{ "paper": { "rank": 2, "paper_id": "aeraej-224", "title": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "authors": "Rudi Rocha; Claudio Ferraz; Rodrigo R. Soares", "year": 2017, "journal": "American Economic Journal: Applied Economics", "doi": "10.1257/app.20150532", "package_bytes": 144148, "source_specification": "Table 6" }, "mapping": { "paper_id": "aeraej-224", "match": false, "outcome": "sh_lit", "treatment": "policy", "unit": "cod72", "time": "year", "cluster": "cod72", "mutate": { "policy": "as.integer(year >= 1920 & settlement == 1)" }, "exclude_terms": [ "IyeaXset_1920", "IyeaXset_1940" ], "benchmark_term": "IyeaXset_1940", "note": "Source target is the 1940 settlement interaction. The comparison averages both post-settlement waves; all 16 baseline-by-wave controls are retained." }, "status": "estimated", "source_fit": { "formula": "list(linear = sh_lit ~ y1920 + y1940 + IyeaXset_1920 + IyeaXset_1940 + Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920 + Iyea_geo_long_72_1920 + Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920 + Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920 + Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920 + Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940 + Iyea_geo_long_72_1940 + Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940 + Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940 + Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940 + Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920 + Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920 + Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920 + Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940 + Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940 + Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940, fixef = ~cod72)", "coefficients": { "y1920": 0.493499519710237, "y1940": 0.736956242186707, "IyeaXset_1920": 0.0410283470913605, "IyeaXset_1940": 0.0683807582287613, "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920": 0.0376031660750257, "Iyea_geo_long_72_1920": -0.0124926648151538, "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920": -0.0142355564791679, "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920": -0.000554881198257762, "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920": -0.0117512925417312, "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940": 0.0833819212800779, "Iyea_geo_long_72_1940": -0.0353750088980639, "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940": -0.0221843218260943, "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940": -0.00103037144791797, "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940": 0.0301426007362894, "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920": -0.483315675450724, "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920": 0.234345764499024, "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920": -0.106864675028817, "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940": 1.08474440811206, "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940": 0.261549622357079, "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940": -0.107310144090145 }, "se": { "y1920": 0.69798802885275, "y1940": 0.771538206306592, "IyeaXset_1920": 0.0242194113944283, "IyeaXset_1940": 0.0307512692411242, "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920": 0.0230990576839866, "Iyea_geo_long_72_1920": 0.00974076273371874, "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920": 0.00625945658099991, "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920": 0.000209636006154418, "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920": 0.0332266146438472, "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940": 0.0264782335035564, "Iyea_geo_long_72_1940": 0.0126106103568247, "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940": 0.00797143060319474, "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940": 0.000250357566557852, "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940": 0.0433100210481083, "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920": 0.783738587439888, "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920": 0.124286518019975, "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920": 0.079586860035697, "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940": 1.05132639860136, "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940": 0.165392436003474, "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940": 0.0913427584153442 }, "n": 264 }, "source_check": { "source_term": "IyeaXset_1940", "source_beta": 0.0683807582287613, "template_source_sample_beta": 0.05470455266012069, "template_source_sample_n": 264, "template_source_sample_se": 0.026346627767709477, "same_point_specification": false, "dropped_missing_identifiers": 0, "controls": { "x001": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920", "x002": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1920", "x003": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920", "x004": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920", "x005": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920", "x006": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940", "x007": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1940", "x008": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940", "x009": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940", "x010": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940", "x011": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920", "x012": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920", "x013": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920", "x014": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940", "x015": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940", "x016": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940" }, "absolute_coefficient_difference": 