{ "paper": { "rank": 42, "paper_id": "aeraej-544", "title": "A Letter and Encouragement: Does Information Increase Postsecondary Enrollment of UI Recipients?", "authors": "Andrew Barr; Sarah Turner", "year": 2018, "journal": "American Economic Journal: Economic Policy", "doi": "10.1257/pol.20160570", "package_bytes": 265133739, "source_specification": "Table 2 Panel B Col", "selection_stratum": "binary_did" }, "mapping": { "paper_id": "aeraej-544", "match": true, "outcome": "train", "treatment": "pos_letter", "unit": "fips", "time": "ym_first", "cluster": "fips", "note": "State and month effects, demographic controls and state clustering are retained. Repeated UI-recipient observations are not collapsed." }, "status": "estimated", "source_fit": { "formula": "list(linear = train ~ pos_letter + i(sex) + i(age) + i(race), fixef = ~ym_first + fips)", "coefficients": { "pos_letter": 0.0247694454060583, "sex::2": 0.0363105844007633, "age::21": -0.0380954795557896, "age::22": -0.0454269787978256, "age::23": -0.0361729614474235, "age::24": -0.0832064452557607, "age::25": -0.0532722603355141, "age::26": -0.0884373898213317, "age::27": -0.07684518629507, "age::28": -0.0853725745844304, "age::29": -0.100174674928046, "age::30": -0.111529880452093, "age::31": -0.11534181985018, "age::32": -0.0770970462655821, "age::33": -0.0916384348698499, "age::34": -0.115408964357176, "age::35": -0.0818423107373438, "age::36": -0.0939439151886353, "age::37": -0.0997654397281316, "age::38": -0.109530754896485, "age::39": -0.116558594771293, "age::40": -0.108231871700626, "race::2": 0.00921256432697836, "race::3": -0.0141150409420315, "race::4": 0.0273533605006597, "race::5": -0.0643015491049362, "race::6": -0.0368447073879333, "race::9": -0.008596306487725 }, "se": { "pos_letter": 0.00823013151393066, "sex::2": 0.0071626066491039, "age::21": 0.0421703755664686, "age::22": 0.0392613282688066, "age::23": 0.0456571952897344, "age::24": 0.0349606459182038, "age::25": 0.0347812204534063, "age::26": 0.034975010403074, "age::27": 0.0339180671456574, "age::28": 0.0397100893708209, "age::29": 0.0368200816036153, "age::30": 0.0354100814031339, "age::31": 0.0328090867316353, "age::32": 0.0369319054707785, "age::33": 0.0385349822581602, "age::34": 0.0387154327656432, "age::35": 0.0404982365372087, "age::36": 0.0415931417693336, "age::37": 0.0422679725195276, "age::38": 0.0390130685187048, "age::39": 0.038726530391889, "age::40": 0.0401856591901783, "race::2": 0.00915692706563706, "race::3": 0.0245554610259176, "race::4": 0.0245357484959109, "race::5": 0.0111882289208241, "race::6": 0.030011255385104, "race::9": 0.0185267032979439 }, "n": 5154 }, "source_check": { "source_term": "pos_letter", "source_beta": 0.0247694454060583, "template_source_sample_beta": 0.024769445406058365, "template_source_sample_n": 5154, "template_source_sample_se": 0.008230131592541127, "same_point_specification": true, "dropped_missing_identifiers": 0, "controls": { "x001": "i(sex)1", "x002": "i(sex)2", "x003": "i(age)20", "x004": "i(age)21", "x005": "i(age)22", "x006": "i(age)23", "x007": "i(age)24", "x008": "i(age)25", "x009": "i(age)26", "x010": "i(age)27", "x011": "i(age)28", "x012": "i(age)29", "x013": "i(age)30", "x014": "i(age)31", "x015": "i(age)32", "x016": "i(age)33", "x017": "i(age)34", "x018": "i(age)35", "x019": "i(age)36", "x020": "i(age)37", "x021": "i(age)38", "x022": "i(age)39", "x023": "i(age)40", "x024": "i(race)1", "x025": "i(race)2", "x026": "i(race)3", "x027": "i(race)4", "x028": "i(race)5", "x029": "i(race)6", "x030": "i(race)9" }, "absolute_coefficient_difference": 6.591949208711867e-17 }, "settings": { "slug": "aeraej-544", "specification_id": "aeraej-544-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2 Panel B Col", "study": "A Letter and Encouragement: Does Information Increase Postsecondary Enrollment of UI Recipients?", "citation": "Andrew Barr; Sarah Turner (2018). https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20160570", "description": "State and month effects, demographic controls and state clustering are retained. Repeated UI-recipient observations are not collapsed.", "data": "analyses/new-library/tranche100/aeraej-544/panel.parquet", "unit": "unit", "time": "time", "cluster": "cluster", "covariates": [ "x001", "x002", "x003", "x004", "x005", "x006", "x007", "x008", "x009", "x010", "x011", "x012", "x013", "x014", "x015", "x016", "x017", "x018", "x019", "x020", "x021", "x022", "x023", "x024", "x025", "x026", "x027", "x028", "x029", "x030" ], "time_fe": null, "unit_fe": null, "allow_repeated_cells": true, "period_values": null, "period_step": 1, "weight": null, "latest_cohort_control": true, "reversal_policy": "drop_post_untreated", "test_mode": "classical", "post_weighting": "observations", "display_window": [ -10, 10 ], "labels": { "y": "train", "d": "pos_letter", "unit": "fips", "time": "ym_first", "cluster": "fips", "x001": "i(sex)1", "x002": "i(sex)2", "x003": "i(age)20", "x004": "i(age)21", "x005": "i(age)22", "x006": "i(age)23", "x007": "i(age)24", "x008": "i(age)25", "x009": "i(age)26", "x010": "i(age)27", "x011": "i(age)28", "x012": "i(age)29", "x013": "i(age)30", "x014": "i(age)31", "x015": "i(age)32", "x016": "i(age)33", "x017": "i(age)34", "x018": "i(age)35", "x019": "i(age)36", "x020": "i(age)37", "x021": "i(age)38", "x022": "i(age)39", "x023": "i(age)40", "x024": "i(race)1", "x025": "i(race)2", "x026": "i(race)3", "x027": "i(race)4", "x028": "i(race)5", "x029": "i(race)6", "x030": "i(race)9" } }, "options": { "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche100/aeraej-544/results", "timeout_seconds": 300, "isolate_matrix": true }, "comparison": { "schema": "expensive-replication-v1", "config": { "outcomes": [ "y" ], "treatments": [ "d" ], "unit": "unit", "time": "time", "cluster": "cluster", "covariates": [ "x001", "x002", "x003", "x004", "x005", "x006", "x007", "x008", "x009", "x010", "x011", "x012", "x013", "x014", "x015", "x016", "x017", "x018", "x019", "x020", "x021", "x022", "x023", "x024", "x025", "x026", "x027", "x028", "x029", "x030" ], "baseline_by_time": [], "weight": null, "period_step": 1, "period_values": null, "display_window": [ -10, 10 ], "seed": 20261008, "panelview_max_units": 