{ "config": { "view": { "continuousWidth": 300, "continuousHeight": 300, "stroke": null }, "axis": { "domainColor": "#A0ABB4", "gridColor": "#E5E9ED", "gridWidth": 0.6, "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "labelPadding": 5, "tickColor": "#A0ABB4", "titleColor": "#172B3A", "titleFontSize": 14, "titleFontWeight": "normal", "titlePadding": 12 }, "background": "white", "font": "DejaVu Sans", "legend": { "columnPadding": 18, "columns": 4, "direction": "horizontal", "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "offset": 24, "orient": "bottom", "rowPadding": 7, "symbolLimit": 1000, "symbolOpacity": 1, "symbolSize": 45, "symbolType": "circle" }, "title": { "color": "#172B3A" } }, "layer": [ { "data": { "values": [ { "start": -5, "end": 5 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#343E47", "strokeDash": [ 5, 4 ], "strokeWidth": 1.1 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "x2": { "field": "end" }, "y": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "y2": { "field": "end" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "y": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.1968348662935391, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 1.7299984589970778, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1558950440315926, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 1.7299984589970778, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.17785546630331156, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 1.3259311030963865, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4034406178342599, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 1.3259311030963865, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.243395282152075, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 1.9671709901532715, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1703534769107733, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 1.9671709901532715, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.18293828952869204, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.7284974412126906, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0055182773027800235, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.7284974412126906, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.26435757556001244, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 2.7668521137499136, "se_normalized_difference": -0.45024342626499575, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 2.7668521137499136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.2248104909471848, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4267860017982645, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23947112930887907, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4267860017982645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 2.0812444473529625, "se_normalized_difference": -0.37415539553290944, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 2.0812444473529625, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.038865603647443965, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.2907555022594998, "se_normalized_difference": 0.11731180414945853, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.2907555022594998, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.26893664935478195, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 2.9025288285417856, "se_normalized_difference": 2.5269079077142518, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 2.9025288285417856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.24904205383548816, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.197790999737314, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7849724955103787, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.197790999737314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": 0.19493219977497012, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": 2.2723297540112926, "se_normalized_difference": 1.435800442034257, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": 2.2723297540112926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": -0.09503625508582456, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": -1.0093279985855126, "se_normalized_difference": -2.686868894454147, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": -1.0093279985855126, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.12510323852077276, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.939623763473195, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2822627867693153, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.939623763473195, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.17541292024781988, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 1.9242791327777347, "se_normalized_difference": 1.263964262995446, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 1.9242791327777347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": 0.011904223595905723, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": 0.11765745362135453, "se_normalized_difference": -0.27403746951695473, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": 0.11765745362135453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.18416629535735, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.6592552786454047, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9992505592072503, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.6592552786454047, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.15320044972034627, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 1.5367690062345962, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25688215435346157, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 1.5367690062345962, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.07491350340050888, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.7386884477438731, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8073475062048978, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.7386884477438731, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 2.13647968337318, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7150004916001228, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 2.13647968337318, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.2543347813592091, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 2.7547057487746716, "se_normalized_difference": 1.203823938913917, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 2.7547057487746716, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.24243269336868634, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 2.6835121339634185, "se_normalized_difference": 1.379902660737298, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 2.6835121339634185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 3.485914549165386, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7914837428944888, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 3.485914549165386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.03676325497054096, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 0.3316094862516826, "se_normalized_difference": -3.5505936280145405, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 0.3316094862516826, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.0882545304980701, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -0.840646194043645, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2275044683687755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -0.840646194043645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": -0.041204530195972575, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": -0.3310086852478959, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3683918580679302, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": -0.3310086852478959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": -0.12366149904646326, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": -0.8386193603417296, "se_normalized_difference": -1.8899795803385593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": -0.8386193603417296, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.015100183162598263, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 0.13292611950497232, "se_normalized_difference": -2.139273611643295, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 0.13292611950497232, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": -1.013139273761133, "se_normalized_difference": -3.1989732528528476, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": -1.013139273761133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 3.177573374734264, "se_normalized_difference": 1.9006343436312647, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 3.177573374734264, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0237936083438006, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1153310249182301, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0237936083438006, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.0008392377342642223, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -0.012853199914074246, "se_normalized_difference": 0.022225952773865233, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -0.012853199914074246, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.2061109075755187, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.320094259170025, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2495923826966735, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.320094259170025, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.006752672573333551, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 0.06378004182440425, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48520617926663695, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 0.06378004182440425, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1297680978023072, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.2625894607308248, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028596041613202793, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.2625894607308248, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.148126476953765, "se_normalized_difference": 0.29731104808983877, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.148126476953765, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": 0.1652549704216297, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7017659281868152, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": 0.1652549704216297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.00020165925944563013, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -0.0017008361367872014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1407419911553307, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -0.0017008361367872014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": -0.061906057913820096, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": -0.4821430984156602, "se_normalized_difference": -0.365705593079389, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": -0.4821430984156602, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": 0.10918049363117435, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": 0.834905220364926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9612708643682949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": 0.834905220364926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": 0.10814893073221972, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8293410970888576, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": 0.10814893073221972, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.42984742704281254, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -3.96062068455452, "se_normalized_difference": -3.4152005756352124, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -3.96062068455452, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.0365599630880471, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.27932879869822824, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4219874951693367, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.27932879869822824, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": -0.24818129472721326, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": -2.3173500315032443, "se_normalized_difference": -3.259948043881154, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": -2.3173500315032443, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.08676428031392841, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 0.8945394143315677, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0277334296267788, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 0.8945394143315677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": -2.493987834174835, "se_normalized_difference": -3.6140323888567703, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": -2.493987834174835, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.2950304764830441, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 1.9895342304526435, "se_normalized_difference": 1.190254975751332, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 1.9895342304526435, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": 0.20760114513306543, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": 1.5258150627999278, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4595342707878537, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": 1.5258150627999278, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 2.440861113769037, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2542040108025876, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 2.440861113769037, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -1.1327327005736298, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3829206566256778, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -1.1327327005736298, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.3138535072417889, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 2.225273763286343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6854896372630422, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 2.225273763286343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.28697117011338297, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 1.997538760171438, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2430898687550956, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 1.997538760171438, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.32461135081791587, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 3.3347583580891453, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8990758359168755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 