0.01367620556864061 }, "settings": { "slug": "aeraej-224", "specification_id": "aeraej-224-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 6", "study": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "citation": "Rudi Rocha; Claudio Ferraz; Rodrigo R. Soares (2017). https://doi.org/10.1257/app.20150532", "description": "Source target is the 1940 settlement interaction. The comparison averages both post-settlement waves; all 16 baseline-by-wave controls are retained.", "data": "analyses/new-library/tranche50/aeraej-224/panel.parquet", "unit": "unit", "time": "time", "cluster": "cluster", "covariates": [ "x001", "x002", "x003", "x004", "x005", "x006", "x007", "x008", "x009", "x010", "x011", "x012", "x013", "x014", "x015", "x016" ], "time_fe": null, "allow_repeated_cells": false, "period_values": [ 1872, 1920, 1940 ], "period_step": 1, "latest_cohort_control": true, "reversal_policy": "drop_post_untreated", "test_mode": "classical", "post_weighting": "observations", "display_window": [ -10, 10 ], "labels": { "y": "sh_lit", "d": "policy", "unit": "cod72", "time": "year", "cluster": "cod72", "x001": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920", "x002": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1920", "x003": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920", "x004": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920", "x005": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920", "x006": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940", "x007": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1940", "x008": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940", "x009": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940", "x010": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940", "x011": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920", "x012": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920", "x013": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920", "x014": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940", "x015": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940", "x016": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940" } }, "options": { "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche50/aeraej-224/results", "timeout_seconds": 300 }, "comparison": { "schema": "expensive-replication-v1", "config": { "outcomes": [ "y" ], "treatments": [ "d" ], "unit": "unit", "time": "time", "cluster": "cluster", "covariates": [ "x001", "x002", "x003", "x004", "x005", "x006", "x007", "x008", "x009", "x010", "x011", "x012", "x013", "x014", "x015", "x016" ], "baseline_by_time": [], "weight": null, "period_step": 1, "period_values": [ 1872, 1920, 1940 ], "display_window": [ -10, 10 ], "seed": 20261008, "panelview_max_units": 100, "test_mode": "classical", "test_horizon": null, "post_horizon": null, "post_weighting": "observations", "sample_query": null, "reversal_policy": "drop_post_untreated", "labels": { "y": "sh_lit", "d": "policy", "unit": "cod72", "time": "year", "cluster": "cod72", "x001": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1920", "x002": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1920", "x003": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1920", "x004": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1920", "x005": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1920", "x006": "Iyea_geo_lat_72_1940", "x007": "Iyea_geo_long_72_1940", "x008": "Iyea_geo_altitude_72_1940", "x009": "Iyea_geo_distk_72_1940", "x010": "Iyea_geo_solo_slat_72_1940", "x011": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1920", "x012": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1920", "x013": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1920", "x014": "Iyea_sh_foreign72_1940", "x015": "Iyea_sh_slaves72_1940", "x016": "Iyea_sh_child_school72_1940" }, "allow_repeated_cells": false, "time_fe": null, "unit_fe": null, "frequency_weights": false, "source_sd": null, "require_never_control_periods": false, "latest_cohort_control": true, "slug": "aeraej-224", "specification_id": "aeraej-224-source", "source_specification_id": "Table 6", "study": "Human Capital Persistence and Development", "citation": "Rudi Rocha; Claudio Ferraz; Rodrigo R. Soares (2017). https://doi.org/10.1257/app.20150532", "description": "Source target is the 1940 settlement interaction. The comparison averages both post-settlement waves; all 16 baseline-by-wave controls are retained.", "data": "analyses/new-library/tranche50/aeraej-224/panel.parquet", "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche50/aeraej-224/results" }, "options": { "output_dir": "analyses/new-library/tranche50/aeraej-224/results", "timeout_seconds": 300 }, "source": { "file": "panel.parquet", "bytes": 27659, "sha256": "ac4f135ab21aff3c04e71aa2a2f5f84d7aaf98ae3ab8ce756f09eab2fc5bdf6e" }, "regressions": { "y__d": { "sample": { "outcome": "y", "treatment": "d", "source_rows": 