100, "test_mode": "classical", "test_horizon": null, "post_horizon": null, "post_weighting": "observations", "sample_query": null, "reversal_policy": "drop_post_untreated", "labels": { "y": "train", "d": "pos_letter", "unit": "fips", "time": "ym_first", "cluster": "fips", "x001": "i(sex)1", "x002": "i(sex)2", "x003": "i(age)20", "x004": "i(age)21", "x005": "i(age)22", "x006": "i(age)23", "x007": "i(age)24", "x008": "i(age)25", "x009": "i(age)26", "x010": "i(age)27", "x011": "i(age)28", "x012": "i(age)29", "x013": "i(age)30", "x014": "i(age)31", "x015": "i(age)32", "x016": "i(age)33", "x017": "i(age)34", "x018": "i(age)35", "x019": "i(age)36", "x020": "i(age)37", "x021": "i(age)38", "x022": "i(age)39", "x023": "i(age)40", "x024": "i(race)1", "x025": "i(race)2", "x026": "i(race)3", "x027": "i(race)4", "x028": "i(race)5", "x029": "i(race)6", "x030": "i(race)9" }, "allow_repeated_cells": true, "time_fe": null, "unit_fe": null, "frequency_weights": false, "source_sd": null, "require_never_control_periods": false, "latest_cohort_control": true, "slug": "aeraej-544", "specification_id": "aeraej-544-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 2 Panel B Col", "study": "A Letter and Encouragement: Does Information Increase Postsecondary Enrollment of UI Recipients?", "citation": "Andrew Barr; Sarah Turner (2018). https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20160570", "description": "State and month effects, demographic controls and state clustering are retained. Repeated UI-recipient observations are not collapsed.", "data": "analyses/new-library/tranche100/aeraej-544/panel.parquet", "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche100/aeraej-544/results" }, "options": { "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche100/aeraej-544/results", "timeout_seconds": 300, "isolate_matrix": true }, "source": { "file": "panel.parquet", "bytes": 40203, "sha256": "defdc545077bd113f0941886da45d36c643793abe88e769447f739ffd3fe98fb" }, "regressions": { "y__d": { "sample": { "outcome": "y", "treatment": "d", "source_rows": 5154, "source_sd": 0.26387035628532285, "rows": 4028, "units": 45, "clusters": 45, "treated_units": 36, "never_treated_units": 9, "treated_cohorts": 11, "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "unique_unit_period_cells": 964, "unsupported_prediction_rows_removed": 0, "rows_without_never_control_time_fe_removed": 0, "initially_treated_units_removed": 0, "post_adoption_untreated_rows_removed": 906, "units_without_minus_one_removed": 4, "additional_rows_removed": 220 }, "estimates": [ { "method": "Static TWFE", "estimate": 0.06327481870451286, "se": 0.04525275606214825, "pvalue": 0.16904560995622356, "lower": -0.027926118517354173, "upper": 0.1544757559263799 }, { "method": "Dynamic TWFE", "estimate": 0.08512752860583779, "se": 0.0798071626517316, "pvalue": 0.2919410100099571, "lower": -0.07571323921082145, "upper": 0.245968296422497 }, { "method": "BJS / did2s", "estimate": 0.0794829609969031, "se": 0.055145075216202856, "pvalue": 0.15656742262081652, "lower": -0.031654635484094557, "upper": 0.19062055747790074 }, { "method": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "estimate": 0.06539341514352318, "se": 0.08460568616679325, "pvalue": 0.44370226869142243, "lower": -0.10511814137059722, "upper": 0.23590497165764357 } ], "event_studies": { "Dynamic TWFE": [ { "event_time": -13, "estimate": 0.4843343323244723, "se": 0.7668751037679329, "pvalue": 0.53093644955559, "lower": -1.061200885457616, "upper": 2.029869550106561 }, { "event_time": -12, "estimate": 0.6397467380811958, "se": 0.18560992173043064, "pvalue": 0.0012599872087974478, "lower": 0.26567452033064093, "upper": 1.0138189558317505 }, { "event_time": -11, "estimate": -0.21017034729641318, "se": 0.11493608556512101, "pvalue": 0.07424551051953183, "lower": -0.441808807277852, "upper": 0.02146811268502563 }, { "event_time": -10, "estimate": -0.10812315502908629, "se": 0.11798955359032433, "pvalue": 0.36446360252456367, "lower": -0.3459154754581207, "upper": 0.1296691653999481 }, { "event_time": -9, "estimate": 0.14190299265329198, "se": 0.2898399719598487, "pvalue": 0.626855576178506, "lower": -0.44223108861227667, "upper": 0.7260370739188606 }, { "event_time": -8, "estimate": 0.3299298568039423, "se": 0.16839446521910215, "pvalue": 0.05643641980968868, "lower": -0.009446888114434282, "upper": 0.6693066017223189 }, { "event_time": -7, "estimate": 0.21763340653875657, "se": 0.1395535722315171, "pvalue": 0.126043286004193, "lower": -0.0636183378344386, "upper": 0.49888515091195174 }, { "event_time": -6, "estimate": 0.05402739033790228, "se": 0.1344988381426162, "pvalue": 0.6898536708253088, "lower": -0.21703720685508648, "upper": 0.325091987530891 }, { "event_time": -5, "estimate": 0.08784932356452019, "se": 0.15100076990921726, "pvalue": 0.5636834887239094, "lower": -0.21647273182655985, "upper": 0.3921713789556002 }, { "event_time": -4, "estimate": 0.028535692740022687, "se": 0.12219139727898426, "pvalue": 0.8164308595023984, "lower": -0.2177248872120181, "upper": 0.27479627269206347 }, { "event_time": -3, "estimate": -0.026921350063008963, "se": 0.08678584207067389, "pvalue": 0.7578701169685639, "lower": -0.20182672209304253, "upper": 0.1479840219670246 }, { "event_time": -2, "estimate": -0.000139617119279455, "se": 0.10817029017061987, "pvalue": 0.9989759922431781, "lower": -0.2181425124473197, "upper": 0.21786327820876078 }, { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.048907881322290334, "se": 0.11210921391500935, "pvalue": 0.6647869782741614, "lower": -0.17703339319839906, "upper": 0.27484915584297975 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.32744131792297887, "se": 0.14668907322425417, "pvalue": 0.030739918253593304, "lower": 0.031808916221610084, "upper": 0.6230737196243477 }, { "event_time": 2, "estimate": -0.04579906163891215, "se": 0.09062275459150604, "pvalue": 0.6158132768464474, "lower": -0.22843722274940811, "upper": 0.13683909947158382 }, { "event_time": 3, "estimate": 0.06275719761544811, "se": 0.09118476642625509, "pvalue": 0.4949130831134078, "lower": -0.12101362392325472, "upper": 0.24652801915415096 }, { "event_time": 4, "estimate": 0.07009318546249779, "se": 0.11184597724159356, "pvalue": 0.5340982025050045, "lower": -0.15531757040218502, "upper": 0.2955039413271806 }, { "event_time": 5, "estimate": 0.011698856474633633, "se": 0.08398667580641404, "pvalue": 0.8898533089563451, "lower": -0.15756516663093376, "upper": 0.18096287958020105 }, { "event_time": 6, "estimate": 0.03828745289143493, "se": 0.13840587360442852, "pvalue": 0.7833582874969949, "lower": -0.24065125688349231, "upper": 0.31722616266636217 }, { "event_time": 7, "estimate": 0.003276711671192655, "se": 0.15381466764886417, "pvalue": 0.9831002774638885, "lower": -0.3067163819821724, "upper": 0.31326980532455767 }, { "event_time": 8, "estimate": 0.060059559174085266, "se": 0.11998817418315696, "pvalue": 