3.3347583580891453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": -0.10559724490425232, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": -0.6986243023324156, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2588459945566806, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": -0.6986243023324156, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.40599369834699806, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 3.447109975178334, "se_normalized_difference": 1.19986508722258, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 3.447109975178334, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.01424846941699318, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.0793074175068347, "se_normalized_difference": -0.047333135547346424, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.0793074175068347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.13234577061775446, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.8263190251737959, "se_normalized_difference": -0.17273174431876187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.8263190251737959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": 0.04276786947607457, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": 0.2419897760768133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7088797686785014, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": 0.2419897760768133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": 0.006508146520436092, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": 0.032041247079287, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6748144851933274, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": 0.032041247079287, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": -0.24271857095084506, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": -1.6069252399135117, "se_normalized_difference": -2.017860174802819, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": -1.6069252399135117, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.3105276124651162, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 2.4636790459635978, "se_normalized_difference": 1.114210705718187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 2.4636790459635978, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.15470509625418946, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -1.0466680210381254, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2780336235314036, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -1.0466680210381254, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8978248374106115, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 53.617200479060784, "se_normalized_difference": 2.209149281675146, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.23132853017175992, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 2.2848743649397822, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8453594737576519, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 2.2848743649397822, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.19202912435914468, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.476059979148172, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6491921202378833, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.476059979148172, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2642718623903228, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.6517339866447736, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9784006145496593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.6517339866447736, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": 0.11512328689103152, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": 1.076436952896589, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7474054146144808, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": 1.076436952896589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.22053192079970058, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 1.8069185928007465, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4390416792879989, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 1.8069185928007465, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.1313298161590262, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -3.5282605356679815, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4631248829489856, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.5282605356679815, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.12419501439442306, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -2.966144537229915, "se_normalized_difference": 4.006717222008618, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -2.966144537229915, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.019450122296723913, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.3271904844684415, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4822534270821075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.3271904844684415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.010446299197532883, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.14740966323394827, "se_normalized_difference": 2.2927149198062593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.14740966323394827, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": -0.04549909291432021, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": -0.5633140844802477, "se_normalized_difference": -2.576111548317189, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": -0.5633140844802477, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.17233390688743072, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.022197289640984, "se_normalized_difference": 2.110817096907396, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.022197289640984, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": 0.012524059045718378, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": 0.1636250397064726, "se_normalized_difference": 3.0595677540307005, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": 0.1636250397064726, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.6907772449565002, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 3.180126629797394, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8087927164766773, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 3.180126629797394, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.09145604538612041, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.330318186773222, "se_normalized_difference": -3.341030845721167, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.330318186773222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.3069726812890671, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.7654668362274366, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8826914094268054, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.7654668362274366, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": 0.07651686405673636, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": 1.0929638545324678, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5615228857174066, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": 1.0929638545324678, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": -0.44158658600568346, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": -1.7993858016630508, "se_normalized_difference": -2.8486305751432432, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": -1.7993858016630508, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.33645246730280537, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -6.414736137513455, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7648376970620165, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.49148914659139925, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -5.915629987922917, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6752461802761296, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.5543978488968974, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -6.158815771159379, "se_normalized_difference": -4.22813004027319, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.22284049443955675, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 11.574353367449056, "se_normalized_difference": 11.539694612463343, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.8490747523821184, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -8.881747470617354, "se_normalized_difference": -6.183518836088058, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.09971958372515587, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 1.159217697458231, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223338358386383, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 1.159217697458231, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.8360059014650376, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -8.55645853985085, "se_normalized_difference": -5.907362219347513, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.4765194429899556, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -12.407896143621349, "se_normalized_difference": -10.518476182888191, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.16329526072171513, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -4.434718840467875, "se_normalized_difference": -4.313169085007901, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -4.434718840467875, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.4410821552360305, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -12.163395560061515, "se_normalized_difference": -10.383081967384674, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0793747343927345, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.7372902907127563, "se_normalized_difference": -0.03844291029513909, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.7372902907127563, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.8303807628780522, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 2.606067660354553, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0141323675963132, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 2.606067660354553, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 1.1269856262714735, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 3.2617350208880813, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8838069232697292, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 3.2617350208880813, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 1.1377091691317782, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 3.1206517903681785, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2437426284156063, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 3.1206517903681785, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.5016893081651924, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 17.47437143893577, "se_normalized_difference": 9.595155916896957, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.29645344748321584, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 6.610602398528956, "se_normalized_difference": 2.950744984113429, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.509399649429192, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 17.572781963788863, "se_normalized_difference": 9.78211857540941, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.2990356557656308, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 6.534814451347721, "se_normalized_difference": 2.901277376670988, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 2.040336149216232, "se_normalized_difference": -0.518468599822108, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 2.040336149216232, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.6623792054333075, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7765223220768968, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.6623792054333075, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 3.180235565397664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3335264216120284, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 3.180235565397664, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": -0.863237973172137, "se_normalized_difference": -2.724932774871158, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": -0.863237973172137, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 2.043402900434037, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8607220531181528, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 2.043402900434037, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.8537365593815207, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18350143528337068, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.8537365593815207, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.1233912344904784, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1858423987182656, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.1233912344904784, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": 0.10048727997511618, "se_normalized_difference": 0.513612273913077, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": 0.10048727997511618, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": 0.07344059764605994, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8866491002064025, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": 0.07344059764605994, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": -2.073528247886675, "se_normalized_difference": -2.848056803502055, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": -2.073528247886675, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 2.289590028538141, "se_normalized_difference": 1.791955633737949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 2.289590028538141, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -1.1240709613629871, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6123691451246932, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -1.1240709613629871, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.5679708940851196, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -6.828636500163685, "se_normalized_difference": -4.773490476307728, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -7.008467277682474, "se_normalized_difference": -4.9205942919283645, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.48876568806058124, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -6.906414510242054, "se_normalized_difference": -5.6066546242752, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -5.000794409638612, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4753266702551544, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.5122122046192551, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -5.272435403164379, "se_normalized_difference": -3.0690475259371177, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P003", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5A-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.618170129730673, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.6799433693738065, "x": 