264, "source_sd": 0.1588339591658798, "rows": 264, "units": 88, "clusters": 88, "treated_units": 19, "never_treated_units": 69, "treated_cohorts": 1, "latest_cohort_control_index": null, "unique_unit_period_cells": 264, "unsupported_prediction_rows_removed": 0, "rows_without_never_control_time_fe_removed": 0, "initially_treated_units_removed": 0, "post_adoption_untreated_rows_removed": 0, "units_without_minus_one_removed": 0, "additional_rows_removed": 0 }, "estimates": [ { "method": "Static TWFE", "estimate": 0.34441345507851656, "se": 0.165875281999324, "pvalue": 0.040813143138033754, "lower": 0.014718370865737684, "upper": 0.6741085392912954 }, { "method": "Dynamic TWFE", "estimate": 0.34441345507851673, "se": 0.16621623874552902, "pvalue": 0.04121833326787091, "lower": 0.014040682413317074, "upper": 0.6747862277437164 }, { "method": "BJS / did2s", "estimate": 0.34964658948981253, "se": 0.1736745086345657, "pvalue": 0.047181651908287256, "lower": 0.004449697826837129, "upper": 0.6948434811527879 }, { "method": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "estimate": 0.34441345507851673, "se": 0.16621623874552902, "pvalue": 0.04121833326787091, "lower": 0.014040682413317074, "upper": 0.6747862277437164 } ], "event_studies": { "Dynamic TWFE": [ { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.25830966694320323, "se": 0.15248257691002756, "pvalue": 0.09383739658238438, "lower": -0.04476596572121, "upper": 0.5613852996076165 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.4305172432138303, "se": 0.1936063887257491, "pvalue": 0.028760766953510826, "lower": 0.04570358161397847, "upper": 0.8153309048136821 } ], "BJS / did2s": [ { "event_time": -1, "estimate": 1.0225738384705389e-16, "se": 1.3135537712533796e-10, "pvalue": 0.9999993806460122, "lower": -2.610829331481935e-10, "upper": 2.6108313766296116e-10 }, { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.27419744809537433, "se": 0.15980274640299338, "pvalue": 0.08974879637921036, "lower": -0.04342781407589341, "upper": 0.591822710266642 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.42509573088425073, "se": 0.20284226317825105, "pvalue": 0.03901469718264151, "lower": 0.021924768734889133, "upper": 0.8282666930336123 } ], "Sun\u2013Abraham": [ { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.25830966694320323, "se": 0.15248257691002756, "pvalue": 0.09383739658238438, "lower": -0.04476596572121, "upper": 0.5613852996076165 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.4305172432138303, "se": 0.1936063887257491, "pvalue": 0.028760766953510826, "lower": 0.04570358161397847, "upper": 0.8153309048136821 } ] }, "target": { "event_times": [ 0, 1 ], "weights": [ 0.5, 0.5 ], "weighting": "observations" }, "checks": { "did2s_vs_direct_imputation_max_post_difference": 4.3298697960381105e-14, "package_aggregate_vs_estimable_cell_weights": null }, "inference": { "standard_errors": "Cluster-robust; did2s uses two-stage covariance", "confidence_intervals": "Pointwise t, clusters minus one degrees of freedom" }, "f_test": { "status": "not_identified", "pvalue": null, "reason": "Only one treated cohort remains on the common supported sample." } } }, "alternative_models": { "y__d": [ { "method": "CS-DID", "class": "csdid.att_gt.ATTgt", "package": { "csdid": "0.4.2", "drdid": "1.1.6" }, "parameters": { "est_method": "dr", "covariate_basis": "cell-specific rank-reduced column space", "control_group": "notyettreated", "xformla": "y ~ 1 + x0 + x1 + x2 + x3 + x4 + x5 + x6 + x7 + x8 + x9 + x10 + x11 + x12 + x13 + x14 + x15", "panel": true, "effective_panel": true, "allow_unbalanced_panel": true, "weights_name": "weight", "fix_weights": null, "base_period": "universal", "clustervar": "cluster", "aggregate": "dynamic", "faster_mode": true }, "data_structure": "panel", "aggregations": { "summaries": [ { "typec": "dynamic", "aggregation": "Native CS-DID dynamic", "matches_treated_unit_year_target": false, "estimate": 0.4444749047255976, "se": 0.17934128752114104, "lower": 0.09297244024311851, "upper": 0.7959773692080767 }, { "typec": "simple", "aggregation": "Native CS-DID simple", "matches_treated_unit_year_target": false, "estimate": 0.4444749047255976, "se": 0.17934128752114104, "lower": 0.09297244024311851, "upper": 0.7959773692080767 }, { "typec": "group", "aggregation": "Native CS-DID group", "matches_treated_unit_year_target": false, "estimate": 0.4444749047255976, "se": 0.17934128752114104, "lower": 0.09297244024311851, "upper": 0.7959773692080767 }, { "typec": "treated_cells", "aggregation": "Observed treated observations, configured weights", "matches_treated_unit_year_target": true, "weight_sum": 38.0, "post_cells": 2, "estimate": 0.4444749047255976, "se": 0.17934128752114104, "lower": 0.09297244024311851, "upper": 0.7959773692080767 } ], "same_group_time_effects": true, "additional_covariates": [ "x0", "x1", "x2", "x3", "x4", "x5", "x6", "x7", "x8", "x9", "x10", "x11", "x12", "x13", "x14", "x15" ] }, "estimate": 0.4444749047255976, "se": 0.17934128752114104, "lower": 0.09297244024311851, "upper": 0.7959773692080767, "event_study": [ { "event_time": -1, "estimate": 0.0, "se": null, "lower": null, "upper": null, "relative_to_minus_one": 0.0, "n": 0.0 }, { "event_time": 0, "estimate": 0.2771937748864325, "se": 0.14718707438425963, "lower": -0.011287589896534334, "upper": 