removed": 0,
        "units_without_minus_one_removed": 0,
        "additional_rows_removed": 0
      },
      "estimates": [
        {
          "method": "Static TWFE",
          "estimate": 0.0006672834198579496,
          "se": 0.019252954127550535,
          "pvalue": 0.9724008667723802,
          "lower": -0.03739448784412751,
          "upper": 0.03872905468384341
        },
        {
          "method": "Dynamic TWFE",
          "estimate": 0.07033200324203043,
          "se": 0.03519679347507242,
          "pvalue": 0.04761268371309568,
          "lower": 0.0007503539222031425,
          "upper": 0.13991365256185773
        },
        {
          "method": "BJS / did2s",
          "estimate": 0.08080782994905886,
          "se": 0.041110492953746886,
          "pvalue": 0.05130671899744132,
          "lower": -0.0004647980844799393,
          "upper": 0.16208045798259765
        },
        {
          "method": "Sun\u2013Abraham",
          "estimate": 0.08217984532708654,
          "se": 0.040324897010945965,
          "pvalue": 0.04342536276166551,
          "lower": 0.002460286650214208,
          "upper": 0.16189940400395886
        }
      ],
      "event_studies": {
        "Dynamic TWFE": [
          {
            "event_time": -4,
            "estimate": 0.11554634492816807,
            "se": 0.04516644012464734,
            "pvalue": 0.011576104594619533,
            "lower": 0.026255387216239143,
            "upper": 0.20483730264009697
          },
          {
            "event_time": -3,
            "estimate": 0.10428758650536546,
            "se": 0.06418250177480223,
            "pvalue": 0.10642563353576193,
            "lower": -0.022596822272564876,
            "upper": 0.2311719952832958
          },
          {
            "event_time": -2,
            "estimate": 0.06455143252766683,
            "se": 0.05080905766461232,
            "pvalue": 0.20600924648348387,
            "lower": -0.035894593477338796,
            "upper": 0.16499745853267245
          },
          {
            "event_time": 0,
            "estimate": 0.07392918029021908,
            "se": 0.042184043528192564,
            "pvalue": 0.08185483737433956,
            "lower": -0.009465783678582765,
            "upper": 0.15732414425902091
          },
          {
            "event_time": 1,
            "estimate": 0.061856777273755374,
            "se": 0.04142878009738332,
            "pvalue": 0.13764867710174875,
            "lower": -0.02004508263646574,
            "upper": 0.1437586371839765
          },
          {
            "event_time": 2,
            "estimate": -0.018303831285194628,
            "se": 0.03565475132367279,
            "pvalue": 0.6085008557895776,
            "lower": -0.08879083189638717,
            "upper": 0.052183169325997925
          },
          {
            "event_time": 3,
            "estimate": 0.043352380453082345,
            "se": 0.03715774794010287,
            "pvalue": 0.24529626672792543,
            "lower": -0.030105941496441566,
            "upper": 0.11681070240260626
          },
          {
            "event_time": 4,
            "estimate": 0.057997957413270074,
            "se": 0.04691790895056232,
            "pvalue": 0.2184550872145866,
            "lower": -0.03475553417197143,
            "upper": 0.15075144899851156
          },
          {
            "event_time": 5,
            "estimate": 0.06904063037387512,
            "se": 0.046129353129174475,
            "pvalue": 0.13671305968162137,
            "lower": -0.022153940377518902,
            "upper": 0.16023520112526912
          },
          {
            "event_time": 6,
            "estimate": 0.0726507179691227,
            "se": 0.04719485235260782,
            "pvalue": 0.12595322289742394,
            "lower": -0.020650271748192048,
            "upper": 0.16595170768643747
          },
          {
            "event_time": 7,
            "estimate": 0.12855478373971563,
            "se": 0.052757290721014025,
            "pvalue": 0.01606746871207279,
            "lower": 0.024257234458311322,
            "upper": 0.23285233302111993
          },
          {
            "event_time": 8,
            "estimate": 0.13371083428014113,
            "se": 0.061849091056040854,
            "pvalue": 0.032314401223163744,
            "lower": 0.01143941862804683,
            "upper": 0.25598224993223545
          },
          {
            "event_time": 9,
            "estimate": 0.1841755189098761,
            "se": 0.061338784043774984,
            "pvalue": 0.003167647823283725,
            "lower": 0.06291294525920106,
            "upper": 0.30543809256055116
          },
          {