0.6191855518440786, "lower": -0.1817607163913596, "upper": 0.3018798347395301 }, { "event_time": 9, "estimate": 0.1679726085443277, "se": 0.1579465936853456, "pvalue": 0.2933674768405043, "lower": -0.15034783486296197, "upper": 0.4862930519516173 }, { "event_time": 10, "estimate": -0.04600608793695071, "se": 0.11242475926230903, "pvalue": 0.684365874220404, "lower": -0.2725833023188545, "upper": 0.1805711264449531 }, { "event_time": 11, "estimate": 0.3029571933655312, "se": 0.16181687839194403, "pvalue": 0.06783130830531246, "lower": -0.023163296343302497, "upper": 0.6290776830743648 }, { "event_time": 12, "estimate": 0.14801176184738027, "se": 0.1903911018461853, "pvalue": 0.441077465749334, "lower": -0.23569629127604177, "upper": 0.5317198149708023 }, { "event_time": 13, "estimate": 0.015759776110395935, "se": 0.1733739564299658, "pvalue": 0.9279842359846868, "lower": -0.33365247393158304, "upper": 0.3651720261523749 }, { "event_time": 14, "estimate": 0.05402713454267863, "se": 0.1521338792118676, "pvalue": 0.724189770093318, "lower": -0.2525785525952635, "upper": 0.3606328216806207 }, { "event_time": 15, "estimate": 0.08781713185589868, "se": 0.11432119559827583, "pvalue": 0.4464945639323411, "lower": -0.14258209882450953, "upper": 0.3182163625363069 }, { "event_time": 16, "estimate": 0.07494102766045262, "se": 0.12573286158325422, "pvalue": 0.5542067035990031, "lower": -0.1784569046164639, "upper": 0.32833895993736917 }, { "event_time": 17, "estimate": 0.0688833133389016, "se": 0.23341359273999, "pvalue": 0.7692958808156544, "lower": -0.4015308729036965, "upper": 0.5392974995814996 }, { "event_time": 18, "estimate": 0.06543561189995654, "se": 0.20338159014317903, "pvalue": 0.7491746470000813, "lower": -0.3444530501134178, "upper": 0.47532427391333093 }, { "event_time": 19, "estimate": 0.24452028448903707, "se": 0.15674835147468472, "pvalue": 0.12593520972853522, "lower": -0.07138526042055682, "upper": 0.560425829398631 }, { "event_time": 20, "estimate": 0.17297325183887563, "se": 0.18828583641890448, "pvalue": 0.3632751003868061, "lower": -0.20649191760680713, "upper": 0.5524384212845583 }, { "event_time": 21, "estimate": 0.09286229347061252, "se": 0.18663559262983628, "pvalue": 0.62127217950609, "lower": -0.283277028152655, "upper": 0.46900161509388005 }, { "event_time": 22, "estimate": -0.16720981349127445, "se": 0.1482228266726562, "pvalue": 0.2653925524813006, "lower": -0.465933292159744, "upper": 0.1315136651771951 } ], "BJS / did2s": [ { "event_time": -13, "estimate": 0.3362319237929659, "se": 0.5964824439880911, "pvalue": 0.5758261608641948, "lower": -0.8658994525456014, "upper": 1.538363300131533 }, { "event_time": -12, "estimate": 0.567113891683104, "se": 0.19953029662085173, "pvalue": 0.006766168469714493, "lower": 0.16498700175429337, "upper": 0.9692407816119146 }, { "event_time": -11, "estimate": -0.308499406478735, "se": 0.07553304849178438, "pvalue": 0.00018395649547115161, "lower": -0.4607262632079657, "upper": -0.15627254974950436 }, { "event_time": -10, "estimate": -0.2376865528355896, "se": 0.0531221362047078, "pvalue": 5.351054842709334e-05, "lower": -0.3447471836277428, "upper": -0.1306259220434364 }, { "event_time": -9, "estimate": 0.012728265908514119, "se": 0.25332980152520845, "pvalue": 0.9601554610938768, "lower": -0.4978244017256653, "upper": 0.5232809335426936 }, { "event_time": -8, "estimate": 0.20509884825893065, "se": 0.1399945358931083, "pvalue": 0.15001710989677194, "lower": -0.07704159997934346, "upper": 0.48723929649720477 }, { "event_time": -7, "estimate": 0.11386295372180859, "se": 0.10104701258464308, "pvalue": 0.26592178028731883, "lower": -0.08978391893569197, "upper": 0.31750982637930913 }, { "event_time": -6, "estimate": -0.027957363380532247, "se": 0.10044559109464726, "pvalue": 0.7820602990918787, "lower": -0.23039215066852162, "upper": 0.1744774239074571 }, { "event_time": -5, "estimate": -0.030199738621707207, "se": 0.12038586436573248, "pvalue": 0.8030918113050135, "lower": -0.27282150608578937, "upper": 0.21242202884237496 }, { "event_time": -4, "estimate": -0.037678230936838995, "se": 0.0792395726949424, "pvalue": 0.6367845308132227, "lower": -0.19737509635900535, "upper": 0.12201863448532735 }, { "event_time": -3, "estimate": -0.057012673017103395, "se": 0.055250491107116544, "pvalue": 0.3077604180877653, "lower": -0.16836272126647958, "upper": 0.0543373752322728 }, { "event_time": -2, "estimate": -0.011917334603424699, "se": 0.06741007341837685, "pvalue": 0.8604856856713115, "lower": -0.14777341076169487, "upper": 0.12393874155484547 }, { "event_time": -1, "estimate": 0.0038512330709206998, "se": 0.0468960754166, "pvalue": 0.9349215808020024, "lower": -0.09066159669236426, "upper": 0.09836406283420565 }, { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.0725332933240073, "se": 0.09577632656089288, "pvalue": 0.4528951166398517, "lower": -0.12049120962615319, "upper": 0.2655577962741678 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.2951487417683973, "se": 0.13876728107755562, "pvalue": 0.03906962353307442, "lower": 0.015481663090968045, "upper": 0.5748158204458265 }, { "event_time": 2, "estimate": -0.04899114546844451, "se": 0.07622104245982457, "pvalue": 0.5237211798088893, "lower": -0.20260456293227627, "upper": 0.10462227199538723 }, { "event_time": 3, "estimate": 0.047187957038953454, "se": 0.08125942551636095, "pvalue": 0.564400271613926, "lower": -0.11657965426464859, "upper": 0.2109555683425555 }, { "event_time": 4, "estimate": 0.08374570480309207, "se": 0.10793720515812406, "pvalue": 0.4419737735690177, "lower": -0.1337874385486753, "upper": 0.30127884815485945 }, { "event_time": 5, "estimate": 0.03385683672731203, "se": 0.09491094376921755, "pvalue": 0.7230049020648147, "lower": -0.15742360180502435, "upper": 0.22513727525964844 }, { "event_time": 6, "estimate": 0.03153877469159972, "se": 0.11864688598668503, "pvalue": 0.7916190711105374, "lower": -0.20757831213469147, "upper": 0.2706558615178909 }, { "event_time": 7, "estimate": -0.0229764998052604, "se": 0.13828414974687298, "pvalue": 0.8687967207768466, "lower": -0.30166989126463395, "upper": 0.25571689165411315 }, { "event_time": 8, "estimate": -0.020245221111889613, "se": 0.13347410483423408, "pvalue": 0.8801334461282807, "lower": -0.28924460402271257, "upper": 0.24875416179893337 }, { "event_time": 9, "estimate": 0.08817128462314115, "se": 0.17653260255749265, "pvalue": 0.6199425499860312, "lower": -0.26760679840339774, "upper": 0.44394936764968007 }, { "event_time": 10, "estimate": -0.0651205091579343, "se": 