{ "config": { "view": { "continuousWidth": 300, "continuousHeight": 300, "stroke": null }, "axis": { "domainColor": "#A0ABB4", "gridColor": "#E5E9ED", "gridWidth": 0.6, "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "labelPadding": 5, "tickColor": "#A0ABB4", "titleColor": "#172B3A", "titleFontSize": 14, "titleFontWeight": "normal", "titlePadding": 12 }, "background": "white", "font": "DejaVu Sans", "legend": { "columnPadding": 18, "columns": 4, "direction": "horizontal", "labelColor": "#172B3A", "labelFontSize": 12, "offset": 24, "orient": "bottom", "rowPadding": 7, "symbolLimit": 1000, "symbolOpacity": 1, "symbolSize": 45, "symbolType": "circle" }, "title": { "color": "#172B3A" } }, "layer": [ { "data": { "values": [ { "start": -5, "end": 5 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#343E47", "strokeDash": [ 5, 4 ], "strokeWidth": 1.1 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "x2": { "field": "end" }, "y": { "field": "start", "type": "quantitative" }, "y2": { "field": "end" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "x": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "zero": 0 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "rule", "color": "#BEC6CD", "strokeWidth": 0.85 }, "encoding": { "y": { "field": "zero", "type": "quantitative" } } }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1007, "study": "Wall Street and the Housing Bubble", "specification_id": "aeraej-7-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 9", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.05687187080097784, "modern": 0.056871870800977754, "twfe_se": 0.2580789096493766, "x": 0.22036620845245894, "y": 0.22036620845245863, "se_normalized_difference": -3.2264057128888246e-16, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-7.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1007 (2014)", "display_x": 0.22036620845245894, "display_y": 0.22036620845245863, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1014, "study": "Taxation and International Migration of Superstars: Evidence from the European Football Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-14-source", "source_specification_id": "", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.568740492019418, "modern": 1.568740492019418, "twfe_se": 0.5579728793858483, "x": 2.8114995369418407, "y": 2.8114995369418407, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-14.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1014 (2013)", "display_x": 2.8114995369418407, "display_y": 2.8114995369418407, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 1019, "study": "Personal Retirement Accounts and Saving", "specification_id": "aeraej-19-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.012907939894475312, "modern": -0.05308780503718426, "twfe_se": 0.048003334187359956, "x": 0.26889673629950017, "y": -1.1059191186591186, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3748158549586187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-19.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1019 (2011)", "display_x": 0.26889673629950017, "display_y": -1.1059191186591186, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 1033, "study": "The Impact of Insurance Provision on Household Production and Financial Decisions", "specification_id": "aeraej-33-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.24736809130756257, "modern": 0.248531965233285, "twfe_se": 0.11628682387828693, "x": 2.127223730579085, "y": 2.1372323789100482, "se_normalized_difference": 0.010008648330963175, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-33.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1033 (2016)", "display_x": 2.127223730579085, "display_y": 2.1372323789100482, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 1034, "study": "Stimulating the Vote: ARRA Road Spending and Vote Share", "specification_id": "aeraej-34-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.12056325250123143, "modern": 0.13054189136193847, "twfe_se": 0.026638808446842233, "x": 4.525850048504065, "y": 4.900440333974958, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3745902854708921, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-34.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1034 (2019)", "display_x": 4.525850048504065, "display_y": 4.900440333974958, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 1036, "study": "The Labor Market Impacts of Universal and Permanent Cash Transfers: Evidence from the Alaska Permanent Fund", "specification_id": "aeraej-36-source", "source_specification_id": "Appendix Table app_table_simpleDD (Washington Control)", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.2674369032186994, "modern": -0.267436903218699, "twfe_se": 0.3265150078348829, "x": -0.81906465798332, "y": -0.8190646579833187, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1900771765299893e-15, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-36.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1036 (2022)", "display_x": -0.81906465798332, "display_y": -0.8190646579833187, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 1038, "study": "Coase and Cap-and-Trade: Evidence on the Independence Property from the European Carbon Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-38-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.041491755509451236, "modern": -0.02316527750360032, "twfe_se": 0.01760182644663777, "x": -2.3572414848674312, "y": -1.3160723731613237, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0411691117061075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-38.