            "event_time": 10,
            "estimate": 0.21091644291342124,
            "se": 0.08532952439907356,
            "pvalue": 0.014634304930456896,
            "lower": 0.042225819218707966,
            "upper": 0.3796070666081345
          },
          {
            "event_time": 11,
            "estimate": 0.09526566550091436,
            "se": 0.09566617671769172,
            "pvalue": 0.32104667373356605,
            "lower": -0.09385981164953941,
            "upper": 0.2843911426513681
          }
        ],
        "BJS / did2s": [
          {
            "event_time": -4,
            "estimate": 0.011265179778207414,
            "se": 0.015313980440989363,
            "pvalue": 0.46318748826619716,
            "lower": -0.01900951037191352,
            "upper": 0.041539869928328345
          },
          {
            "event_time": -3,
            "estimate": 0.017103005404776564,
            "se": 0.01934224990382797,
            "pvalue": 0.3780771282979791,
            "lower": -0.021135297491133798,
            "upper": 0.055341308300686926
          },
          {
            "event_time": -2,
            "estimate": -0.004925665770702813,
            "se": 0.013672492769278406,
            "pvalue": 0.7191910598505153,
            "lower": -0.03195524725441343,
            "upper": 0.022103915713007804
          },
          {
            "event_time": -1,
            "estimate": -0.010716580304719305,
            "se": 0.007306031857062021,
            "pvalue": 0.14465386350165724,
            "lower": -0.0251601047399102,
            "upper": 0.0037269441304715913
          },
          {
            "event_time": 0,
            "estimate": 0.046420295630176626,
            "se": 0.02992438058348819,
            "pvalue": 0.12308265947620824,
            "lower": -0.012738154623196607,
            "upper": 0.10557874588354986
          },
          {
            "event_time": 1,
            "estimate": 0.050820208834693126,
            "se": 0.037058061885338126,
            "pvalue": 0.17243903627688753,
            "lower": -0.02244104061418864,
            "upper": 0.12408145828357489
          },
          {
            "event_time": 2,
            "estimate": 0.01164843338007279,
            "se": 0.040655664921650535,
            "pvalue": 0.7749047310192652,
            "lower": -0.06872503079490118,
            "upper": 0.09202189755504676
          },
          {
            "event_time": 3,
            "estimate": 0.035937390345329334,
            "se": 0.03704713330329272,
            "pvalue": 0.3336850762263517,
            "lower": -0.037302254045580754,
            "upper": 0.10917703473623942
          },
          {
            "event_time": 4,
            "estimate": 0.054881595736017,
            "se": 0.04785469733129642,
            "pvalue": 0.25339086782647025,
            "lower": -0.039723862297284446,
            "upper": 0.14948705376931845
          },
          {
            "event_time": 5,
            "estimate": 0.08997928649022403,
            "se": 0.05888776449728999,
            "pvalue": 0.12875789307754687,
            "lower": -0.02643778943974677,
            "upper": 0.20639636242019482
          },
          {
            "event_time": 6,
            "estimate": 0.09413729476357248,
            "se": 0.058211303684017245,
            "pvalue": 0.10807768290873225,
            "lower": -0.020942464483812304,
            "upper": 0.20921705401095725
          },
          {
            "event_time": 7,
            "estimate": 0.1505525660864608,
            "se": 0.06192768149455627,
            "pvalue": 0.016308308668869887,
            "lower": 0.028125782521759818,
            "upper": 0.2729793496511618
          },
          {
            "event_time": 8,
            "estimate": 0.13125489554030487,
            "se": 0.07503142055270497,
            "pvalue": 0.08240939806067597,
            "lower": -0.017077082387296827,
            "upper": 0.27958687346790656
          },
          {
            "event_time": 9,
            "estimate": 0.2525350823421784,
            "se": 0.09285254585394245,
            "pvalue": 0.007355266313293242,
            "lower": 0.06897196064366373,
            "upper": 0.4360982040406931
          },
          {
            "event_time": 10,
            "estimate": 0.312745747790233,
            "se": 0.12540896392824794,
            "pvalue": 0.013793670897337709,
            "lower": 0.0648208180434825,
            "upper": 0.5606706775369835
          },
          {
            "event_time": 11,
            "estimate": 0.1907272963670297,
            "se": 0.1394680075304243,
            "pvalue": 0.17363374173728227,