0.9091494344594852, "y": -0.15343514541988482, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06258457987937, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.9091494344594852, "display_y": -0.15343514541988482, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P004", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5B-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19611887422714344, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.5415606686426057, "x": 0.3621364799602332, "y": -0.28407309311387524, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6462095730741084, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.3621364799602332, "display_y": -0.28407309311387524, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P012", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C1-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6123433590401681, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.586415027748376, "x": 1.0442149843794892, "y": -0.17790678072786714, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2221217651073564, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.0442149843794892, "display_y": -0.17790678072786714, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P013", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C3-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2555657596969807, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.48203992765186965, "x": 0.5301755000709213, "y": -0.3191495256410151, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8493250257119365, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.5301755000709213, "display_y": -0.3191495256410151, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.08458449736888857, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 3.665115129901997, "se_normalized_difference": 2.768557835068676, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 3.665115129901997, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.17986442248622828, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 8.302407471201867, "se_normalized_difference": 7.5080675508252375, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.19727869764236783, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 9.01213415244927, "se_normalized_difference": 7.976178500918021, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": 0.03214054573252869, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": 0.3772282970720262, "se_normalized_difference": 6.360928133496516, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": 0.3772282970720262, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": false, "shape": "diamond", "size": 120, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#A95E00", "#F09556", "#332288", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Horizontal ridge estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.capped && datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.1968348662935391, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 1.7299984589970778, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1558950440315926, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 1.7299984589970778, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.17785546630331156, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 1.3259311030963865, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4034406178342599, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 1.3259311030963865, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.243395282152075, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 1.9671709901532715, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1703534769107733, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 1.9671709901532715, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.18293828952869204, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.7284974412126906, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0055182773027800235, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.7284974412126906, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.26435757556001244, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 2.7668521137499136, "se_normalized_difference": -0.45024342626499575, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 2.7668521137499136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.2248104909471848, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4267860017982645, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23947112930887907, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4267860017982645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 2.0812444473529625, "se_normalized_difference": -0.37415539553290944, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 2.0812444473529625, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.038865603647443965, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.2907555022594998, "se_normalized_difference": 0.11731180414945853, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.2907555022594998, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.26893664935478195, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 2.9025288285417856, "se_normalized_difference": 2.5269079077142518, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 2.9025288285417856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.24904205383548816, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.197790999737314, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7849724955103787, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.197790999737314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": 0.19493219977497012, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": 2.2723297540112926, "se_normalized_difference": 1.435800442034257, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": 2.2723297540112926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": -0.09503625508582456, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": -1.0093279985855126, "se_normalized_difference": -2.686868894454147, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": -1.0093279985855126, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.12510323852077276, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.939623763473195, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2822627867693153, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.939623763473195, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.17541292024781988, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 1.9242791327777347, "se_normalized_difference": 1.263964262995446, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 1.9242791327777347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": 0.011904223595905723, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": 0.11765745362135453, "se_normalized_difference": -0.27403746951695473, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": 0.11765745362135453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.18416629535735, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.6592552786454047, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9992505592072503, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.6592552786454047, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.15320044972034627, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 1.5367690062345962, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25688215435346157, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 1.5367690062345962, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.07491350340050888, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.7386884477438731, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8073475062048978, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.7386884477438731, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 2.13647968337318, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7150004916001228, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 2.13647968337318, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.2543347813592091, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 2.7547057487746716, "se_normalized_difference": 1.203823938913917, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 2.7547057487746716, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.24243269336868634, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 2.6835121339634185, "se_normalized_difference": 1.379902660737298, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 2.6835121339634185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 3.485914549165386, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7914837428944888, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 3.485914549165386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.03676325497054096, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 0.3316094862516826, "se_normalized_difference": -3.5505936280145405, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 0.3316094862516826, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.0882545304980701, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -0.840646194043645, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2275044683687755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -0.840646194043645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": -0.041204530195972575, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": -0.3310086852478959, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3683918580679302, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": -0.3310086852478959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": -0.12366149904646326, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": -0.8386193603417296, "se_normalized_difference": -1.8899795803385593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": -0.8386193603417296, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.015100183162598263, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 0.13292611950497232, "se_normalized_difference": -2.139273611643295, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 0.13292611950497232, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": -1.013139273761133, "se_normalized_difference": -3.1989732528528476, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": -1.013139273761133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 3.177573374734264, "se_normalized_difference": 1.9006343436312647, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 3.177573374734264, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0237936083438006, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1153310249182301, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0237936083438006, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.0008392377342642223, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -0.012853199914074246, "se_normalized_difference": 0.022225952773865233, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -0.012853199914074246, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.2061109075755187, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.320094259170025, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2495923826966735, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.320094259170025, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.006752672573333551, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 0.06378004182440425, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48520617926663695, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 0.06378004182440425, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1297680978023072, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.2625894607308248, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028596041613202793, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.2625894607308248, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.148126476953765, "se_normalized_difference": 0.29731104808983877, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.148126476953765, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": 0.1652549704216297, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7017659281868152, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": 0.1652549704216297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.00020165925944563013, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -0.0017008361367872014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1407419911553307, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -0.0017008361367872014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": -0.061906057913820096, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": -0.4821430984156602, "se_normalized_difference": -0.365705593079389, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": -0.4821430984156602, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": 0.10918049363117435, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": 0.834905220364926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9612708643682949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": 0.834905220364926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": 0.10814893073221972, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8293410970888576, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": 0.10814893073221972, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.42984742704281254, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -3.96062068455452, "se_normalized_difference": -3.4152005756352124, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -3.96062068455452, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.0365599630880471, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.27932879869822824, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4219874951693367, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.27932879869822824, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": -0.24818129472721326, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": -2.3173500315032443, "se_normalized_difference": -3.259948043881154, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": -2.3173500315032443, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.08676428031392841, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 0.8945394143315677, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0277334296267788, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 0.8945394143315677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": -2.493987834174835, "se_normalized_difference": -3.6140323888567703, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": -2.493987834174835, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.2950304764830441, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 