0.12168600101228744, "pvalue": 0.5952392527436873, "lower": -0.3103625298618294, "upper": 0.1801215115459608 }, { "event_time": 11, "estimate": 0.28118142453284806, "se": 0.15124005332776352, "pvalue": 0.0696980999806201, "lower": -0.023622874901072177, "upper": 0.5859857239667683 }, { "event_time": 12, "estimate": 0.08849983621248107, "se": 0.17265497170455837, "pvalue": 0.6108074777089437, "lower": -0.2594633953273914, "upper": 0.43646306775235355 }, { "event_time": 13, "estimate": -0.08622011482438525, "se": 0.15171647367212887, "pvalue": 0.5727219652539604, "lower": -0.39198457637214473, "upper": 0.21954434672337425 }, { "event_time": 14, "estimate": 0.0825389974065587, "se": 0.17198207516057618, "pvalue": 0.6336559267251187, "lower": -0.26406810025761673, "upper": 0.4291460950707342 }, { "event_time": 15, "estimate": 0.09079175000853476, "se": 0.11502832053359305, "pvalue": 0.4341700063011578, "lower": -0.14103259733759244, "upper": 0.32261609735466196 }, { "event_time": 16, "estimate": 0.07068784999018557, "se": 0.1246426501612196, "pvalue": 0.5735120247654083, "lower": -0.18051290553747418, "upper": 0.3218886055178453 }, { "event_time": 17, "estimate": -0.012947232596409687, "se": 0.22324214009933502, "pvalue": 0.954014116996463, "lower": -0.46286220300204134, "upper": 0.436967737809222 }, { "event_time": 18, "estimate": 0.028808856319920806, "se": 0.20485496090068508, "pvalue": 0.8888036949382523, "lower": -0.38404918934326493, "upper": 0.44166690198310654 }, { "event_time": 19, "estimate": 0.2865488202257979, "se": 0.16428676219361674, "pvalue": 0.08810734989868477, "lower": -0.04454939320957085, "upper": 0.6176470336611667 }, { "event_time": 20, "estimate": 0.33923590481589566, "se": 0.17477225512816577, "pvalue": 0.05867878037455085, "lower": -0.01299443108182241, "upper": 0.6914662407136137 }, { "event_time": 21, "estimate": 0.36580176832455413, "se": 0.14790158037500048, "pvalue": 0.017320595882281225, "lower": 0.06772571902779007, "upper": 0.6638778176213183 }, { "event_time": 22, "estimate": -0.08547674652877031, "se": 0.13343344616504488, "pvalue": 0.525108474004415, "lower": -0.3543941872760893, "upper": 0.1834406942185487 } ], "Sun\u2013Abraham": [ { "event_time": -13, "estimate": 0.6400640515104389, "se": 0.8335544256227571, "pvalue": 0.44666406234974804, "lower": -1.0398545094237615, "upper": 2.3199826124446394 }, { "event_time": -12, "estimate": 0.9713258842429784, "se": 0.26696057059708167, "pvalue": 0.000716604887789034, "lower": 0.4333022066066148, "upper": 1.509349561879342 }, { "event_time": -11, "estimate": 0.007530781859746334, "se": 0.20000133793769545, "pvalue": 0.9701341476632627, "lower": -0.39554542946525445, "upper": 0.4106069931847471 }, { "event_time": -10, "estimate": 0.000531585253339989, "se": 0.11175623106416661, "pvalue": 0.9962262580957117, "lower": -0.22469829907542627, "upper": 0.22576146958210624 }, { "event_time": -9, "estimate": 0.3081743829136744, "se": 0.09520055843082885, "pvalue": 0.0022976519517970157, "lower": 0.11631026438324304, "upper": 0.5000385014441058 }, { "event_time": -8, "estimate": 0.3596079788430032, "se": 0.1664607016780112, "pvalue": 0.03623543848690802, "lower": 0.02412847826198289, "upper": 0.6950874794240236 }, { "event_time": -7, "estimate": 0.2994204850594676, "se": 0.12674575521450998, "pvalue": 0.022646170817019813, "lower": 0.04398119980175763, "upper": 0.5548597703171776 }, { "event_time": -6, "estimate": 0.157594226058542, "se": 0.08537973428290399, "pvalue": 0.07165571461336795, "lower": -0.014477321929847242, "upper": 0.32966577404693126 }, { "event_time": -5, "estimate": 0.1397378390730709, "se": 0.09446132345269338, "pvalue": 0.14618120498303017, "lower": -0.05063644925253155, "upper": 0.33011212739867335 }, { "event_time": -4, "estimate": 0.048236869381318145, "se": 0.10187065323745491, "pvalue": 0.638189709046315, "lower": -0.1570699419408531, "upper": 0.25354368070348937 }, { "event_time": -3, "estimate": 0.009443867767954738, "se": 0.09547053960749287, "pvalue": 0.9216517349302049, "lower": -0.1829643620716354, "upper": 0.2018520976075449 }, { "event_time": -2, "estimate": 0.027373257231688302, "se": 0.11695431807381539, "pvalue": 0.8160311405133198, "lower": -0.20833268310546144, "upper": 0.263079197568838 }, { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.010743172307970165, "se": 0.11617963428795432, "pvalue": 0.9267440943311224, "lower": -0.22340149544670782, "upper": 0.24488784006264816 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.3151008568301958, "se": 0.13807040857630878, "pvalue": 0.027369900107740014, "lower": 0.03683823239530093, "upper": 0.5933634812650906 }, { "event_time": 2, "estimate": -0.057546213993971376, "se": 0.09861783834108145, "pvalue": 0.5625177233788672, "lower": -0.25629740764832387, "upper": 0.14120497966038115 }, { "event_time": 3, "estimate": 0.05415399002192197, "se": 0.08396991604998974, "pvalue": 0.5223267840175041, "lower": -0.1150762560139923, "upper": 0.22338423605783625 }, { "event_time": 4, "estimate": 0.07071681767010682, "se": 0.11973053147900439, "pvalue": 0.5577880302755499, "lower": -0.17058421314359695, "upper": 0.3120178484838106 }, { "event_time": 5, "estimate": -0.019534934703952928, "se": 0.07617002038918026, "pvalue": 0.7987872822062623, "lower": -0.17304552394102718, "upper": 0.13397565453312132 }, { "event_time": 6, "estimate": 0.04311450336270167, "se": 0.1323755409486178, "pvalue": 0.7461964484715542, "lower": -0.2236708695145953, "upper": 0.30989987623999865 }, { "event_time": 7, "estimate": 0.002406663590406144, "se": 0.14851677889652803, "pvalue": 0.9871443772593552, "lower": -0.2969092368584903, "upper": 0.3017225640393026 }, { "event_time": 8, "estimate": 0.00912855722057987, "se": 0.15172760047818304, "pvalue": 0.9522973662403382, "lower": -0.2966583289313083, "upper": 0.314915443372468 }, { "event_time": 9, "estimate": 0.10829677235228902, "se": 0.17087238008535285, "pvalue": 0.5295006792278629, "lower": -0.2360738818397614, "upper": 0.45266742654433945 }, { "event_time": 10, "estimate": -0.07217183381844917, "se": 0.11921470707681972, "pvalue": 0.5480274923814983, "lower": -0.31243328885788313, "upper": 0.16808962122098475 }, { "event_time": 11, "estimate": 0.2620115387467597, "se": 0.13901847563011185, "pvalue": 0.06608288063044232, "lower": -0.01816178928676826, "upper": 0.5421848667802877 }, { "event_time": 12, "estimate": 0.1183959337225494, "se": 0.15063929041058008, "pvalue": 0.4361052924222099, "lower": -0.18519760760815107, "upper": 0.4219894750532499 }, { "event_time": 