0.5656751396693993, "relative_to_minus_one": 0.2771937748864325, "n": 19.0 }, { "event_time": 1, "estimate": 0.6117560345647627, "se": 0.22847209663661416, "lower": 0.16395895368464408, "upper": 1.0595531154448814, "relative_to_minus_one": 0.6117560345647627, "n": 19.0 } ], "group_time_estimates": [ { "group": 2, "year": 1, "att": 0.0, "se": null, "event_time": -1, "mass": 0.0 }, { "group": 2, "year": 2, "att": 0.2771937748864325, "se": 0.14718707438425963, "event_time": 0, "mass": 19.0 }, { "group": 2, "year": 3, "att": 0.6117560345647627, "se": 0.2284720966366141, "event_time": 1, "mass": 19.0 } ], "treated_cell_att": 0.4444749047255976, "treated_cell_se": 0.17934128752114104, "checks": { "input_rows": 264, "retained_rows": 264, "all_observed_post_cells_estimated": true, "dynamic_cluster_se_error": 0.0 }, "target": "Equal average of nonnegative native CS-DID event-time effects", "donor_rule": "notyettreated", "inference": "Configured-cluster analytical influence-function intervals; observed-cell ratio includes estimated weight-share uncertainty", "warnings": [ "Be aware that there are some small groups in your dataset.\n Check groups: 2.", "No pre-treatment periods available for the Wald pre-test of parallel trends. The pre-test will not be reported." ], "seconds": 0.03205545898526907, "status": "estimated" }, { "method": "SDID", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "sdid: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Matrix completion", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "matrix-completion: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Horizontal ridge", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "horizontal-ridge: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Multisynth (cohort-averaged)", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "multisynth-cohort: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "method": "Multisynth (individual)", "status": "unsupported", "reason": "multisynth-individual: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." } ] }, "combined_table": [ { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Static TWFE", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.34441345507851656, "SE": 0.165875281999324, "Aggregation": "Coefficient", "Event study": "No", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Dynamic TWFE", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.34441345507851673, "SE": 0.16621623874552902, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "BJS / did2s", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.34964658948981253, "SE": 0.1736745086345657, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Sun\u2013Abraham", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.34441345507851673, "SE": 0.16621623874552902, "Aggregation": "observations", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "CS-DID", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.4444749047255976, "SE": 0.17934128752114104, "Aggregation": "Equal post-event times", "Event study": "Yes", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "CS-DID (treated cells)", "Estimate (SDs)": 0.4444749047255976, "SE": 0.17934128752114104, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "Same CS-DID path", "Status": "estimated", "Note": "" }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "SDID", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "sdid: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Matrix completion", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "matrix-completion: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Horizontal ridge", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "horizontal-ridge: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Multisynth (cohort-averaged)", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "multisynth-cohort: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." }, { "Outcome / treatment": "y__d", "Estimator": "Multisynth (individual)", "Estimate (SDs)": null, "SE": null, "Aggregation": "Treated cells", "Event study": "No", "Status": "unsupported", "Note": "multisynth-individual: this adapter does not implement covariate adjustment; controls retained." } ], "adapter_sha256": { "validate_template.py": "9c8cc9bb42c9d4eb4f48bfa0a6ee09498fe83516d08aa9f26a49c21c4686618a", "mtgpax_worker.py": "7279b1b2aaa3f5909cd39ac1964d2e9c75907219011fe661a015511131affa85", "csdid_general.py": "07619c3b3dfee796ae9e4842afdbc6e367a74cece254ede73f7c403dfc924f6d", "runner.py": "3d6f87d28c1a24f0efe21b6d9b06d77866b0d16abcfdaaaef47465cc9cc1078e", "matrix_inputs.py": "3f675276f9022147996dd5b62762721be2dd436d5db171491a286b05628176ae", "csdid_model.py": "b9fd5536d4886e99a707d2b162db5b11da3ff463930eca5b7590d27500096a3f", "multisynth_model.R": "3ae0740c5b75b14f563dacc9961688e8286655866a6b435045a3ef6f453c1604", "csdid_streaming.py": "378198e98c44bd46862601bdcb514b19d9ea4038cddc38dad7fdba9b0aa0216b", "multisynth_sparse.R": "f9ab3d8d7f7b52a79ccd694c7173f626276a0830f23bb79e527c88c0f0292540", "matrix_models.py": "dc7188bf9bf709f0803169dfc3b1198e8b9d2b79d5904ebc5f010a48edde2ee2", "csdid_aggregations.py": "cbed0fb13450d9398f9a59d53dbfdf8e275a74daa01158c38c0f3396a3e8c6ee", "bootstrap_matrix.py": "a55b171313d43a703063c87e668021b75eb3153fa30795b9ae3d9e2721d9b9d0", "eligibility.py": "f0eb686ff3f13e89c8f3d85f49890601c4a7f9a611a2938753be599b8ceac9a6" } } }