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1038 (2023)", "display_x": -2.3572414848674312, "display_y": -1.3160723731613237, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1039, "study": "When Does Product Liability Risk Chill Innovation? Evidence from Medical Implants", "specification_id": "aeraej-39-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.15936653530656933, "modern": -0.14723540278724181, "twfe_se": 0.026381687456431914, "x": -6.040801429770385, "y": -5.580969868981808, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4598315607885771, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-39.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1039 (2022)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 1056, "study": "Compulsory Licensing: Evidence from the Trading with the Enemy Act", "specification_id": "aeraej-56-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.15082404398358323, "modern": 1.3101999385394447, "twfe_se": 0.03115715131754854, "x": 4.840752045859697, "y": 42.051339199341534, "se_normalized_difference": 37.21058715348184, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-56.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1056 (2012)", "display_x": 4.840752045859697, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 1057, "study": "Giving Mom a Break: The Impact of Higher EITC Payments on Maternal Health", "specification_id": "aeraej-57-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.051402414841530804, "modern": 0.04598549921583511, "twfe_se": 0.01761102903663903, "x": 2.918762710264697, "y": 2.6111761624016494, "se_normalized_difference": -0.30758654786304757, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-57.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1057 (2014)", "display_x": 2.918762710264697, "display_y": 2.6111761624016494, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 1059, "study": "Awarding Price, Contract Performance, and Bids Screening: Evidence from Procurement Auctions", "specification_id": "aeraej-59-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.659428803827662, "modern": 1.4026273320191576, "twfe_se": 0.20393946856699582, "x": 8.136869314644338, "y": 6.8776649359482995, "se_normalized_difference": -1.259204378696039, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-59.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1059 (2014)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 1078, "study": "Trickle-Down Ethnic Politics: Drunk and Absent in the Kenya Police Force (1957-1970)", "specification_id": "aeraej-78-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.06336897006790011, "modern": 0.021412390417728078, "twfe_se": 0.02155266816168833, "x": 2.940191422820853, "y": 0.9934913977746103, "se_normalized_difference": -1.946700025046243, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-78.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1078 (2018)", "display_x": 2.940191422820853, "display_y": 0.9934913977746103, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 1104, "study": "There Will Be Killing: Collectivization and Death of Draft Animals", "specification_id": "aeraej-104-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.09746319625630824, "modern": -0.07965579079579135, "twfe_se": 0.007984263547983475, "x": -12.20691121611633, "y": -9.976598382190105, "se_normalized_difference": 2.230312833926226, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 5, "report": "aeraej-104.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1104 (2017)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 1113, "study": "The Economics of Nationalism", "specification_id": "aeraej-113-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -1.18567590759286, "modern": -1.3951531391651613, "twfe_se": 0.4994848314448515, "x": -2.3737976269731256, "y": -2.793184199667135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4193865726940094, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-113.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1113 (2015)", "display_x": -2.3737976269731256, "display_y": -2.793184199667135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 1120, "study": "The Power of Political Voice: Women's Political Representation and Crime in India", "specification_id": "aeraej-120-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3358685755485454, "modern": 0.20520120180815798, "twfe_se": 0.15072788192944972, "x": 2.228310855623602, "y": 1.3614017471844078, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8669091084391942, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 22, "report": "aeraej-120.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1120 (2012)", "display_x": 2.228310855623602, "display_y": 1.3614017471844078, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 1150, "study": "Rebel on the Canal: Disrupted Trade Access and Social Conflict in China, 1650-1911", "specification_id": "aeraej-150-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.09519882679194765, "modern": 0.03543163546874211, "twfe_se": 0.04244615164206323, "x": 2.2428140858265144, "y": 0.8347431768968689, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4080709089296455, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-150.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1150 (2022)", "display_x": 2.2428140858265144, "display_y": 0.8347431768968689, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 1159, "study": "Do College Graduates Serving as Village Officials Help Rural China?", "specification_id": "aeraej-159-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5, Panel A, Column 1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.22985211340622605, "modern": -0.07275800325736283, "twfe_se": 0.13089293284421888, "x": 1.7560315015615289, "y": -0.555858912138176, "se_normalized_difference": -2.311890413699705, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "he-wang-village-officials.