13, "estimate": -0.09708982499081056, "se": 0.1318479180658759, "pvalue": 0.4654091630860944, "lower": -0.3628118438186949, "upper": 0.1686321938370738 }, { "event_time": 14, "estimate": 0.04519551748457161, "se": 0.1813406461276641, "pvalue": 0.8043427270980309, "lower": -0.32027254064980365, "upper": 0.4106635756189469 }, { "event_time": 15, "estimate": 0.061956734990778514, "se": 0.11218726524670883, "pvalue": 0.5835636244983149, "lower": -0.1641418416529602, "upper": 0.2880553116345172 }, { "event_time": 16, "estimate": 0.07287801489724108, "se": 0.134807143091128, "pvalue": 0.5915031518620611, "lower": -0.19880793009201894, "upper": 0.3445639598865011 }, { "event_time": 17, "estimate": -0.051349315044471544, "se": 0.214481650779344, "pvalue": 0.8118984796286749, "lower": -0.4836086793383324, "upper": 0.3809100492493893 }, { "event_time": 18, "estimate": 0.010026272934466939, "se": 0.23675380429945578, "pvalue": 0.9664121269838066, "lower": -0.4671196673768607, "upper": 0.4871722132457946 }, { "event_time": 19, "estimate": 0.2682620220558425, "se": 0.1959248001782274, "pvalue": 0.17788282774597028, "lower": -0.12659846725273072, "upper": 0.6631225113644157 }, { "event_time": 20, "estimate": 0.29359259190307707, "se": 0.2047551732252894, "pvalue": 0.1586777547754463, "lower": -0.11906434491478707, "upper": 0.7062495287209412 }, { "event_time": 21, "estimate": 0.2183839520807334, "se": 0.22523123199393585, "pvalue": 0.337546407587567, "lower": -0.23553976963186568, "upper": 0.6723076737933324 }, { "event_time": 22, "estimate": -0.0880638226028748, "se": 0.22705661872019206, "pvalue": 0.6999973938537382, "lower": -0.5456663695343907, "upper": 0.3695387243286411 } ] }, "target": { "event_times": [ 0.0, 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, 5.0, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0, 9.0, 10.0, 11.0, 12.0, 13.0, 14.0, 15.0, 16.0, 17.0, 18.0, 19.0, 20.0, 21.0, 22.0 ], "weights": [ 0.07532347504621072, 0.05499075785582255, 0.054528650646950096, 0.06192236598890943, 0.06146025878003697, 0.0688539741219963, 0.051756007393715345, 0.044824399260628464, 0.04205175600739371, 0.04066543438077634, 0.04944547134935305, 0.04944547134935305, 0.04390018484288355, 0.03927911275415896, 0.0355822550831793, 0.04713493530499076, 0.03512014787430684, 0.03512014787430684, 0.022181146025878003, 0.027726432532347505, 0.031423290203327174, 0.020794824399260628, 0.006469500924214418 ], "weighting": "observations" }, "checks": { "did2s_vs_direct_imputation_max_post_difference": 4.672195147437108e-08, "package_aggregate_vs_estimable_cell_weights": null, "saturated_vs_deviations_relative_rss_difference": 1.2014655767571744e-14 }, "inference": { "standard_errors": "Cluster-robust; did2s uses two-stage covariance", "confidence_intervals": "Pointwise t, clusters minus one degrees of freedom" }, "f_test": { "F": 0.8241053557983791, "df_num": 144, "df_den": 3687, "pvalue": 0.9364732467976324, "log10_pvalue": -0.028504625052355792, "inference": "Homoskedastic nested-model F", "observations": 4028, "design_columns": 271, "restricted_design_columns": 127, "fixed_effect_rank": 70, "covariance_rank": 144, "rss_unrestricted": 3557.842339411982, "rss_restricted": 3672.356393517589, "test_horizon": null, "reference_cohort": 3, "pyfixest": "0.27.0", "formulaic": "1.0.2", "formula": "y~i(rel_time,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_4,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_5,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_6,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_7,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_8,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_9,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_10,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_11,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_12,ref=-1.0)+i(rel_time,cohort_dummy_14,ref=-1.0)+x0+x1+x2+x3+x4+x5+x6+x7+x8+x9+x10+x11+x12+x13+x14+x15+x16+x17+x18+x19+x20+x21+x22+x23+x24+x25+x26+x27+x28+x29|unit_fe+time_fe", "restriction_names": [ "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.16.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.17.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.18.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.19.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.20.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.21.0]:cohort_dummy_4", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.16.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.17.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.18.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.19.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.20.0]:cohort_dummy_5", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.16.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.17.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.18.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.19.0]:cohort_dummy_6", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.16.0]:cohort_dummy_7", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_8", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.16.0]:cohort_dummy_9", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.15.0]:cohort_dummy_10", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.13.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.14.0]:cohort_dummy_11", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.7.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.8.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.9.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.10.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.11.