1.9895342304526435, "se_normalized_difference": 1.190254975751332, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 1.9895342304526435, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": 0.20760114513306543, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": 1.5258150627999278, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4595342707878537, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": 1.5258150627999278, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 2.440861113769037, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2542040108025876, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 2.440861113769037, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -1.1327327005736298, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3829206566256778, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -1.1327327005736298, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.3138535072417889, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 2.225273763286343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6854896372630422, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 2.225273763286343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.28697117011338297, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 1.997538760171438, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2430898687550956, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 1.997538760171438, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.32461135081791587, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 3.3347583580891453, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8990758359168755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 3.3347583580891453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": -0.10559724490425232, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": -0.6986243023324156, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2588459945566806, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": -0.6986243023324156, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.40599369834699806, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 3.447109975178334, "se_normalized_difference": 1.19986508722258, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 3.447109975178334, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.01424846941699318, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.0793074175068347, "se_normalized_difference": -0.047333135547346424, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.0793074175068347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.13234577061775446, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.8263190251737959, "se_normalized_difference": -0.17273174431876187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.8263190251737959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": 0.04276786947607457, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": 0.2419897760768133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7088797686785014, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": 0.2419897760768133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": 0.006508146520436092, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": 0.032041247079287, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6748144851933274, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": 0.032041247079287, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": -0.24271857095084506, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": -1.6069252399135117, "se_normalized_difference": -2.017860174802819, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": -1.6069252399135117, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.3105276124651162, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 2.4636790459635978, "se_normalized_difference": 1.114210705718187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 2.4636790459635978, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.15470509625418946, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -1.0466680210381254, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2780336235314036, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -1.0466680210381254, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8978248374106115, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 53.617200479060784, "se_normalized_difference": 2.209149281675146, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.23132853017175992, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 2.2848743649397822, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8453594737576519, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 2.2848743649397822, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.19202912435914468, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.476059979148172, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6491921202378833, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.476059979148172, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2642718623903228, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.6517339866447736, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9784006145496593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.6517339866447736, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": 0.11512328689103152, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": 1.076436952896589, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7474054146144808, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": 1.076436952896589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.22053192079970058, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 1.8069185928007465, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4390416792879989, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 1.8069185928007465, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.1313298161590262, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -3.5282605356679815, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4631248829489856, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.5282605356679815, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.12419501439442306, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -2.966144537229915, "se_normalized_difference": 4.006717222008618, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -2.966144537229915, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.019450122296723913, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.3271904844684415, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4822534270821075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.3271904844684415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.010446299197532883, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.14740966323394827, "se_normalized_difference": 2.2927149198062593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.14740966323394827, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": -0.04549909291432021, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": -0.5633140844802477, "se_normalized_difference": -2.576111548317189, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": -0.5633140844802477, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.17233390688743072, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.022197289640984, "se_normalized_difference": 2.110817096907396, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.022197289640984, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": 0.012524059045718378, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": 0.1636250397064726, "se_normalized_difference": 3.0595677540307005, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": 0.1636250397064726, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.6907772449565002, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 3.180126629797394, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8087927164766773, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 3.180126629797394, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.09145604538612041, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.330318186773222, "se_normalized_difference": -3.341030845721167, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.330318186773222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.3069726812890671, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.7654668362274366, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8826914094268054, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.7654668362274366, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": 0.07651686405673636, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": 1.0929638545324678, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5615228857174066, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": 1.0929638545324678, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": -0.44158658600568346, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": -1.7993858016630508, "se_normalized_difference": -2.8486305751432432, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": -1.7993858016630508, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.33645246730280537, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -6.414736137513455, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7648376970620165, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.49148914659139925, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -5.915629987922917, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6752461802761296, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.5543978488968974, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -6.158815771159379, "se_normalized_difference": -4.22813004027319, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.22284049443955675, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 11.574353367449056, "se_normalized_difference": 11.539694612463343, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.8490747523821184, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -8.881747470617354, "se_normalized_difference": -6.183518836088058, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.09971958372515587, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 1.159217697458231, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223338358386383, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 1.159217697458231, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.8360059014650376, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -8.55645853985085, "se_normalized_difference": -5.907362219347513, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.4765194429899556, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -12.407896143621349, "se_normalized_difference": -10.518476182888191, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.16329526072171513, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -4.434718840467875, "se_normalized_difference": -4.313169085007901, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -4.434718840467875, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.4410821552360305, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -12.163395560061515, "se_normalized_difference": -10.383081967384674, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0793747343927345, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.7372902907127563, "se_normalized_difference": -0.03844291029513909, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.7372902907127563, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.8303807628780522, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 2.606067660354553, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0141323675963132, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 2.606067660354553, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 1.1269856262714735, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 3.2617350208880813, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8838069232697292, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 3.2617350208880813, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 1.1377091691317782, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 3.1206517903681785, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2437426284156063, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 3.1206517903681785, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.5016893081651924, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 17.47437143893577, "se_normalized_difference": 9.595155916896957, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.29645344748321584, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 6.610602398528956, "se_normalized_difference": 2.950744984113429, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.509399649429192, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 17.572781963788863, "se_normalized_difference": 9.78211857540941, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.2990356557656308, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 6.534814451347721, "se_normalized_difference": 2.901277376670988, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 2.040336149216232, "se_normalized_difference": -0.518468599822108, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 2.040336149216232, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.6623792054333075, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7765223220768968, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.6623792054333075, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 3.180235565397664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3335264216120284, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 3.180235565397664, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": -0.863237973172137, "se_normalized_difference": -2.724932774871158, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": -0.863237973172137, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 2.043402900434037, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8607220531181528, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 2.043402900434037, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.8537365593815207, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18350143528337068, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.8537365593815207, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.1233912344904784, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1858423987182656, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.1233912344904784, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": 0.10048727997511618, "se_normalized_difference": 0.513612273913077, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": 0.10048727997511618, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": 