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1159 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7560315015615289, "display_y": -0.555858912138176, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 1199, "study": "Buffalo Hunt: International Trade and the Virtual Extinction of the North American Bison", "specification_id": "aeraej-199-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3002498666631857, "modern": 0.2661344737521629, "twfe_se": 0.014542878684129101, "x": 20.64583451355155, "y": 18.29998582348075, "se_normalized_difference": -2.345848690070798, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-199.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1199 (2011)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 1224, "study": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "specification_id": "aeraej-224-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 6", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.34441345507851673, "modern": 0.4444749047255976, "twfe_se": 0.16621623874552902, "x": 2.0720806683984776, "y": 2.674076300126562, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6019956317280846, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-224.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1224 (2017)", "display_x": 2.0720806683984776, "display_y": 2.674076300126562, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 18 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": false, "shape": "diamond", "size": 120, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "range": [ "#703dad", "#ad3d44", "#3d63ad", "#adac3d", "#3d46ad", "#41ad3d", "#84ad3d", "#3dad95", "#ad3daa", "#3dad66", "#64ad3d", "#69ad3d", "#3dad85", "#92ad3d", "#ad463d", "#76ad3d", "#ad833d", "#573dad", "#3dada3" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "CS-DID: equal event time estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.capped && datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1007, "study": "Wall Street and the Housing Bubble", "specification_id": "aeraej-7-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 9", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.05687187080097784, "modern": 0.056871870800977754, "twfe_se": 0.2580789096493766, "x": 0.22036620845245894, "y": 0.22036620845245863, "se_normalized_difference": -3.2264057128888246e-16, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-7.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1007 (2014)", "display_x": 0.22036620845245894, "display_y": 0.22036620845245863, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1014, "study": "Taxation and International Migration of Superstars: Evidence from the European Football Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-14-source", "source_specification_id": "", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.568740492019418, "modern": 1.568740492019418, "twfe_se": 0.5579728793858483, "x": 2.8114995369418407, "y": 2.8114995369418407, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-14.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1014 (2013)", "display_x": 2.8114995369418407, "display_y": 2.8114995369418407, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 1019, "study": "Personal Retirement Accounts and Saving", "specification_id": "aeraej-19-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.012907939894475312, "modern": -0.05308780503718426, "twfe_se": 0.048003334187359956, "x": 0.26889673629950017, "y": -1.1059191186591186, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3748158549586187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-19.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1019 (2011)", "display_x": 0.26889673629950017, "display_y": -1.1059191186591186, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 1033, "study": "The Impact of Insurance Provision on Household Production and Financial Decisions", "specification_id": "aeraej-33-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.24736809130756257, "modern": 0.248531965233285, "twfe_se": 0.11628682387828693, "x": 2.127223730579085, "y": 2.1372323789100482, "se_normalized_difference": 0.010008648330963175, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-33.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1033 (2016)", "display_x": 2.127223730579085, "display_y": 2.1372323789100482, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 1034, "study": "Stimulating the Vote: ARRA Road Spending and Vote Share", "specification_id": "aeraej-34-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.12056325250123143, "modern": 0.13054189136193847, "twfe_se": 0.026638808446842233, "x": 4.525850048504065, "y": 4.900440333974958, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3745902854708921, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-34.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1034 (2019)", "display_x": 4.525850048504065, "display_y": 4.900440333974958, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 1036, "study": "The Labor Market Impacts of Universal and Permanent Cash Transfers: Evidence from the Alaska Permanent Fund", "specification_id": "aeraej-36-source", "source_specification_id": "Appendix Table app_table_simpleDD (Washington Control)", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.2674369032186994, "modern": -0.267436903218699, "twfe_se": 0.3265150078348829, "x": -0.81906465798332, "y": -0.8190646579833187, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1900771765299893e-15, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-36.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1036 (2022)", "display_x": -0.81906465798332, "display_y": -0.8190646579833187, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 1038, "study": "Coase and Cap-and-Trade: Evidence on the Independence Property from the European Carbon Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-38-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.041491755509451236, "modern": -0.02316527750360032, "twfe_se": 0.01760182644663777, "x": -2.3572414848674312, "y": -1.3160723731613237, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0411691117061075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-38.