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.12.0]:cohort_dummy_12", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.1.0]:cohort_dummy_14", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.2.0]:cohort_dummy_14", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.3.0]:cohort_dummy_14", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.4.0]:cohort_dummy_14", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.5.0]:cohort_dummy_14", "C(rel_time, contr.treatment(base=-1.0))[T.6.0]:cohort_dummy_14" ], "deviations": [ { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.44610867827047096 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -1.2039385197632138 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.6202217801026246 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.6818905221980377 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.07819994786802612 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.6885965979173007 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.551015263299969 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.13952368683416638 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.5461125066670397 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.2176949317359652 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.295741601761668 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.2556088598209616 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.2945354270660555 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.9483169644795495 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -1.3170240828532165 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.8768792127722322 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.17001759944108208 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.03561828023363861 }, { "event_time": 16.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.7370917498440818 }, { "event_time": 17.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.5263662058501833 }, { "event_time": 18.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.14063824935939281 }, { "event_time": 19.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.021742054706064343 }, { "event_time": 20.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": 0.17189274802284762 }, { "event_time": 21.0, "cohort": 4, "estimate": -0.04523949192127505 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.10095785613917246 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.2088042911253799 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -1.362756187480576 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.6195925192929683 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.19310524889730235 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.1894307895508602 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.7930849960404417 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.5289523098429143 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.03684215156119237 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.8134742028854429 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.31862894677127596 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.059083222725142104 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.9148521535278465 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.10316119393103795 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -1.4869107934640158 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -1.5714021143576598 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -1.2500140576983214 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.048918518885615006 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.25910123589364686 }, { "event_time": 16.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.6153986126352698 }, { "event_time": 17.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.25213855323419454 }, { "event_time": 18.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": -0.30682863085197765 }, { "event_time": 19.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.07835310895507241 }, { "event_time": 20.0, "cohort": 5, "estimate": 0.26442916236862957 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.1941571336522081 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.6653037964041197 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.3881290048269337 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.9574072392059938 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 1.55599902906458 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.6700499952807969 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.08122676093693702 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.45340579445610635 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.4607467029297412 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.22227490700279312 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.09439111472728207 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.562598937143413 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.23271887727233376 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.8039227025755504 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.7696381486160531 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -1.8796129754512971 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.7506796552095995 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.13605021929850544 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.5831475138637235 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.3185507180450855 }, { "event_time": 16.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -1.1633385050644474 }, { "event_time": 17.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 1.2581326230608276 }, { "event_time": 18.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": -0.32265485258459364 }, { "event_time": 19.0, "cohort": 6, "estimate": 0.5002827770786921 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 1.7989511965153717 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.22990275506908364 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.11681216382545012 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.1890836858628115 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -1.1037991920075303 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.6749903245723671 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.3386177861328755 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.07154313850907762 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.7226665225347296 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.6726367658622903 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.023736840480238025 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.6762419846352753 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.3350362147554448 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.08043737900073744 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.7072843516177851 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.022910095369791272 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.6908187912079582 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.6510823988007262 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.20839664822166312 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": 0.37688464105117003 }, { "event_time": 16.0, "cohort": 7, "estimate": -0.7015541511199447 }, { "event_time": -7.