0.07344059764605994, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8866491002064025, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": 0.07344059764605994, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": -2.073528247886675, "se_normalized_difference": -2.848056803502055, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": -2.073528247886675, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 2.289590028538141, "se_normalized_difference": 1.791955633737949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 2.289590028538141, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -1.1240709613629871, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6123691451246932, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -1.1240709613629871, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.5679708940851196, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -6.828636500163685, "se_normalized_difference": -4.773490476307728, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -7.008467277682474, "se_normalized_difference": -4.9205942919283645, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.48876568806058124, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -6.906414510242054, "se_normalized_difference": -5.6066546242752, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -5.000794409638612, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4753266702551544, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.5122122046192551, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -5.272435403164379, "se_normalized_difference": -3.0690475259371177, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P003", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5A-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.618170129730673, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.6799433693738065, "x": 0.9091494344594852, "y": -0.15343514541988482, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06258457987937, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.9091494344594852, "display_y": -0.15343514541988482, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P004", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5B-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19611887422714344, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.5415606686426057, "x": 0.3621364799602332, "y": -0.28407309311387524, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6462095730741084, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.3621364799602332, "display_y": -0.28407309311387524, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P012", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C1-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6123433590401681, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.586415027748376, "x": 1.0442149843794892, "y": -0.17790678072786714, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2221217651073564, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.0442149843794892, "display_y": -0.17790678072786714, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P013", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C3-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2555657596969807, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.48203992765186965, "x": 0.5301755000709213, "y": -0.3191495256410151, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8493250257119365, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.5301755000709213, "display_y": -0.3191495256410151, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.08458449736888857, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 3.665115129901997, "se_normalized_difference": 2.768557835068676, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 3.665115129901997, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.17986442248622828, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 8.302407471201867, "se_normalized_difference": 7.5080675508252375, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.19727869764236783, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 9.01213415244927, "se_normalized_difference": 7.976178500918021, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": 0.03214054573252869, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": 0.3772282970720262, "se_normalized_difference": 6.360928133496516, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": 0.3772282970720262, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#A95E00", "#F09556", "#332288", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Horizontal ridge estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "!datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P013", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2145722116583281, "modern": 0.1968348662935391, "twfe_se": 0.11377748070807477, "x": 1.8858935030286705, "y": 1.7299984589970778, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1558950440315926, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.8858935030286705, "display_y": 1.7299984589970778, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P014", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2319714901623524, "modern": 0.17785546630331156, "twfe_se": 0.13413628045075177, "x": 1.7293717209306465, "y": 1.3259311030963865, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4034406178342599, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7293717209306465, "display_y": 1.3259311030963865, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P015", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.38820146125710797, "modern": 0.243395282152075, "twfe_se": 0.12372858453606565, "x": 3.1375244670640448, "y": 1.9671709901532715, "se_normalized_difference": -1.1703534769107733, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.1375244670640448, "display_y": 1.9671709901532715, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P016", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18352232522747058, "modern": 0.18293828952869204, "twfe_se": 0.10583659840441823, "x": 1.7340157185154708, "y": 1.7284974412126906, "se_normalized_difference": -0.0055182773027800235, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7340157185154708, "display_y": 1.7284974412126906, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P017", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3073758706064841, "modern": 0.26435757556001244, "twfe_se": 0.0955445266648996, "x": 3.2170955400149093, "y": 2.7668521137499136, "se_normalized_difference": -0.45024342626499575, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.2170955400149093, "display_y": 2.7668521137499136, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P018", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.18707839792149378, "modern": 0.2248104909471848, "twfe_se": 0.15756426728594378, "x": 1.1873148724893854, "y": 1.4267860017982645, "se_normalized_difference": 0.23947112930887907, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1873148724893854, "display_y": 1.4267860017982645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P019", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3414339401929659, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.13905431377387112, "x": 2.455399842885872, "y": 2.0812444473529625, "se_normalized_difference": -0.37415539553290944, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.455399842885872, "display_y": 2.0812444473529625, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P020", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-A08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023184407426537507, "modern": 0.038865603647443965, "twfe_se": 0.13367108565586608, "x": 0.1734436981100413, "y": 0.2907555022594998, "se_normalized_difference": 0.11731180414945853, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.1734436981100413, "display_y": 0.2907555022594998, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P021", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03480352404481226, "modern": 0.26893664935478195, "twfe_se": 0.0926559787142215, "x": 0.3756209208275339, "y": 2.9025288285417856, "se_normalized_difference": 2.5269079077142518, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3756209208275339, "display_y": 2.9025288285417856, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P022", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16009312169879325, "modern": 0.24904205383548816, "twfe_se": 0.11331471184714757, "x": 1.4128185042269357, "y": 2.197790999737314, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7849724955103787, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4128185042269357, "display_y": 2.197790999737314, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P023", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07176181127411996, "modern": 0.19493219977497012, "twfe_se": 0.08578517243408915, "x": 0.8365293119770356, "y": 2.2723297540112926, "se_normalized_difference": 1.435800442034257, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8365293119770356, "display_y": 2.2723297540112926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P024", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15795381156581198, "modern": -0.09503625508582456, "twfe_se": 0.09415794986269062, "x": 1.6775408958686344, "y": -1.0093279985855126, "se_normalized_difference": -2.686868894454147, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.6775408958686344, "display_y": -1.0093279985855126, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P025", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16268422583873243, "modern": 0.12510323852077276, "twfe_se": 0.1331418418563034, "x": 1.2218865502425102, "y": 0.939623763473195, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2822627867693153, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2218865502425102, "display_y": 0.939623763473195, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P026", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.060192805512769086, "modern": 0.17541292024781988, "twfe_se": 0.09115773136021482, "x": 0.6603148697822885, "y": 1.9242791327777347, "se_normalized_difference": 1.263964262995446, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6603148697822885, "display_y": 1.9242791327777347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P027", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B07-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03963050196059358, "modern": 0.011904223595905723, "twfe_se": 0.1011769609957387, "x": 0.3916949231383093, "y": 0.11765745362135453, "se_normalized_difference": -0.27403746951695473, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.3916949231383093, "display_y": 0.11765745362135453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P028", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B08-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.07325613223091536, "modern": 0.18416629535735, "twfe_se": 0.11099334606770156, "x": 0.6600047194381545, "y": 1.6592552786454047, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9992505592072503, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.6600047194381545, "display_y": 1.6592552786454047, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P029", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B09-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12759187653047674, "modern": 0.15320044972034627, "twfe_se": 0.09968996583014077, "x": 1.2798868518811346, "y": 1.5367690062345962, "se_normalized_difference": 0.25688215435346157, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2798868518811346, "display_y": 1.5367690062345962, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P030", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B10-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.00696300399066093, "modern": -0.07491350340050888, "twfe_se": 0.10141420734182618, "x": 0.06865905846102476, "y": -0.7386884477438731, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8073475062048978, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.06865905846102476, "display_y": -0.7386884477438731, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P031", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-B11-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1590401968258393, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.11188359122405678, "x": 1.421479191773057, "y": 2.13647968337318, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7150004916001228, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.421479191773057, "display_y": 2.13647968337318, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P032", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14318886371089287, "modern": 0.2543347813592091, "twfe_se": 0.09232738613637427, "x": 1.5508818098607546, "y": 2.7547057487746716, "se_normalized_difference": 1.203823938913917, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.5508818098607546, "display_y": 2.7547057487746716, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P033", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.11777012359857324, "modern": 0.24243269336868634, "twfe_se": 0.09034156779109655, "x": 1.3036094732261208, "y": 2.6835121339634185, "se_normalized_difference": 1.379902660737298, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3036094732261208, "display_y": 2.6835121339634185, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P034", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-C03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375680744740297, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09074245279203282, "x": 1.694430806270897, "y": 3.485914549165386, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7914837428944888, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.694430806270897, "display_y": 3.485914549165386, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P035", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4303930642951357, "modern": 0.03676325497054096, "twfe_se": 0.11086309799544955, "x": 3.8822031142662228, "y": 0.3316094862516826, "se_normalized_difference": -3.5505936280145405, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 3.8822031142662228, "display_y": 0.3316094862516826, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P036", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04061398910953183, "modern": -0.0882545304980701, "twfe_se": 0.10498415519322277, "x": 0.38685827432513037, "y": -0.840646194043645, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2275044683687755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.38685827432513037, "display_y": -0.840646194043645, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P037", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12913524077848546, "modern": -0.041204530195972575, "twfe_se": 