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1038 (2023)", "display_x": -2.3572414848674312, "display_y": -1.3160723731613237, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1039, "study": "When Does Product Liability Risk Chill Innovation? Evidence from Medical Implants", "specification_id": "aeraej-39-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.15936653530656933, "modern": -0.14723540278724181, "twfe_se": 0.026381687456431914, "x": -6.040801429770385, "y": -5.580969868981808, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4598315607885771, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-39.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1039 (2022)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 1056, "study": "Compulsory Licensing: Evidence from the Trading with the Enemy Act", "specification_id": "aeraej-56-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.15082404398358323, "modern": 1.3101999385394447, "twfe_se": 0.03115715131754854, "x": 4.840752045859697, "y": 42.051339199341534, "se_normalized_difference": 37.21058715348184, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-56.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1056 (2012)", "display_x": 4.840752045859697, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 1057, "study": "Giving Mom a Break: The Impact of Higher EITC Payments on Maternal Health", "specification_id": "aeraej-57-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.051402414841530804, "modern": 0.04598549921583511, "twfe_se": 0.01761102903663903, "x": 2.918762710264697, "y": 2.6111761624016494, "se_normalized_difference": -0.30758654786304757, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-57.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1057 (2014)", "display_x": 2.918762710264697, "display_y": 2.6111761624016494, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 1059, "study": "Awarding Price, Contract Performance, and Bids Screening: Evidence from Procurement Auctions", "specification_id": "aeraej-59-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.659428803827662, "modern": 1.4026273320191576, "twfe_se": 0.20393946856699582, "x": 8.136869314644338, "y": 6.8776649359482995, "se_normalized_difference": -1.259204378696039, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-59.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1059 (2014)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 1078, "study": "Trickle-Down Ethnic Politics: Drunk and Absent in the Kenya Police Force (1957-1970)", "specification_id": "aeraej-78-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.06336897006790011, "modern": 0.021412390417728078, "twfe_se": 0.02155266816168833, "x": 2.940191422820853, "y": 0.9934913977746103, "se_normalized_difference": -1.946700025046243, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-78.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1078 (2018)", "display_x": 2.940191422820853, "display_y": 0.9934913977746103, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 1104, "study": "There Will Be Killing: Collectivization and Death of Draft Animals", "specification_id": "aeraej-104-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.09746319625630824, "modern": -0.07965579079579135, "twfe_se": 0.007984263547983475, "x": -12.20691121611633, "y": -9.976598382190105, "se_normalized_difference": 2.230312833926226, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 5, "report": "aeraej-104.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1104 (2017)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 1113, "study": "The Economics of Nationalism", "specification_id": "aeraej-113-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -1.18567590759286, "modern": -1.3951531391651613, "twfe_se": 0.4994848314448515, "x": -2.3737976269731256, "y": -2.793184199667135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4193865726940094, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-113.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1113 (2015)", "display_x": -2.3737976269731256, "display_y": -2.793184199667135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 1120, "study": "The Power of Political Voice: Women's Political Representation and Crime in India", "specification_id": "aeraej-120-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3358685755485454, "modern": 0.20520120180815798, "twfe_se": 0.15072788192944972, "x": 2.228310855623602, "y": 1.3614017471844078, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8669091084391942, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 22, "report": "aeraej-120.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1120 (2012)", "display_x": 2.228310855623602, "display_y": 1.3614017471844078, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 1150, "study": "Rebel on the Canal: Disrupted Trade Access and Social Conflict in China, 1650-1911", "specification_id": "aeraej-150-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.09519882679194765, "modern": 0.03543163546874211, "twfe_se": 0.04244615164206323, "x": 2.2428140858265144, "y": 0.8347431768968689, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4080709089296455, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-150.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1150 (2022)", "display_x": 2.2428140858265144, "display_y": 0.8347431768968689, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 1159, "study": "Do College Graduates Serving as Village Officials Help Rural China?", "specification_id": "aeraej-159-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5, Panel A, Column 1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.22985211340622605, "modern": -0.07275800325736283, "twfe_se": 0.13089293284421888, "x": 1.7560315015615289, "y": -0.555858912138176, "se_normalized_difference": -2.311890413699705, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "he-wang-village-officials.