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": -0.05397523021277345 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.3982066156084749 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.9667898846195445 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": -0.13940131090401897 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": -0.18128441654556982 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": -1.4310824598081822 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.7880894896964364 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.7136108608040682 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.05469535565346026 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.8356201923653135 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.8278537369066298 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": -0.27180190018997175 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 8, "estimate": 0.5352442630544523 }, { "event_time": -8.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.8078364914497904 }, { "event_time": -7.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.22247767945251523 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.3630130389495274 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.15035602905895096 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.127538546887829 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.09701380909366175 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -1.400101616497544 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.7090935075766841 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.6596152178630517 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.20036458486770586 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.7118022507632041 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.8188657998251059 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.46238400035529575 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": 0.6049343767384927 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.3151522507964939 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.07027553420171417 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.41602137320457344 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.010573595323166984 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -1.9695469008243276 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -1.6852665288868207 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -1.0711861665698312 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.36701475511219334 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.11784436758639759 }, { "event_time": 16.0, "cohort": 9, "estimate": -0.2677769271772036 }, { "event_time": -9.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -0.1400867261331431 }, { "event_time": -8.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.32645064575435434 }, { "event_time": -7.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.31735644786346967 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.7232604802946149 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -0.11308015908855631 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.10060681397365145 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.04885469558855626 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -1.0785207371960148 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.7384393793139946 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.742754047702027 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.10176056932454375 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.9596120003606234 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.6960588385627217 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.3766877728069363 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 1.1073280681449236 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -0.33171200381513266 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.33498469177273116 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.28965756446966856 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.19314263271889687 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -1.6727995795320905 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -1.1572199227565303 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": -0.720671967990163 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.4644040180816566 }, { "event_time": 15.0, "cohort": 10, "estimate": 0.8982423778847031 }, { "event_time": -10.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.17781493707161183 }, { "event_time": -9.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.1892392054349254 }, { "event_time": -8.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -0.6208273468933801 }, { "event_time": -7.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.5328457721976716 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -0.17819066055301824 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -0.038794330013423695 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.09564773641410382 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.0227990207142989 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -1.3321985845110431 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.7216120442501639 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.5521490486577394 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.11508203724163148 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 1.011974448221058 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.5854353305593376 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -0.02456348427461766 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.5085053424139716 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.1978686919404935 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -0.19168502816592958 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.1476620033737217 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.9610677153551481 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -1.489023763396872 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": -1.3076460146552518 }, { "event_time": 13.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.24933488839658588 }, { "event_time": 14.0, "cohort": 11, "estimate": 0.21571744233222534 }, { "event_time": -11.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.010193743175743508 }, { "event_time": -10.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.18175027455577925 }, { "event_time": -9.