0.12448171915825734, "x": 1.0373831728200342, "y": -0.3310086852478959, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3683918580679302, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0373831728200342, "display_y": -0.3310086852478959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P038", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1550319334264455, "modern": -0.12366149904646326, "twfe_se": 0.14745843572711265, "x": 1.0513602199968295, "y": -0.8386193603417296, "se_normalized_difference": -1.8899795803385593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0513602199968295, "display_y": -0.8386193603417296, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P039", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2581180602436974, "modern": 0.015100183162598263, "twfe_se": 0.1135983147543355, "x": 2.2721997311482673, "y": 0.13292611950497232, "se_normalized_difference": -2.139273611643295, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2721997311482673, "display_y": 0.13292611950497232, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P040", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-D06-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2958180726771467, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.13533419075133454, "x": 2.1858339790917145, "y": -1.013139273761133, "se_normalized_difference": -3.1989732528528476, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.1858339790917145, "display_y": -1.013139273761133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P041", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-E01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13635414951625008, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.10678203594299218, "x": 1.2769390311029993, "y": 3.177573374734264, "se_normalized_difference": 1.9006343436312647, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2769390311029993, "display_y": 3.177573374734264, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P042", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-F01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15375133442040897, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.13497323289386004, "x": 1.1391246332620306, "y": 1.0237936083438006, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1153310249182301, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1391246332620306, "display_y": 1.0237936083438006, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P043", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.002290460649374832, "modern": -0.0008392377342642223, "twfe_se": 0.06529406994948063, "x": -0.03507915268793948, "y": -0.012853199914074246, "se_normalized_difference": 0.022225952773865233, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.03507915268793948, "display_y": -0.012853199914074246, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P044", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16714118085775276, "modern": 0.2061109075755187, "twfe_se": 0.15613347769961938, "x": 1.0705018764733516, "y": 1.320094259170025, "se_normalized_difference": 0.2495923826966735, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0705018764733516, "display_y": 1.320094259170025, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P045", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04461823226499024, "modern": 0.006752672573333551, "twfe_se": 0.10587438296018437, "x": -0.42142613744223273, "y": 0.06378004182440425, "se_normalized_difference": 0.48520617926663695, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.42142613744223273, "display_y": 0.06378004182440425, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P046", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.13270717977648508, "modern": 0.1297680978023072, "twfe_se": 0.10277932917893479, "x": 1.2911855023440275, "y": 1.2625894607308248, "se_normalized_difference": -0.028596041613202793, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.2911855023440275, "display_y": 1.2625894607308248, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P047", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-G05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09713268965189745, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11416423157910575, "x": 0.8508154288639261, "y": 1.148126476953765, "se_normalized_difference": 0.29731104808983877, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8508154288639261, "display_y": 1.148126476953765, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P048", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-H01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12068036700026637, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.13918968642388724, "x": 0.8670208986084448, "y": 0.1652549704216297, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7017659281868152, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8670208986084448, "display_y": 0.1652549704216297, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P049", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.13545348051334632, "modern": -0.00020165925944563013, "twfe_se": 0.11856477827814435, "x": -1.1424428272921179, "y": -0.0017008361367872014, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1407419911553307, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -1.1424428272921179, "display_y": -0.0017008361367872014, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P050", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01495030618995545, "modern": -0.061906057913820096, "twfe_se": 0.12839768549471237, "x": -0.11643750533627127, "y": -0.4821430984156602, "se_normalized_difference": -0.365705593079389, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.11643750533627127, "display_y": -0.4821430984156602, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P051", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.016524825876976464, "modern": 0.10918049363117435, "twfe_se": 0.13076992569701865, "x": -0.12636564400336892, "y": 0.834905220364926, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9612708643682949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.12636564400336892, "display_y": 0.834905220364926, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P052", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-I04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.10383844587036897, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.14398166080331445, "x": -0.721192166356638, "y": 0.10814893073221972, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8293410970888576, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.721192166356638, "display_y": 0.10814893073221972, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P053", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.05919461850781727, "modern": -0.42984742704281254, "twfe_se": 0.10853031917929314, "x": -0.5454201089193075, "y": -3.96062068455452, "se_normalized_difference": -3.4152005756352124, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5454201089193075, "display_y": -3.96062068455452, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P054", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.018671890265089666, "modern": 0.0365599630880471, "twfe_se": 0.1308850475082754, "x": -0.14265869647110843, "y": 0.27932879869822824, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4219874951693367, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.14265869647110843, "display_y": 0.27932879869822824, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P055", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1009494430875839, "modern": -0.24818129472721326, "twfe_se": 0.1070970252026278, "x": 0.94259801237791, "y": -2.3173500315032443, "se_normalized_difference": -3.259948043881154, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.94259801237791, "display_y": -2.3173500315032443, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P056", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J04-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1864474803468351, "modern": 0.08676428031392841, "twfe_se": 0.09699324470656424, "x": 1.9222728439583465, "y": 0.8945394143315677, "se_normalized_difference": -1.0277334296267788, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.9222728439583465, "display_y": 0.8945394143315677, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P057", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-J05-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10958618325549639, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.09784091427203638, "x": 1.1200445546819353, "y": -2.493987834174835, "se_normalized_difference": -3.6140323888567703, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.1200445546819353, "display_y": -2.493987834174835, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P058", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1185261031190653, "modern": 0.2950304764830441, "twfe_se": 0.1482912291566459, "x": 0.7992792547013114, "y": 1.9895342304526435, "se_normalized_difference": 1.190254975751332, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7992792547013114, "display_y": 1.9895342304526435, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P059", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K02-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14507728941205536, "modern": 0.20760114513306543, "twfe_se": 0.1360591792507996, "x": 1.066280792012074, "y": 1.5258150627999278, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4595342707878537, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.066280792012074, "display_y": 1.5258150627999278, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P060", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-K03-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16979332256640287, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.14308541375764514, "x": 1.186657102966449, "y": 2.440861113769037, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2542040108025876, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.186657102966449, "display_y": 2.440861113769037, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P061", "source_specification_id": "CI-T3-L01-ORIG", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.023075762589221598, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09223370682328534, "x": 0.2501879560520481, "y": -1.1327327005736298, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3829206566256778, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.2501879560520481, "display_y": -1.1327327005736298, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P074", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.4105352415894667, "modern": 0.3138535072417889, "twfe_se": 0.14104040249783997, "x": 2.9107634005493854, "y": 2.225273763286343, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6854896372630422, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.9107634005493854, "display_y": 2.225273763286343, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P075", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.32189403893089286, "modern": 0.28697117011338297, "twfe_se": 0.14366237884102623, "x": 2.2406286289265336, "y": 1.997538760171438, "se_normalized_difference": -0.2430898687550956, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2406286289265336, "display_y": 1.997538760171438, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P076", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23709369878871236, "modern": 0.32461135081791587, "twfe_se": 0.09734179090682957, "x": 2.4356825221722698, "y": 3.3347583580891453, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8990758359168755, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.4356825221722698, "display_y": 3.3347583580891453, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P077", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.23582791435780864, "modern": -0.10559724490425232, "twfe_se": 0.15115025994902712, "x": 1.560221692224265, "y": -0.6986243023324156, "se_normalized_difference": -2.2588459945566806, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.560221692224265, "display_y": -0.6986243023324156, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P078", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.264675995173418, "modern": 0.40599369834699806, "twfe_se": 0.11777799410823679, "x": 2.2472448879557536, "y": 3.447109975178334, "se_normalized_difference": 1.19986508722258, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.2472448879557536, "display_y": 3.447109975178334, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P079", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.022752399509013088, "modern": 0.01424846941699318, "twfe_se": 0.17966124563021166, "x": 0.12664055305418115, "y": 0.0793074175068347, "se_normalized_difference": -0.047333135547346424, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.12664055305418115, "display_y": 0.0793074175068347, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P080", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C07", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16001101263152434, "modern": 0.13234577061775446, "twfe_se": 0.1601630442793191, "x": 0.9990507694925577, "y": 0.8263190251737959, "se_normalized_difference": -0.17273174431876187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9990507694925577, "display_y": 0.8263190251737959, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P081", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C08", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16805116826903127, "modern": 0.04276786947607457, "twfe_se": 0.17673419997090717, "x": 0.9508695447553148, "y": 0.2419897760768133, "se_normalized_difference": -0.7088797686785014, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.9508695447553148, "display_y": 0.2419897760768133, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P082", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C09", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.130558664046681, "modern": 0.006508146520436092, "twfe_se": 0.20311776580766325, "x": -0.6427732381140403, "y": 0.032041247079287, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6748144851933274, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6427732381140403, "display_y": 0.032041247079287, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P083", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C10", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.062069807401543796, "modern": -0.24271857095084506, "twfe_se": 0.15104534107878517, "x": 