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1159 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7560315015615289, "display_y": -0.555858912138176, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 1199, "study": "Buffalo Hunt: International Trade and the Virtual Extinction of the North American Bison", "specification_id": "aeraej-199-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3002498666631857, "modern": 0.2661344737521629, "twfe_se": 0.014542878684129101, "x": 20.64583451355155, "y": 18.29998582348075, "se_normalized_difference": -2.345848690070798, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-199.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1199 (2011)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 1224, "study": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "specification_id": "aeraej-224-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 6", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.34441345507851673, "modern": 0.4444749047255976, "twfe_se": 0.16621623874552902, "x": 2.0720806683984776, "y": 2.674076300126562, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6019956317280846, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-224.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1224 (2017)", "display_x": 2.0720806683984776, "display_y": 2.674076300126562, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 18 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "range": [ "#703dad", "#ad3d44", "#3d63ad", "#adac3d", "#3d46ad", "#41ad3d", "#84ad3d", "#3dad95", "#ad3daa", "#3dad66", "#64ad3d", "#69ad3d", "#3dad85", "#92ad3d", "#ad463d", "#76ad3d", "#ad833d", "#573dad", "#3dada3" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "CS-DID: equal event time estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "!datum.event" } ] }, { "data": { "values": [ { "study_id": 1007, "study": "Wall Street and the Housing Bubble", "specification_id": "aeraej-7-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 9", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.05687187080097784, "modern": 0.056871870800977754, "twfe_se": 0.2580789096493766, "x": 0.22036620845245894, "y": 0.22036620845245863, "se_normalized_difference": -3.2264057128888246e-16, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-7.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1007 (2014)", "display_x": 0.22036620845245894, "display_y": 0.22036620845245863, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 0 }, { "study_id": 1014, "study": "Taxation and International Migration of Superstars: Evidence from the European Football Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-14-source", "source_specification_id": "", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.568740492019418, "modern": 1.568740492019418, "twfe_se": 0.5579728793858483, "x": 2.8114995369418407, "y": 2.8114995369418407, "se_normalized_difference": 0.0, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-14.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1014 (2013)", "display_x": 2.8114995369418407, "display_y": 2.8114995369418407, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 1 }, { "study_id": 1019, "study": "Personal Retirement Accounts and Saving", "specification_id": "aeraej-19-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.012907939894475312, "modern": -0.05308780503718426, "twfe_se": 0.048003334187359956, "x": 0.26889673629950017, "y": -1.1059191186591186, "se_normalized_difference": -1.3748158549586187, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-19.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1019 (2011)", "display_x": 0.26889673629950017, "display_y": -1.1059191186591186, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 2 }, { "study_id": 1033, "study": "The Impact of Insurance Provision on Household Production and Financial Decisions", "specification_id": "aeraej-33-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 4", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.24736809130756257, "modern": 0.248531965233285, "twfe_se": 0.11628682387828693, "x": 2.127223730579085, "y": 2.1372323789100482, "se_normalized_difference": 0.010008648330963175, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-33.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1033 (2016)", "display_x": 2.127223730579085, "display_y": 2.1372323789100482, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 3 }, { "study_id": 1034, "study": "Stimulating the Vote: ARRA Road Spending and Vote Share", "specification_id": "aeraej-34-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.12056325250123143, "modern": 0.13054189136193847, "twfe_se": 0.026638808446842233, "x": 4.525850048504065, "y": 4.900440333974958, "se_normalized_difference": 0.3745902854708921, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-34.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1034 (2019)", "display_x": 4.525850048504065, "display_y": 4.900440333974958, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 4 }, { "study_id": 1036, "study": "The Labor Market Impacts of Universal and Permanent Cash Transfers: Evidence from the Alaska Permanent Fund", "specification_id": "aeraej-36-source", "source_specification_id": "Appendix Table app_table_simpleDD (Washington Control)", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.2674369032186994, "modern": -0.267436903218699, "twfe_se": 0.3265150078348829, "x": -0.81906465798332, "y": -0.8190646579833187, "se_normalized_difference": 1.1900771765299893e-15, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-36.