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 1.4192298357687088 }, { "event_time": -8.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -1.1308325552090854 }, { "event_time": -7.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.11274091469338055 }, { "event_time": -6.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.15876656974183756 }, { "event_time": -5.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.039436424985159174 }, { "event_time": -4.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.3484623473470207 }, { "event_time": -3.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.22368832752489373 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -1.3249536999700344 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.3559448229663195 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.019169341081136833 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.16785309910366789 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.6158691591640257 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.32745508486579544 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.37864274720193647 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": 0.4578118298579244 }, { "event_time": 7.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.2693219475717268 }, { "event_time": 8.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.25994485394648603 }, { "event_time": 9.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.6061725193136306 }, { "event_time": 10.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -0.10038932136868678 }, { "event_time": 11.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -1.716530942565551 }, { "event_time": 12.0, "cohort": 12, "estimate": -1.6734996787612086 }, { "event_time": -2.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": -0.7283748198000144 }, { "event_time": 0.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.5062793319065161 }, { "event_time": 1.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.6589323070744741 }, { "event_time": 2.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.552498714819118 }, { "event_time": 3.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.8876782994457956 }, { "event_time": 4.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.3289867268912483 }, { "event_time": 5.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": -0.18795865772474313 }, { "event_time": 6.0, "cohort": 14, "estimate": 0.6696835191159982 } ] } } }, "alternative_models": { "y__d": [ { "method": "CS-DID", "status": "unidentified", "reason": "UnidentifiedTarget: CS-DID cannot estimate 177 observed post-treatment group-time cells with the configured controls; no target cells were dropped. See csdid-group-time.json and package log." }, { "method": "SDID", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "sdid: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Matrix completion", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "matrix-completion: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Horizontal ridge", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "horizontal-ridge: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Multisynth (cohort-averaged)", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "multisynth-cohort: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Multisynth (individual)", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "multisynth-individual: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." } ] }, "combined_table": [ { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Static TWFE", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.06327481870451286, "SE": 0.04525275606214825, "Aggregation": "Coefficient", "Event study": "No", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Dynamic TWFE", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.08512752860583779, "SE": 0.0798071626517316, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "BJS / did2s", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.0794829609969031, "SE": 0.055145075216202856, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.06539341514352318, "SE": 0.08460568616679325, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "CS-DID", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Equal post-event times", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unidentified", "Note": "UnidentifiedTarget: CS-DID cannot estimate 177 observed post-treatment group-time cells with the configured controls; no target cells were dropped. See csdid-group-time.json and package log." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "SDID", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "sdid: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Matrix completion", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "matrix-completion: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "horizontal-ridge: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Multisynth (cohort-averaged)", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "multisynth-cohort: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Multisynth (individual)", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "multisynth-individual: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." } ], "adapter_sha256": { "validate_template.py": "9c8cc9bb42c9d4eb4f48bfa0a6ee09498fe83516d08aa9f26a49c21c4686618a", "mtgpax_worker.py": "7279b1b2aaa3f5909cd39ac1964d2e9c75907219011fe661a015511131affa85", "csdid_general.py": "07619c3b3dfee796ae9e4842afdbc6e367a74cece254ede73f7c403dfc924f6d", "runner.py": "58547dcbff39ff9f3c439b6db688064bd9e5f19237ca1cae4e68b0c77dde1096", "matrix_inputs.py": "3f675276f9022147996dd5b62762721be2dd436d5db171491a286b05628176ae", "csdid_model.py": "b9fd5536d4886e99a707d2b162db5b11da3ff463930eca5b7590d27500096a3f", "multisynth_model.R": "3ae0740c5b75b14f563dacc9961688e8286655866a6b435045a3ef6f453c1604", "csdid_streaming.py": "378198e98c44bd46862601bdcb514b19d9ea4038cddc38dad7fdba9b0aa0216b", "multisynth_sparse.R": "f9ab3d8d7f7b52a79ccd694c7173f626276a0830f23bb79e527c88c0f0292540", "matrix_models.py": "dc7188bf9bf709f0803169dfc3b1198e8b9d2b79d5904ebc5f010a48edde2ee2", "matrix_worker.py": "c70d8461b3cd9c702154ea38ff99ff31fc9daec8620914e6d5b49d3126ce6312", "csdid_aggregations.py": "cbed0fb13450d9398f9a59d53dbfdf8e275a74daa01158c38c0f3396a3e8c6ee", "bootstrap_matrix.py": "a55b171313d43a703063c87e668021b75eb3153fa30795b9ae3d9e2721d9b9d0", "eligibility.py": "f0eb686ff3f13e89c8f3d85f49890601c4a7f9a611a2938753be599b8ceac9a6" } } }