            "lower": -0.08499139937694519,
            "upper": 0.46644599211100457
          }
        ],
        "Sun\u2013Abraham": [
          {
            "event_time": -4,
            "estimate": 0.07973390457998816,
            "se": 0.05583495808095784,
            "pvalue": 0.15549490319081988,
            "lower": -0.030647982216830932,
            "upper": 0.19011579137680726
          },
          {
            "event_time": -3,
            "estimate": 0.09314512637530561,
            "se": 0.0681829497990775,
            "pvalue": 0.17408062576668815,
            "lower": -0.04164789407045921,
            "upper": 0.22793814682107044
          },
          {
            "event_time": -2,
            "estimate": 0.042538719132020696,
            "se": 0.05721620878010904,
            "pvalue": 0.4584322743500472,
            "lower": -0.07057380566564847,
            "upper": 0.15565124392968988
          },
          {
            "event_time": 0,
            "estimate": 0.07515073927448791,
            "se": 0.047273802380142,
            "pvalue": 0.11414420157472563,
            "lower": -0.01830632923828769,
            "upper": 0.16860780778726353
          },
          {
            "event_time": 1,
            "estimate": 0.06358663671151148,
            "se": 0.04366652066824237,
            "pvalue": 0.14756394087879565,
            "lower": -0.022739082996635282,
            "upper": 0.14991235641965822
          },
          {
            "event_time": 2,
            "estimate": 0.011191244334462332,
            "se": 0.0422269173802805,
            "pvalue": 0.7913762414156497,
            "lower": -0.0722884783025712,
            "upper": 0.09467096697149587
          },
          {
            "event_time": 3,
            "estimate": 0.05008045617698686,
            "se": 0.03893990428993417,
            "pvalue": 0.20051747608659362,
            "lower": -0.026901066778188036,
            "upper": 0.12706197913216175
          },
          {
            "event_time": 4,
            "estimate": 0.06374671278418358,
            "se": 0.051777064931292915,
            "pvalue": 0.22030644513365072,
            "lower": -0.0386129972675497,
            "upper": 0.16610642283591687
          },
          {
            "event_time": 5,
            "estimate": 0.0946037795810417,
            "se": 0.05499262653678771,
            "pvalue": 0.08757190323261912,
            "lower": -0.014112875462237537,
            "upper": 0.20332043462432092
          },
          {
            "event_time": 6,
            "estimate": 0.09056152633170175,
            "se": 0.04931395641928697,
            "pvalue": 0.06840047924717,
            "lower": -0.006928786942723905,
            "upper": 0.18805183960612742
          },
          {
            "event_time": 7,
            "estimate": 0.14283246995994447,
            "se": 0.054911714132205344,
            "pvalue": 0.010282686365924885,
            "lower": 0.03427577319710523,
            "upper": 0.2513891667227837
          },
          {
            "event_time": 8,
            "estimate": 0.12559939091864922,
            "se": 0.06547935281842146,
            "pvalue": 0.05711308736112097,
            "lower": -0.0038488035234801876,
            "upper": 0.25504758536077865
          },
          {
            "event_time": 9,
            "estimate": 0.20242626157406013,
            "se": 0.07513522934035378,
            "pvalue": 0.00791374977684439,
            "lower": 0.053889060785358545,
            "upper": 0.3509634623627617
          },
          {
            "event_time": 10,
            "estimate": 0.24564800055528246,
            "se": 0.0994866966156962,
            "pvalue": 0.014737825168650886,
            "lower": 0.04896961731550989,
            "upper": 0.44232638379505507
          },
          {
            "event_time": 11,
            "estimate": 0.11750439267779784,
            "se": 0.10674203982347967,
            "pvalue": 0.27284821397903297,
            "lower": -0.09351730701029053,
            "upper": 0.3285260923658862
          }
        ]
      },
      "target": {
        "event_times": [
          0.0,
          1.0,
          2.0,
          3.0,
          4.0,
          5.0,
          6.0,
          7.0,
          8.0,
          9.0,
          10.0,
          11.0
        ],
        "weights": [
          0.13141426783479349,
          0.13016270337922403,
          0.12891113892365458,
          0.1251564455569462,
          0.11013767209011265,
          0.08385481852315395,
          0.0688360450563204,
          0.06382978723404255,
          0.06132665832290363,