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1036 (2022)", "display_x": -0.81906465798332, "display_y": -0.8190646579833187, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 5 }, { "study_id": 1038, "study": "Coase and Cap-and-Trade: Evidence on the Independence Property from the European Carbon Market", "specification_id": "aeraej-38-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.041491755509451236, "modern": -0.02316527750360032, "twfe_se": 0.01760182644663777, "x": -2.3572414848674312, "y": -1.3160723731613237, "se_normalized_difference": 1.0411691117061075, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-38.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1038 (2023)", "display_x": -2.3572414848674312, "display_y": -1.3160723731613237, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 6 }, { "study_id": 1039, "study": "When Does Product Liability Risk Chill Innovation? Evidence from Medical Implants", "specification_id": "aeraej-39-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.15936653530656933, "modern": -0.14723540278724181, "twfe_se": 0.026381687456431914, "x": -6.040801429770385, "y": -5.580969868981808, "se_normalized_difference": 0.4598315607885771, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-39.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1039 (2022)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 7 }, { "study_id": 1056, "study": "Compulsory Licensing: Evidence from the Trading with the Enemy Act", "specification_id": "aeraej-56-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.15082404398358323, "modern": 1.3101999385394447, "twfe_se": 0.03115715131754854, "x": 4.840752045859697, "y": 42.051339199341534, "se_normalized_difference": 37.21058715348184, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-56.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1056 (2012)", "display_x": 4.840752045859697, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 8 }, { "study_id": 1057, "study": "Giving Mom a Break: The Impact of Higher EITC Payments on Maternal Health", "specification_id": "aeraej-57-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.051402414841530804, "modern": 0.04598549921583511, "twfe_se": 0.01761102903663903, "x": 2.918762710264697, "y": 2.6111761624016494, "se_normalized_difference": -0.30758654786304757, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-57.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1057 (2014)", "display_x": 2.918762710264697, "display_y": 2.6111761624016494, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 9 }, { "study_id": 1059, "study": "Awarding Price, Contract Performance, and Bids Screening: Evidence from Procurement Auctions", "specification_id": "aeraej-59-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 1.659428803827662, "modern": 1.4026273320191576, "twfe_se": 0.20393946856699582, "x": 8.136869314644338, "y": 6.8776649359482995, "se_normalized_difference": -1.259204378696039, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-59.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1059 (2014)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 10 }, { "study_id": 1078, "study": "Trickle-Down Ethnic Politics: Drunk and Absent in the Kenya Police Force (1957-1970)", "specification_id": "aeraej-78-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.06336897006790011, "modern": 0.021412390417728078, "twfe_se": 0.02155266816168833, "x": 2.940191422820853, "y": 0.9934913977746103, "se_normalized_difference": -1.946700025046243, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-78.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1078 (2018)", "display_x": 2.940191422820853, "display_y": 0.9934913977746103, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 11 }, { "study_id": 1104, "study": "There Will Be Killing: Collectivization and Death of Draft Animals", "specification_id": "aeraej-104-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -0.09746319625630824, "modern": -0.07965579079579135, "twfe_se": 0.007984263547983475, "x": -12.20691121611633, "y": -9.976598382190105, "se_normalized_difference": 2.230312833926226, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 5, "report": "aeraej-104.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1104 (2017)", "display_x": -5, "display_y": -5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 12 }, { "study_id": 1113, "study": "The Economics of Nationalism", "specification_id": "aeraej-113-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 7", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": -1.18567590759286, "modern": -1.3951531391651613, "twfe_se": 0.4994848314448515, "x": -2.3737976269731256, "y": -2.793184199667135, "se_normalized_difference": -0.4193865726940094, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-113.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1113 (2015)", "display_x": -2.3737976269731256, "display_y": -2.793184199667135, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 13 }, { "study_id": 1120, "study": "The Power of Political Voice: Women's Political Representation and Crime in India", "specification_id": "aeraej-120-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3358685755485454, "modern": 0.20520120180815798, "twfe_se": 0.15072788192944972, "x": 2.228310855623602, "y": 1.3614017471844078, "se_normalized_difference": -0.8669091084391942, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": 22, "report": "aeraej-120.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1120 (2012)", "display_x": 2.228310855623602, "display_y": 1.3614017471844078, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 14 }, { "study_id": 1150, "study": "Rebel on the Canal: Disrupted Trade Access and Social Conflict in China, 1650-1911", "specification_id": "aeraej-150-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 3", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.09519882679194765, "modern": 0.03543163546874211, "twfe_se": 0.04244615164206323, "x": 2.2428140858265144, "y": 0.8347431768968689, "se_normalized_difference": -1.4080709089296455, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-150.