0.41093493488930727, "y": -1.6069252399135117, "se_normalized_difference": -2.017860174802819, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.41093493488930727, "display_y": -1.6069252399135117, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P084", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C11", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.17009000522215836, "modern": 0.3105276124651162, "twfe_se": 0.1260422346708973, "x": 1.3494683402454108, "y": 2.4636790459635978, "se_normalized_difference": 1.114210705718187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3494683402454108, "display_y": 2.4636790459635978, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P085", "source_specification_id": "CI-T5-C-C12", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.03419750779060759, "modern": -0.15470509625418946, "twfe_se": 0.1478072255429635, "x": 0.23136560249327806, "y": -1.0466680210381254, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2780336235314036, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.23136560249327806, "display_y": -1.0466680210381254, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P098", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C01", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.8196301845967586, "modern": 1.8978248374106115, "twfe_se": 0.03539582112556906, "x": 51.40805119738564, "y": 53.617200479060784, "se_normalized_difference": 2.209149281675146, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P099", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C02", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.14574143289768993, "modern": 0.23132853017175992, "twfe_se": 0.10124343540344134, "x": 1.4395148911821305, "y": 2.2848743649397822, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8453594737576519, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.4395148911821305, "display_y": 2.2848743649397822, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P100", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C03", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.10757199107782624, "modern": 0.19202912435914468, "twfe_se": 0.13009574615657818, "x": 0.8268678589102888, "y": 1.476059979148172, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6491921202378833, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8268678589102888, "display_y": 1.476059979148172, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P101", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C04", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16676443748529515, "modern": 0.2642718623903228, "twfe_se": 0.09966002009300516, "x": 1.673333372095114, "y": 2.6517339866447736, "se_normalized_difference": 0.9784006145496593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.673333372095114, "display_y": 2.6517339866447736, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P102", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C05", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.0717590514756359, "modern": 0.11512328689103152, "twfe_se": 0.1069484716046265, "x": -0.6709684617178919, "y": 1.076436952896589, "se_normalized_difference": 1.7474054146144808, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.6709684617178919, "display_y": 1.076436952896589, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P103", "source_specification_id": "CI-T6-C06", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16694748969678513, "modern": 0.22053192079970058, "twfe_se": 0.12204862005314436, "x": 1.3678769135127475, "y": 1.8069185928007465, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4390416792879989, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.3678769135127475, "display_y": 1.8069185928007465, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P025", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22301288059949576, "modern": -0.1313298161590262, "twfe_se": 0.03722225579187916, "x": -5.991385418616967, "y": -3.5282605356679815, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4631248829489856, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -3.5282605356679815, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P026", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRDI-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2919596990939979, "modern": -0.12419501439442306, "twfe_se": 0.04187085721399433, "x": -6.9728617592385325, "y": -2.966144537229915, "se_normalized_difference": 4.006717222008618, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -2.966144537229915, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P027", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SFULL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.16700983145710996, "modern": -0.019450122296723913, "twfe_se": 0.059445867835438024, "x": -2.8094439115505487, "y": -0.3271904844684415, "se_normalized_difference": 2.4822534270821075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.8094439115505487, "display_y": -0.3271904844684415, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P028", "source_specification_id": "REXER-F4-THEFT-CTRLNONE-SHNONE-FENONE-TRNNPC-SONSHORE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1520287075388508, "modern": 0.010446299197532883, "twfe_se": 0.07086576936923028, "x": -2.1453052565723114, "y": 0.14740966323394827, "se_normalized_difference": 2.2927149198062593, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.1453052565723114, "display_y": 0.14740966323394827, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P049", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PB-SPILLS-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16257441691578423, "modern": -0.04549909291432021, "twfe_se": 0.0807703804464623, "x": 2.0127974638369417, "y": -0.5633140844802477, "se_normalized_difference": -2.576111548317189, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 2.0127974638369417, "display_y": -0.5633140844802477, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P053", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T1-PC-THEFT-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.26277336841551135, "modern": -0.17233390688743072, "twfe_se": 0.04284571205178576, "x": -6.13301438654838, "y": -4.022197289640984, "se_normalized_difference": 2.110817096907396, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -4.022197289640984, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P074", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.22165896865343812, "modern": 0.012524059045718378, "twfe_se": 0.07654121317975122, "x": -2.895942714324228, "y": 0.1636250397064726, "se_normalized_difference": 3.0595677540307005, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.895942714324228, "display_y": 0.1636250397064726, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P076", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2978769001470398, "modern": 0.6907772449565002, "twfe_se": 0.21721689900144311, "x": 1.3713339133207165, "y": 3.180126629797394, "se_normalized_difference": 1.8087927164766773, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.3713339133207165, "display_y": 3.180126629797394, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P078", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PA-SECURITY-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.3211435530070257, "modern": 0.09145604538612041, "twfe_se": 0.0687474968736264, "x": 4.671349032494389, "y": 1.330318186773222, "se_normalized_difference": -3.341030845721167, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 4.671349032494389, "display_y": 1.330318186773222, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P080", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C3-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.04701019018057746, "modern": -0.3069726812890671, "twfe_se": 0.40102675486499967, "x": 0.11722457319936876, "y": -0.7654668362274366, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8826914094268054, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 0.11722457319936876, "display_y": -0.7654668362274366, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P082", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C5-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1728203499337184, "modern": 0.07651686405673636, "twfe_se": 0.07000859519683533, "x": -2.468559031184939, "y": 1.0929638545324678, "se_normalized_difference": 3.5615228857174066, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": -2.468559031184939, "display_y": 1.0929638545324678, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 22, "study": "Corruption as a Local Advantage", "specification_id": "S22-P084", "source_specification_id": "REXER-T6-PB-OTHER-C7-HOLD", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.25749476125531173, "modern": -0.44158658600568346, "twfe_se": 0.24540962010345685, "x": 1.0492447734801926, "y": -1.7993858016630508, "se_normalized_difference": -2.8486305751432432, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 22 (2025)", "display_x": 1.0492447734801926, "display_y": -1.7993858016630508, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P004", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-BLACK", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.19143692107818552, "modern": -0.33645246730280537, "twfe_se": 0.052449930923148536, "x": -3.6498984404514387, "y": -6.414736137513455, "se_normalized_difference": -2.7648376970620165, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.6498984404514387, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P008", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-POOL", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.2692212791368487, "modern": -0.49148914659139925, "twfe_se": 0.0830831454291092, "x": -3.2403838076467877, "y": -5.915629987922917, "se_normalized_difference": -2.6752461802761296, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -3.2403838076467877, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P009", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-WHITE", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17379445267896745, "modern": -0.5543978488968974, "twfe_se": 0.09001695609942455, "x": -1.9306857308861889, "y": -6.158815771159379, "se_normalized_difference": -4.22813004027319, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.9306857308861889, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P001", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0006672834198579496, "modern": 0.22284049443955675, "twfe_se": 0.019252954127550535, "x": 0.0346587549857132, "y": 11.574353367449056, "se_normalized_difference": 11.539694612463343, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": 0.0346587549857132, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P002", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25794448866198855, "modern": -0.8490747523821184, "twfe_se": 0.09559771375971139, "x": -2.698228634529296, "y": -8.881747470617354, "se_normalized_difference": -6.183518836088058, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.698228634529296, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P003", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.01403176767730052, "modern": 0.09971958372515587, "twfe_se": 0.08602317230301686, "x": -0.1631161383804073, "y": 1.159217697458231, "se_normalized_difference": 1.3223338358386383, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.1631161383804073, "display_y": 1.159217697458231, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P004", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.25882906428816876, "modern": -0.8360059014650376, "twfe_se": 0.0977046633921527, "x": -2.649096320503337, "y": -8.55645853985085, "se_normalized_difference": -5.907362219347513, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -2.649096320503337, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P005", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.07256228911341406, "modern": -0.4765194429899556, "twfe_se": 0.03840453187826888, "x": -1.8894199607331568, "y": -12.407896143621349, "se_normalized_difference": -10.518476182888191, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.8894199607331568, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P006", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C6", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.004475706289962468, "modern": -0.16329526072171513, "twfe_se": 0.03682200982655465, "x": -0.12154975545997376, "y": -4.434718840467875, "se_normalized_difference": -4.313169085007901, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -0.12154975545997376, "display_y": -4.434718840467875, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 4, "study": "Market Integration Demand and the Growth of Firms", "specification_id": "S04-P007", "source_specification_id": "MI-T4-C7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.06455964969455705, "modern": -0.4410821552360305, "twfe_se": 0.03626307744889288, "x": -1.7803135926768419, "y": -12.163395560061515, "se_normalized_difference": -10.383081967384674, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 4 (2018)", "display_x": -1.7803135926768419, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P001", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C1-ALL-OPERAS-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 1.103259232171212, "modern": 1.0793747343927345, "twfe_se": 0.621297856876815, "x": 1.7757332010078954, "y": 1.7372902907127563, "se_normalized_difference": -0.03844291029513909, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.7757332010078954, "display_y": 1.7372902907127563, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P002", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C3-HISTORICALLY-POPULAR-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.5072440992085515, "modern": 0.8303807628780522, "twfe_se": 0.3186336162757492, "x": 1.59193529275824, "y": 2.606067660354553, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0141323675963132, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.59193529275824, "display_y": 2.606067660354553, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P003", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C4-METROPOLITAN-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.8216151125584968, "modern": 1.1269856262714735, "twfe_se": 0.3455172229056872, "x": 2.377928097618352, "y": 3.2617350208880813, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8838069232697292, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 2.377928097618352, "display_y": 3.2617350208880813, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 8, "study": "Copyrights and Creativity", "specification_id": "S08-P004", "source_specification_id": "C95FF064-T6-C5-AMAZON-DURABLE-OLS", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6842726797560931, "modern": 1.1377091691317782, "twfe_se": 