          0.03504380475594493,
          0.03128911138923655,
          0.030037546933667083
        ],
        "weighting": "observations"
      },
      "checks": {
        "did2s_vs_direct_imputation_max_post_difference": 5.551115123125783e-17,
        "package_aggregate_vs_estimable_cell_weights": 0.0,
        "saturated_vs_deviations_relative_rss_difference": 1.588259637072603e-15
      },
      "inference": {
        "standard_errors": "Cluster-robust; did2s uses two-stage covariance",
        "confidence_intervals": "Pointwise t, clusters minus one degrees of freedom"
      },
      "f_test": {
        "F": 0.8617702343438123,
        "df_num": 8,
        "df_den": 1344,
        "pvalue": 0.5483424989161068,
        "log10_pvalue": -0.2609480931107136,
        "inference": "Homoskedastic nested-model F",
        "observations": 1522,
        "design_columns": 24,
        "restricted_design_columns": 16,
        "fixed_effect_rank": 154,
        "covariance_rank": 8,
        "rss_unrestricted": 58.15834734619678,
        "rss_restricted": 58.45667551656333,
        "test_horizon": null,
        "reference_cohort": 2,
        "pyfixest": "0.27.0",
        "formulaic": "1.0.2",
        "design_head": {
          "index": [
            0,
            1,
            2,
            3,
            4
          ],
          "columns": [
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.-4.0]",
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.-3.0]",
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.-2.0]",
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.0.0]",
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]",
            "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]"
          ],
          "data": [
            [
              -0.31293205577935596,
              0.025096113234728476,
              0.025096113234728476,
              -0.009372512981857794,
              -0.00634158279727411,
              -0.003463733539881984
            ],
            [
              0.025096113234728476,
              -0.31293205577935596,
              0.025096113234728476,
              0.5892190363139169,
              -0.00634158279727411,
              -0.003463733539881984
            ],
            [
              0.025096113234728476,
              0.025096113234728476,
              -0.31293205577935596,
              -0.009372512981857794,
              0.5922499664985007,
              -0.003463733539881984
            ],
            [
              0.025096113234728476,
              0.025096113234728476,
              0.025096113234728476,
              -0.009372512981857794,
              -0.00634158279727411,
              0.5951278157558928
            ],
            [
              0.026303356678752277,
              0.026303356678752277,
              0.02630335667875228,
              -0.3543674828045773,
              -0.008479409761904661,
              -0.005601560514914014
            ]
          ]
        },
        "formula": "y~i(rel_time,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_5,ref=-1.0)|unit+time_fe",
        "restriction_names": [
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_5",
          "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_5"
        ],
        "deviations": [
          {
            "event_time": 0.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.08632371134209268
          },
          {
            "event_time": 1.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.04652912427804946
          },
          {
            "event_time": 2.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": 0.006685358656089777
          },
          {
            "event_time": 3.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": 0.01840150604345912
          },
          {
            "event_time": 4.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.01725381843210139
          },
          {
            "event_time": 5.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.18866074926906054
          },
          {
            "event_time": 6.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.12319060922803687
          },
          {
            "event_time": 7.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.042763844956812125
          },
          {
            "event_time": 8.0,
            "cohort": 5,
            "estimate": -0.06393319228328617
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  },
  "code_sha256": {
    "replication_engine.py": "f9d56fa725aee6a41a1b7f11796f1d432696b3a0c8161ac280f273cca73f63c2",
    "reference_f_test.py": "18f7ea6e16e141249b386529a195514afb1ec80e236d4684c7efac07347c8bdb"
  }
}