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1150 (2022)", "display_x": 2.2428140858265144, "display_y": 0.8347431768968689, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 15 }, { "study_id": 1159, "study": "Do College Graduates Serving as Village Officials Help Rural China?", "specification_id": "aeraej-159-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 5, Panel A, Column 1", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.22985211340622605, "modern": -0.07275800325736283, "twfe_se": 0.13089293284421888, "x": 1.7560315015615289, "y": -0.555858912138176, "se_normalized_difference": -2.311890413699705, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "he-wang-village-officials.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1159 (2017)", "display_x": 1.7560315015615289, "display_y": -0.555858912138176, "marker": "circle", "event": false, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 16 }, { "study_id": 1199, "study": "Buffalo Hunt: International Trade and the Virtual Extinction of the North American Bison", "specification_id": "aeraej-199-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2", "specification_type": "twfe_scalar", "twfe_model": "Static TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.3002498666631857, "modern": 0.2661344737521629, "twfe_se": 0.014542878684129101, "x": 20.64583451355155, "y": 18.29998582348075, "se_normalized_difference": -2.345848690070798, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Dynamic aggregation: equal weights across all observed nonnegative event times; cohort-size weights within each event time", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-199.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1199 (2011)", "display_x": 5, "display_y": 5, "marker": "diamond", "event": false, "capped": true, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 17 }, { "study_id": 1224, "study": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "specification_id": "aeraej-224-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 6", "specification_type": "event_study_post_average", "twfe_model": "Dynamic TWFE", "modern_estimator": "CS-DID", "twfe": 0.34441345507851673, "modern": 0.4444749047255976, "twfe_se": 0.16621623874552902, "x": 2.0720806683984776, "y": 2.674076300126562, "se_normalized_difference": 0.6019956317280846, "homogeneity_pvalue": null, "homogeneity_reject_005": null, "aggregation": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "report": "aeraej-224.html", "collection": "New library", "paper": "Study 1224 (2017)", "display_x": 2.0720806683984776, "display_y": 2.674076300126562, "marker": "square", "event": true, "capped": false, "homogeneity_test": "Unavailable", "draw_order": 18 } ] }, "mark": { "type": "point", "filled": true, "opacity": 0.9, "strokeWidth": 0.8 }, "encoding": { "color": { "field": "paper", "scale": { "domain": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "range": [ "#703dad", "#ad3d44", "#3d63ad", "#adac3d", "#3d46ad", "#41ad3d", "#84ad3d", "#3dad95", "#ad3daa", "#3dad66", "#64ad3d", "#69ad3d", "#3dad85", "#92ad3d", "#ad463d", "#76ad3d", "#ad833d", "#573dad", "#3dada3" ] }, "sort": [ "Study 1019 (2011)", "Study 1199 (2011)", "Study 1056 (2012)", "Study 1120 (2012)", "Study 1014 (2013)", "Study 1007 (2014)", "Study 1057 (2014)", "Study 1059 (2014)", "Study 1113 (2015)", "Study 1033 (2016)", "Study 1104 (2017)", "Study 1159 (2017)", "Study 1224 (2017)", "Study 1078 (2018)", "Study 1034 (2019)", "Study 1036 (2022)", "Study 1039 (2022)", "Study 1150 (2022)", "Study 1038 (2023)" ], "title": null, "type": "nominal" }, "order": { "field": "draw_order", "sort": "ascending", "type": "quantitative" }, "shape": { "field": "marker", "legend": null, "scale": null, "type": "nominal" }, "size": { "condition": { "test": "datum.event || datum.capped", "value": 49 }, "value": 41 }, "tooltip": [ { "field": "paper", "title": "Paper", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "study", "title": "Title", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "specification_id", "title": "Specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "source_specification_id", "title": "Archive specification", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "twfe_model", "title": "TWFE model", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "x", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "y", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "se_normalized_difference", "format": ".4f", "title": "Difference / SE(TWFE)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "modern", "format": ".4f", "title": "CS-DID: equal event time (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "twfe_se", "format": ".4f", "title": "TWFE SE (outcome SDs)", "type": "quantitative" }, { "field": "capped", "title": "Displayed at boundary", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "aggregation", "title": "Modern aggregation", "type": "nominal" }, { "field": "donor_rule", "title": "Comparison information", "type": "nominal" } ], "x": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_x", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "TWFE estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" }, "y": { "axis": { "format": ".1~f", "values": [ -5, -2.5, 0, 2.5, 5 ] }, "field": "display_y", "scale": { "domain": [ -5, 5 ], "nice": false, "zero": false }, "title": "CS-DID: equal event time estimate (TWFE SEs)", "type": "quantitative" } }, "transform": [ { "filter": "datum.event" } ] } ], "height": 720, "title": { "text": "CS-DID: equal event time vs TWFE", "anchor": "start", "fontSize": 21, "offset": 18, "subtitle": "19 comparisons; 5 capped (diamonds)", "subtitleColor": "#5A6873", "subtitleFontSize": 12, "subtitlePadding": 8 }, "usermeta": { "estimator": "CS-DID", "comparisons": 19, "capped": 5, "homogeneity_rings": 0, "view": "capped" }, "width": 720, "$schema": "https://vega.github.io/schema/vega-lite/v6.4.1.json" }