0.3645742125549835, "x": 1.8769091619525724, "y": 3.1206517903681785, "se_normalized_difference": 1.2437426284156063, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": 71, "paper": "Study 8 (2020)", "display_x": 1.8769091619525724, "display_y": 3.1206517903681785, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P001", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22621232460060603, "modern": 0.5016893081651924, "twfe_se": 0.028710005960348665, "x": 7.8792155220388125, "y": 17.47437143893577, "se_normalized_difference": 9.595155916896957, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P002", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PA-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.1641268499285223, "modern": 0.29645344748321584, "twfe_se": 0.044845148688595314, "x": 3.659857414415527, "y": 6.610602398528956, "se_normalized_difference": 2.950744984113429, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.659857414415527, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P003", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.22583568196766463, "modern": 0.509399649429192, "twfe_se": 0.028987991228644396, "x": 7.790663388379453, "y": 17.572781963788863, "se_normalized_difference": 9.78211857540941, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 14, "study": "Reconciliation Narratives", "specification_id": "S14-P004", "source_specification_id": "BON-T4-PB-C4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.16627207244585196, "modern": 0.2990356557656308, "twfe_se": 0.045760389677775556, "x": 3.633537074676733, "y": 6.534814451347721, "se_normalized_difference": 2.901277376670988, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 14 (2023)", "display_x": 3.633537074676733, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P001", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-A-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.36294680885002306, "modern": 0.28940601842234587, "twfe_se": 0.1418423226650752, "x": 2.55880474903834, "y": 2.040336149216232, "se_normalized_difference": -0.518468599822108, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 2.55880474903834, "display_y": 2.040336149216232, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P002", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-B-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.12737923360443842, "modern": 0.23903701955302709, "twfe_se": 0.1437921135994485, "x": 0.8858568833564109, "y": 1.6623792054333075, "se_normalized_difference": 0.7765223220768968, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8858568833564109, "display_y": 1.6623792054333075, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P003", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-C-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.08421747394838008, "modern": 0.31632043641470037, "twfe_se": 0.09946446730437307, "x": 0.8467091437856358, "y": 3.180235565397664, "se_normalized_difference": 2.3335264216120284, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.8467091437856358, "display_y": 3.180235565397664, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P004", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-D-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.29570225126452043, "modern": -0.13711238373285772, "twfe_se": 0.15883497713731407, "x": 1.861694801699021, "y": -0.863237973172137, "se_normalized_difference": -2.724932774871158, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.861694801699021, "display_y": -0.863237973172137, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P005", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-E-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19638456140282684, "modern": 0.33930775431236915, "twfe_se": 0.16605034388484874, "x": 1.182680847315884, "y": 2.043402900434037, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8607220531181528, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.182680847315884, "display_y": 2.043402900434037, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P006", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-F-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.167886046245096, "modern": 0.13818473313423313, "twfe_se": 0.16185875094108587, "x": 1.0372379946648913, "y": 0.8537365593815207, "se_normalized_difference": -0.18350143528337068, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.0372379946648913, "display_y": 0.8537365593815207, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P007", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-G-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.15275868556552996, "modern": 0.13107497699705245, "twfe_se": 0.11667794172926976, "x": 1.309233633208744, "y": 1.1233912344904784, "se_normalized_difference": -0.1858423987182656, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 1.309233633208744, "display_y": 1.1233912344904784, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P008", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-H-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09456533532615642, "modern": 0.0230017875129754, "twfe_se": 0.2289024791861355, "x": -0.4131249939379608, "y": 0.10048727997511618, "se_normalized_difference": 0.513612273913077, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.4131249939379608, "display_y": 0.10048727997511618, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P009", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-I-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.17242296820887307, "modern": 0.01557146266092761, "twfe_se": 0.21202799486971516, "x": -0.8132085025603426, "y": 0.07344059764605994, "se_normalized_difference": 0.8866491002064025, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.8132085025603426, "display_y": 0.07344059764605994, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P010", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-J-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.09114698572120529, "modern": -0.24401404987900172, "twfe_se": 0.11768060074787942, "x": 0.7745285556153803, "y": -2.073528247886675, "se_normalized_difference": -2.848056803502055, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.7745285556153803, "display_y": -2.073528247886675, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P011", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-K-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0759086201346267, "modern": 0.34925162238858914, "twfe_se": 0.15253893406042632, "x": 0.49763439480019234, "y": 2.289590028538141, "se_normalized_difference": 1.791955633737949, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": 0.49763439480019234, "display_y": 2.289590028538141, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1, "study": "Curriculum and Ideology", "specification_id": "S01-P012", "source_specification_id": "CI-F4-L-DYNAMIC", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.04755983410930353, "modern": -0.10447613581385642, "twfe_se": 0.09294443091668729, "x": -0.5117018162382939, "y": -1.1240709613629871, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6123691451246932, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 1 (2017)", "display_x": -0.5117018162382939, "display_y": -1.1240709613629871, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P001", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-BLACK", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.1709364855805352, "modern": -0.5679708940851196, "twfe_se": 0.08317486134625926, "x": -2.0551460238559565, "y": -6.828636500163685, "se_normalized_difference": -4.773490476307728, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.0551460238559565, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P002", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.14510364668274423, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.06949831128273105, "x": -2.08787298575411, "y": -7.008467277682474, "se_normalized_difference": -4.9205942919283645, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.08787298575411, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P003", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F4-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.09198376871762172, "modern": -0.48876568806058124, "twfe_se": 0.07076981657207991, "x": -1.2997598859668535, "y": -6.906414510242054, "se_normalized_difference": -5.6066546242752, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -1.2997598859668535, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P006", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-POOL", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.24598018662127266, "modern": -0.4870766404792113, "twfe_se": 0.09739985301943466, "x": -2.5254677393834575, "y": -5.000794409638612, "se_normalized_difference": -2.4753266702551544, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.5254677393834575, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 16, "study": "The Gift of a Lifetime", "specification_id": "S16-P007", "source_specification_id": "GIFT-F5A-LOGIMR-CSA-WHITE", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.21405708670201215, "modern": -0.5122122046192551, "twfe_se": 0.09714907162482041, "x": -2.203387877227261, "y": -5.272435403164379, "se_normalized_difference": -3.0690475259371177, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 16 (2024)", "display_x": -2.203387877227261, "display_y": -5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P003", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5A-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.618170129730673, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.6799433693738065, "x": 0.9091494344594852, "y": -0.15343514541988482, "se_normalized_difference": -1.06258457987937, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.9091494344594852, "display_y": -0.15343514541988482, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P004", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-F5B-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.19611887422714344, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.5415606686426057, "x": 0.3621364799602332, "y": -0.28407309311387524, "se_normalized_difference": -0.6462095730741084, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.3621364799602332, "display_y": -0.28407309311387524, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P012", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C1-MARRIAGE-RULERS", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.6123433590401681, "modern": -0.10432720975715645, "twfe_se": 0.586415027748376, "x": 1.0442149843794892, "y": -0.17790678072786714, "se_normalized_difference": -1.2221217651073564, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 1.0442149843794892, "display_y": -0.17790678072786714, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 18, "study": "The Rise of Fiscal Capacity", "specification_id": "S18-P013", "source_specification_id": "FISCAL-T8-C3-MARRIAGE-LAND", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.2555657596969807, "modern": -0.15384281425012344, "twfe_se": 0.48203992765186965, "x": 0.5301755000709213, "y": -0.3191495256410151, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8493250257119365, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated observations, using configured observation weights; cell mass equals sum of row weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 18 (2024)", "display_x": 0.5301755000709213, "display_y": -0.3191495256410151, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P001", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C1-CRACKDOWN", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.020690986628819668, "modern": 0.08458449736888857, "twfe_se": 0.023078264766856125, "x": 0.8965572948333209, "y": 3.665115129901997, "se_normalized_difference": 2.768557835068676, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.8965572948333209, "display_y": 3.665115129901997, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P002", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C3-CONVICTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.017208682124055824, "modern": 0.17986442248622828, "twfe_se": 0.021664128520566442, "x": 0.7943399203766299, "y": 8.302407471201867, "se_normalized_difference": 7.5080675508252375, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 0.7943399203766299, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 5, "study": "Do Government Audits Reduce Corruption?", "specification_id": "S05-P003", "source_specification_id": "AUDITS-T4-C5-LEGAL-ACTION", "specification_type": "scalar", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": 0.0226774233818737, "modern": 0.19727869764236783, "twfe_se": 0.02189034187742894, "x": 1.03595565153125, "y": 9.01213415244927, "se_normalized_difference": 7.976178500918021, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 5 (2018)", "display_x": 1.03595565153125, "display_y": 5, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 20, "study": "Credit Markets Property Rights and the Commons", "specification_id": "S20-P001", "source_specification_id": "CMPRC-CSA-NOTYET", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "twfe": -0.5098222475224472, "modern": 0.03214054573252869, "twfe_se": 0.0852018419137627, "x": -5.98369983642449, "y": 0.3772282970720262, "se_normalized_difference": 6.360928133496516, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "All observed treated unit-years, equal cell weights", "donor_rule": "Units untreated throughout retained analysis window", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "paper": "Study 20 (2024)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": 0.3772282970720262, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "range": [ "#8A61A8", "#0072B2", "#264653", "#A95E00", "#F09556", "#332288", "#C49A00", "#7F8FAD", "#525252" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1 (2017)", "Study 4 (2018)", "Study 5 (2018)", "Study 8 (2020)", "Study 14 (2023)", "Study 16 (2024)", "Study 18 (2024)", "Study 20 (2024)", "Study 22 (2025)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "Horizontal ridge (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "Horizontal ridge estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.event" } ] } ], "height": 720, "title": { "text": "Horizontal ridge vs TWFE", "anchor": "start", "fontSize": 21, "offset": 18, "subtitle": "122 comparisons; 24 capped (diamonds)", "subtitleColor": "#5A6873", "subtitleFontSize": 12, "subtitlePadding": 8 }, "usermeta": { "estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "comparisons": 122, "capped": 24, "homogeneity_rings": 0, "view": "capped" }, "width": 720, "$schema": "https://vega.github.io/schema/vega-lite/v6.4.1.json" }